Author Topic: Struggling with decision  (Read 27787 times)

Brigid

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 793
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #30 on: January 24, 2006, 05:30:27 PM »
Plucky,
I agree with what mum has said about what your children can learn in a positive sense from you making the decision to leave their father.  It will never be an easy decision and there is going to be fallout of some sort, but I do believe the long term benefits will outweigh the short term anxieties.

My children watched their mother crumble into a puddle of devastation when their father suddenly wanted to end our marriage.  I'm sure some of that scared them and they probably wondered if I would ever be the same or happy again.  They watched me work my way through hours of therapy, while still supporting everything they did, still decorating the house for the holidays, taking them away on vacations, and trying as best I could to present a happy face, while doing my best to not talk badly about the man who had abandoned me/us.  They have seen me sell our family home, buy and make a new home for the three of us and handle most things on my own.  Through much of that, I was sad and angry, but kept that from them as much as possible (although quite often the anger gave me the energy I needed to keep going).

They now see a happy, healthy mom who has survived and conquered her fear of being alone.  Who has proven that she can face adversity and be victorious.  Who made sure that we were well taken care of financially and their educations were secure.  I am proud of what I have demonstrated for them over the last 2 1/2 years and I believe those are life lessons that they will appreciate forever more. 

My therapist told me many times that once I had my feet back on the ground and was able to consider a new relationship, that there was a chance for my children to see what a real, adult love relationship should look like.   I believe that that is now the legacy I am giving my children when they see how happy I am with my bf and how much they like him as a person.  My kids understand that their father is a big child who is irresponsible and undependable.  They also see his nearly 3 year affair with a married woman as really icky, and that too is a life lesson.

I believe that things happen for a reason.  Like mum, my life has taken some bad turns, but I'll never regret my 2 beautiful children and how they came into my life.  Perhaps the relationship I am now in will not last forever, but then again, maybe it will.  Faith and hope have gotten me this far and I'm just going to keep hanging on to that.

Blessings,

Brigid

mum

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1036
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #31 on: January 24, 2006, 09:13:44 PM »
Bless you, Brigid. I had tears in my eyes reading your post. Your strength and grace are inspirational.

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13616
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #32 on: January 24, 2006, 10:44:23 PM »
Brigid,
I am so glad for your achievement and moved by your confidence and faith.

Question for you: do you believe a middle-aged woman can later model marital (or partner-al) happiness and for a sad adult daughter already (in her case) very scarred by divorce?

IOW, if I turn up a good relationship sometime between now and age 60, is there a chance it'll help my daughter, or is her train too far down the track?

Hopalong
"That'll do, pig, that'll do."

Healing&Hopeful

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 645
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #33 on: January 25, 2006, 02:33:33 AM »
Brigid,
I am so glad for your achievement and moved by your confidence and faith.

Question for you: do you believe a middle-aged woman can later model marital (or partner-al) happiness and for a sad adult daughter already (in her case) very scarred by divorce?

IOW, if I turn up a good relationship sometime between now and age 60, is there a chance it'll help my daughter, or is her train too far down the track?

Hopalong

Mum & Bridgid

I loved reading your stories.... I am always so inspired by the strength of people on here, and love to read how people can move on in their lives.

Plucky.... "And every person who writes something touches my heart."  This is lovely Plucky.  I'm sending you much strength at this time.  I think to post that you are struggling with this decision is a huge step because it brings it to life, makes it more real.

Hoppy.... As someone with divorced parents, IMO all I've ever wanted to see for both of my bio parents is that they were happy.  I've always grown up thinking they were happier apart than together.

I believe there is a chance for everyone to have a happy and good relationship, whatever their age.  You've said a couple of times about your daughter's "train being too far down the track".  As she is only 25, in my personal opinion, I think she's got a long way to go before her train is too far down the track.

One thing that struck me from your post was "if I turn up a good relationship".  I was intrigued by this.... makes it all your responsibility.  I feel the secret is to believe that you deserve to be loved and respected.  I feel this self belief helps others to treat you as you should be treated.

