Author Topic: Daughter's Love  (Read 8101 times)

Hops

  • Guest
Re: Losing Daughter's Love
« Reply #30 on: July 03, 2006, 09:44:49 AM »
LoH:
Quote
trying that hard can teach you a lot about yourself. Even if the other person needs space at times. Sooner or later, so long as they're capable of progress, things will change, maybe only an inch at a time. But those inches pile up, in the nicest way.
Thanks so much, LoH. I've got to change, too. But I can report that after the summing-up email I wrote my D (90% love and support, 10% asserting myself, asking for what I need) I have been able to NOT contact her again. I think this is respectful of her obvious need for distance right now. I don't like it, but I'd rather do this than have her feel that our only interactions are out of obligation. It feels wrong to me to have NO sense of obligation to a parent who has tried their best to love and raise you and has never abused you. But maybe that's a generational thing that seems to be changing. At any rate, I have accepted that I can't force it. And if I set her free, maybe she will come back of her own accord. I think she will. I do have to curb my dependency, and that may force me to do some much-needed personal growth I"ve been neglecting.

Plucky, these things are such an enormous gift. I can't thank you adequately (but thank you for saying thanks is voluntary here! I just want to this time for each person because I'm so overwhelmed by the support and caring...it's brought me tears of relief.):
Quote
Maybe coming from your childhood or a marriage is that fear of losing the love of your loved one by making a mistake.  A small mistake.  And this fear had to be confronted every day.  And you had to live with stress and on eggshells.
Yes. Time to let that go.

Quote
But a normal relationship is not destroyed by a single act of, what at worst might have been thoughtlessness.   You cannot possibly destroy the entire relationship with your daughter just by making that sort of comment.
  I needed badly to hear this. And this is incredibly insightful and important:

Quote
remember that whatever you do, you are still teaching her.  If you desperately hound her to reassure you that she still loves you, she is learning that behaviour too.  Just think where and when it might come out.
Thank you so much, Plucky.

Moon, thank you:
Quote
a little not holding on to tight right now would be good for your daughter to see strength in you.So many times gentleness is taken for weakness

Your whole heart helps me heal mine. Thank you for your amazingly loving spirit.

(((((MS))))) --hugs back!

Mum, you are so wise as ever:
Quote
You can only take care of "your side of the street". What she does on her side, is up to her. Yes, letting go of wanting...anything....something different.....is key in getting free of this fear. You won't die without her approval, nor will she die without yours.
Funny how the desperation (added to my underlying anxiety tendencies) really can feel like my emotional survival is at stake. But you're right, nobody's going to die. Thanks. I'm breeaaaaathing.

Hi Beth:
Quote
I think you need to talk to her about this NOW. You should say you have been thinking about it and you would really like to know if she is having problems with it and if you can help her.
Thanks for this. I really don't think I can approach her about her eating issues now. That's what I did a few years ago, and since that time I believe any purging is over. She's pudgy, and I don't believe she is doing it any more. Hasn't for the last two years, I believe. Since she quit smoking I think she's living (and eating) much more healthily. She does have IBS, and I think her stress issues happen for her with her stomach (as mine do with my chest, and other have headaches, etc.) But I think she just focuses on that area of her body, and that's how her anxiety shows. I might be wrong, but I don't believe she is bulimic now. (And don't forget, that's what she raged about--so she would not be receptive to discussing it with me if she were.) As you say, I can't control or force her to help herself. I've pushed therapy so hard it may have backfired, sent her tons of links to local resources, offered to pay for therapy, etc. She knows she can do it if she wants to. And for now, I have given the message that I'm so longer "bailing her out" financially. I said I would pay the small fees involved in her graduate school applications and testing, but that's it.

Hi Write, you said you had neither advice nor wisdom but I thank you for both in abundance:
Quote
You can't make her more mature, you can't make her appreciate the parts of herself which she needs to change, she'll only discover that in time ( as you have, as I have )
You can however keep loving her whilst working on stuff you feel you need to eg boundaries or assertiveness or whatever

And especially:
Quote
The best thing you can do is make a good, happy life for yourself, and be pleased to see her & share it with her when she visits.
I need to choose happiness. And remember to re-choose it. And choose it again. And again.
Thank you.

All of you. This has been caring that goes to the core of me, and I can't express how grateful I am to have found this board, and what comfort it is amid panic or pain to be able to reach out here. And then be so embraced. Unbelievable...but I think I'll believe it!

Much love,
Hops






mum

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1036
Re: Losing Daughter's Love
« Reply #31 on: July 03, 2006, 01:56:31 PM »
Keep the image of her as open and warm in your head and heart while you let her figure it out. Of course she will come back to you...you have never lost her, just as you have never owned her... You loved her/love her. That's enough. And it's enough for you right now to know that. (((((((((((((Hops))))))))))))))) Don't worry (if you are)that you and she will become your mother and you. Not going to happen. Let that go.

Hops

  • Guest
Re: Losing Daughter's Love
« Reply #32 on: July 03, 2006, 02:07:31 PM »
Mum, WOW.

Quote
Don't worry (if you are)that you and she will become your mother and you. Not going to happen. Let that go.

What an incredibly perceptive thing to notice.

I did not know that I was. But when I read your insight it went Bang!
(In a good way.)