Also, one last thing.... I've never found a good man when I've been looking.... when I've stopped looking and lived to enjoy myself, been happy with myself, then bam... a cracking blokey pops into my life.  :lol:

Take care all

H&H xx
Here's a little hug for u
To make you smilie while ur feeling blue
To make u happy if you're sad
To let u know, life ain't so bad
Now I've given a hug to u
Somehow, I feel better too!
Hugs r better when u share
So pass one on & show u care

2224Jessica

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 56
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #34 on: January 25, 2006, 03:35:14 AM »
Hi plucky,
I have two small children and it's very difficult at the best of times let alone if you have to deal with a husband that won't help. My husband does consider my feelings and helps me when I need him.  My advice would be if he consistantly shows selfish behaviour and doesn't want to consider your feelings and views on this, I think counselling is the way to go. If this doesn't work and he chooses to not work with you on the marriage then maybe there are choices you can consider. Maybe a trial separation, living apart but still having a relationship. Building on respect, teamwork etc.
My opinion is to do everything possible you can do to make this work on your side and then if he doesn't change, you know that you've done everything and you can leave knowing that you tried your best and there is no guilt.
I also think that you know your own gut and sometimes that gut feeling is what leads you to the right descision.
I really feel for you and this must be a really hard time for you. Make sure you nurture yourself during this time and maybe go on a few nice day outs with the children just the three of you. You'll be amazed at how it feels when you enjoy the look of joy on your childrens faces. Remember that you are valuable and you deserve respect and consideration. Ultimately whatever the outcome, you know that you can choose to have a happy life and that one person cannot take your dignity, uniqueness ect away and ultimately he has to make the choice whether he's going to start respecting and working on the marriage and friendship with you. If he refuses then there is your choice.
All the best Plucky, we are here for you.
Jessica :)

Brigid

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 793
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #35 on: January 25, 2006, 08:38:13 AM »
Mum,
I'm glad I could inspire you for a change.  You have certainly been a role model for me since I started posting here nearly a year ago.

Hoppy,

Quote
Question for you: do you believe a middle-aged woman can later model marital (or partner-al) happiness and for a sad adult daughter already (in her case) very scarred by divorce?

Yes, I have to believe that it is never too late to be a positive role model for your children.  Keep in mind that your daughter is still observing a mom who is struggling to right her ship.  This may still be affecting how she is dealing with life and how much you are able to help her with that.  I am certainly not trying to lay any guilt trips at your feet as I know you are doing the best you can with a difficult situation, but who knows what could happen if she saw you find a happy complete relationship that would help you gain the strength to help her with her issues.  Or perhaps it would give you the strength for a tough love stance which would require her to take responsibility for her own behaviors.

She is still a very young adult with a lot of life left to live.  Many of us on this board made some very stupid decisions and bad choices when we were that age.  I realize she is dealing with a bit more than that, but with good therapy and medicinal management, she does have hope of a full future.

You are overwhelmed by all that you are required to manage right now.  It is hard to have a positive outlook under those circumstances, but if you are serious about wanting to begin a journey to find a healthy relationship, that is a place to start.  As my therapist told me many times, you cannot find a healthy partner until you are healthy yourself.  I also agree with H & H that it quite often happens when you are not looking, but at our age, you do need to be a bit more proactive than folks in their 20's and 30's.  You are obviously a very bright, sensitive, intuitive and beautiful on the inside (can't speak to the outside) woman.  There are men out there who would be honored to have you in their life and could give you the love, caring and attention that you deserve.  Faith, hope and a bit of initiative can help you to find them. 

Many blessings,

Brigid

Sela

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1273
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #36 on: January 25, 2006, 10:35:48 AM »
Hiya Plucky:
 
Quote
I wonder what will become of my H after the divorce.

I wonder what will become of you if there is no divorce.  Who can you effect change in/for?

Quote
At one point I thought he would just drink himself to death, or catch something from a prostitute.

I had the exact same thoughts when I was struggling, as you are, to decide.  Once I decided that those would be his choices, nothing to do with me......I let go of worrying about it.  If he decided to rot....he would do so with or without me.

Quote
  But now I think he will be fine.  All his pathetic posturing was just for control.

Bet you're right!  But if he isn't fine?

Do you feel responsible for him/his behaviour/what he chooses/how fine he is?
Can you really change anything for him?

Not up to you Plucky!  Not your stuff!  You can't fix him or change him or make him fine or not fine.
You can do those things for yourself, if you need/want/decide to.

Quote
I love you guys.

Plucky you seem like a very loving person.  You deserve love in your life.....whether it be from your kids and friends, or in a relationship with a mate.  You deserved love because you ARE lovable and loving.   Be kind to yourself.

Life in the dead zone sucks.  It's survival and it is possible, people do it all the time, for years and years and years, but it still sucks.   Take heart!  Life after emerging from that crypt is peaceful, comfortable and enjoyable!   It too is possible .....doable.......not nearly as scary as staying in place that drains life from you.
Both are choices eh?

I'm not sure what the last straw was for me but once it was broken......I had nothing to grasp.  I had to go get myself away from that pile of a mess.  Staying married or divorcing for the children's sake was not an option for me.  I knew I'd resent doing so, eventually.  I had to decide for me.  I had to save me......first.  Then......I was soooo much more able to do my best for them.

(((((((Plucky))))))

Sela

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13616
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #37 on: January 25, 2006, 04:01:01 PM »
While I'm chugging along a parallel track wondering about a new relationship one day, your Decision stories remind me life's not SOOO bad without a mate!

But regardless, thanks H & H, for pointing out it wouldn't be ALL my job either to find or ensure the success of a good relationship. I forgot! It takes two people, who knew?

And Brigid, thanks very much for the encouraging words. I think I'll go marry Leo Kottke. Siggghhh.  :)

Meanwhile, back to you, plucky Plucky...thinking of you.
Sela, the Dead Zone is such a painfully perfect phrase.

Here's to faith in new life.

Hopalong
"That'll do, pig, that'll do."

Brigid

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 793
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #38 on: January 25, 2006, 05:48:56 PM »
Plucky,

Quote
I wonder what will become of my H after the divorce.  At one point I thought he would just drink himself to death, or catch something from a prostitute.  But now I think he will be fine.

I forgot that I had wanted to respond to this statement (thanks Sela for your posting).  Aside from how it will affect your children, what does it matter?  I also thought those same things about my ex, even though he made the decision to leave.  I actually worried more about depression taking over and the potential for suicide, but I no longer have those worries. 

I do believe that he will be a sad and lonely man and be searching for something to make him happy for the rest of his life.  If he will ever understand the extent to which he damaged the relationships in his life--with friends, family, our children--I don't know.  I don't think he can allow himself to look at any of that realistically.  It would only add to the very low opinion that he really has of himself and he can't go there.  Everyone that knows the story of our break-up, sees him as a pathetic loser, who gave up the only good thing he had going for him. 

He saw me as the weight around his neck that kept him from enjoying life.  In reality, it was quite the opposite and without him dragging me down, I am enjoying life more than I ever thought possible.  I have found the courage to try new things and have exciting new life experiences and feel a joyeux de vivre that is wonderful.  He sits in a bar with a couple of other single people night after night waiting for his girlfriend to leave her husband.  I don't think he will be fine, but the bottom line is that it is not my problem and I don't care.  As Sela said, he has to save himself and you have to save yourself.  I'm just so happy to not have that third child in my life anymore who was waaayyy more work than my other two children combined.

Brigid 

Plucky

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 800
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #39 on: January 25, 2006, 08:14:50 PM »
Quote
When you've been only in abusive relationships, you CAN'T imagine what a loving relationship feels like --
Hi Marta,
Actually, I have had loving relationships.  Of course, I ran like hell from this unaccustomed lack of drama and the possibility to envision a future with the person.  If I could imagine a relationship after this, it could be with someone I knew before, a la Mum.   But I don't think that is realistic.

I imagine a great relationship with my children where I spend lots of time and am not stressed, where I can form friendships with other adults and their children, and we can have more structure and traditions and family customs.  Nearly everything I want to do now, I have to drag my H behind like a beached whale.   

Plucky
« Last Edit: January 26, 2006, 01:25:23 AM by Plucky »

Plucky

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 800
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #40 on: January 26, 2006, 01:49:03 AM »
Quote
No one is meant to live half way.

This is a great phrase Mum, did you invent it?

Life in the dead zone.  Yup, that's my address.

I think I sort of get what Marta and others are saying.  What do I want, in positive terms, not as an absence of what I don't want.  Although what I don't want is definitely driving things and I think that is legit.

Mainly I want relationships with others.   Not romantic. I want friends.  Buddies.  People to talk to, listen to, open up with, trust, make plans with.  I want my children to have a community.

As nothing as it is, at least I can count on my H to be there.    When it is over, I know I will have to work through the worst of it alone.  I don't have any friends and my family will be less than helpful if I tell them anything.

I want to be able to support my children through this and I hope I will have the strength.  That is what I am afraid of.

Plucky

Portia

  • Guest
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #41 on: January 26, 2006, 07:46:55 AM »
Dear Plucky, it's a biggie, sorry. I agree with you about “Although what I don't want is definitely driving things and I think that is legit.”  I think it is legit too. You have to clean out all the crap before you see the possibilities for new stuff. Even in a wardrobe. All the clutter crowds your mind.

This is Plucky’s manifesto! :D It’s grrrreat! :D
Mainly I want relationships with others.   Not romantic.
(applause!! Cheers! Even……*pom poms*)

I want friends.  Buddies.  People to talk to, listen to, open up with, trust, make plans with. 
Yeah! This is a great goal. Where are all those safe people?? It’s not easy, nothing ever is, but it’s worth making the time and huge effort to go out and find those 3D people. I’ve found one or two. To me, they’re a bit weird, they have their own stuff and they’re not ‘perfect’ friends. But I like them (and I’m nowhere near perfect either). Just finding one or two things in common is a start. These are people who we don’t have to live with too!

I want my children to have a community.
Do they already have friends? Do those friends visit you? Can they visit more often? Do you like their moms? Do they visit their friends? Etc etc what are the opportunities for simple contact and communication right now? However small? Tiny changes make big impacts. Asking someone in for a coffee. Having kids to dinner. Anything to change the routine.

Nobody has to be alone. I thought I had to do everything myself. I don’t. It’s a hard lesson to learn. It means giving up a tiny bit of control, and that’s hard. I like being in control, having everything just so, having the stuff I want clean, clean. Having stuff tidy. Having an ordered life so that if anything goes wrong, I have mental space to deal with it. This attitude of mine is all a result of a crap childhood. It’s not healthy. It’s not optimistic, loving, spontaneous, happy. It’s a coping mechanism. Because at heart I believe that life is antagonistic, is to be survived and battled through (also not a healthy outlook, result of….blah). Okay yes life is difficult and things will go wrong and there’s zero we can do about the earthquake that’s about to happen etc. (Gosh I’m ranting :shock:!!) BUT…..allowing things to get a little out of control is freeing. It opens up new possibilities. New ways of thinking and seeing the world. Rant over.

Some practical chat, I hope.

You said:
Every time my H does something nice, I feel guilty that I am planning to leave.

Yeah, we’re conditioned to feel guilty for wanting something for ourselves. So any scrap that is thrown our way we fawn over and lap up. We feel so pathetically grateful. Well I did. (You know there’s lots of projection in what I’m writing? Good. It’s about me. Don’t take it too personally.  :roll:Haha!)  And then that huge boulder of GUILT descends that says: I AM A BAD PERSON for wanting what I want. I have no right. I’m lucky to have that scrap. It’s a wonder I have anything, I’m sooooo selfish etc etc. This is what Hop pointed out to me – Toxic Shame. Guilt with an added bonus :x. It’s not, “I did something wrong, I feel guilty”, it’s “I feel bad for wanting to leave this man because hey he just did something nice and I must be a Bad Person for not being grateful and putting up with my lot in life.” Plucky: I am a bad person is not guilt. I am a bad person is what your mother taught you. It’s rot. Mind-rot.

It’s all bollocks. It’s our internal childhood programming running in loops. Bad girl! :x :x :x

You are not a bad person.  :D You have no reason to feel guilty.  :D Just because H does something nice doesn’t mean you have to even like it! Let alone feel guilty. You’re worth so much more. This ain’t false praise or just motivational words. You are actually worth more. Your self is all you really have. If you don’t take yourself and your needs and wants seriously, who else will? I’m ranting again. Sorry. Hope you get a laugh or two? Trying to hide a couple in there.

Where was I? Oh yeah, I was going to be practical. Hmm. Went off track I feel. Haha. Oh well. Not perfect, not God. Practical! See if I can hold the thought for longer than an ant’s memory span (apologies to ants there).

You said:
Up until a year ago I did work.  And now we are partly living on my savings from my many decades of work,  so actually I am still providing in a way.  (Why am I throwing this in all of a sudden?  I guess the topic of guilt came up and...)

Holy Cow!!!!!!  :shock: :shock: You have kids, you worked and now you’re spending your savings!!! Still actually providing in some way? Yeah! With that important stuff called money! Pleeeeease don’t put yourself down so much. You’re guilty for not working 40 hours a week, looking after your kids and your h? Are you superwoman????

How many women do you know who get married, have kids and don’t work again until kids leave home/go to college etc? How many women leave all the financial stuff to their hubbies and just spend money as they need/want to? How many people live on so much credit that you wonder how they get to sleep at nights?
Lots.

When he is about to come home, I start to feel tense and frozen.

I lived with that for 6 months. That was enough for me. No kids though, that’s a big difference. I just packed my little beat-up car and drove away. He cried. Ahhhhhh! Big deal. He had a new woman in the flat by the weekend.

As nothing as it is, at least I can count on my H to be there.
Yep, the lump on the couch. Being alone can be a universe better than being with someone you have to eggshell tiptoe around. And who you resent. You resent him. No worries there, I’d resent him. In fact I do resent him :D Free yourself from that. You can. It's doing you no good.

I want to be able to support my children through this and I hope I will have the strength.  That is what I am afraid of.

Please talk more. Exactly what is the worse that could happen? Will you go mad on your own? Start having schizophrenic tendencies? Do you hear voices yet? Do you have obsessional traits? Will you murder your kids and yourself? Have to beg on the street?

I’m being over the top to try and nibble away (nibble nibble like mice at cheese) at the real fear in there. Fear is a bummer. It’s usually about something which is unrelated too. Like being left alone lot by your mom? Or something. Help me out here please. I’m playing a total blinder (is that the right expression??).

Hahaha did I say practical??

Okay, back to topic.

Practical stuff.

Do you wash, dry and iron his shirts?
Do you wash and dry his underwear?
(Do you iron sheets btw? Is there any woman who actually does this?)
Do you cook his food?
Do you collect his clothes for washing etc?

If so: You don’t have to do any of this.

One of the ways to formally separate before a divorce (and this is practised in Law over here) is that the couple stay in the home but live separate lives. They can sleep in the same bed but they do their own washing, ironing and cooking. They do that for 2 years and then get a divorce based on breakdown. I think. Something like that. Whatever. The point is, if you do this stuff now, you’ll need a heap of strength to make changes like this. To have that conversation where you state your new mode of living and he gets to like it or lump it. Not easy :?, but easier than huge dramatic life-changing moves made all at once. Little steps.

Hope my ramble brought a smile or two and maybe some thoughts. ((((plucky))))

Portia

  • Guest
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #42 on: January 26, 2006, 08:27:41 AM »
Nope I ain’t finished. I wish I’d just shut up! :D

Every time my H does something nice,

I feel this is important and deserves more attention. What do I know? Never mind:

Q. What does he actually do that is nice? (Let’s see the reality clearly here. Let’s check with each other and compare ideas, please.)

I feel guilty that I am planning to leave.

Interesting choice of words – that you are planning to leave.

You’re not actually planning to leave. You’re planning to stop being his partner. Difference. It could possibly happen that you both physically leave. Or you stay and he leaves.

But you see it as you leaving him. Abandoning him. Which is a bad thing to do? It takes two to make a reciprocal relationship work.

where does it come from.....

Did your mom ever make you feel guilty for leaving her? For having your own friends, your own life? Not giving her enough attention?

Did you ever feel responsible for your mom’s feelings? Did you ‘make’ her sad, angry, depressed etc?

Keep thinking. Thinking is free! Feelings are just feelings. Not good or bad, just feelings to be examined and understood. Bye for now, P

Marta

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 281
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #43 on: January 26, 2006, 09:00:10 AM »
Portia, you have some really excellent points!

Quote
Up until a year ago I did work.  And now we are partly living on my savings from my many decades of work,  so actually I am still providing in a way.  (Why am I throwing this in all of a sudden?  I guess the topic of guilt came up and...)

Who do you think you are????!!!!!  :shock: :shock: :shock:
Some kind of a superman?

I'd missed this important piece of info. until I saw it quoted in Portia's post. Plucky, you are doing WAY much too much beyond what is your due.  Why do you have to spend away your savings, for it seems like your H is quite well-off, if you don't mind my asking? I am worried that this may besome kind of a strategy by your H to render you completely dependent on hi. Forgive me and ignore if I am of base here -- I am rather paranoid these days.

To me, all that you are doing, and to feel guilt on top of everything else, just doesn't make sense. You and your children are going to NEED your savings, sweetie, so why not keep them for a rainy day?

Quote
Portia:
It’s a coping mechanism.

Please talk more. Exactly what is the worse that could happen?


Seriously seconded. This is exactly what I meant, when we face a difficult situation, we automatically resort to our coping mechanisms. You have to know what your particular variety of coping mechanism is, and try to break out of that. It could be to say that look, x, y, z could happen if I get out so I better stay. Of course it is a as legit a way of dealing with the world as any other, question is not of legitimacy but of making life affirming choices and confronting unfounded fears that are legacy of our N parents. We are only trying to get you to spell out why you think the choice to stay in this particular situation is a preferable one, on what basis, why, in your own mind, not to us necessarily.

I also agree with the second comment by P. What EXACTLY could happen? Put your fears out there one by one on the table and see if they hold up to rational scrutiny. Remember, one of the main characteristics of N offsprings is their distorted world view. One distortion in yours has been noted by many of us--that is your tendency to take on more than your fair share of guilt.

Take care Plucky, I am seeing that pieces are falling in place for you.....




Healing&Hopeful

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 645
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #44 on: January 26, 2006, 09:06:21 AM »
Q. What does he actually do that is nice? (Let’s see the reality clearly here. Let’s check with each other and compare ideas, please.)


I'll help you out on this one Portia..... things my H does which is nice.

Practical things he does:-
He cooks my tea.... he cooks most nights, more often than me anyhow... and then sometimes he'll even wash up as well!
He sometimes does the washing.
He likes doing the ironing!!

Little nice things he does..... (and these are mainly daily things)
He gives me a big hug and kiss when I get in from work.
Tells me I'm his gorgeous sexy wife.
Tells me he loves me.

One thing both of us do is to thank the other for things.... like when he cooks I'll say "Thank you for that, it was lovely"... and he does the same when I cook.  It means we both feel appreciated when we do things for the other.

Ah yes... and money.  Whatever we earn is ours... it's shared equally, if one of us is a bit short, the other will help out.




Here's a little hug for u
To make you smilie while ur feeling blue
To make u happy if you're sad
To let u know, life ain't so bad
Now I've given a hug to u
Somehow, I feel better too!
Hugs r better when u share
So pass one on & show u care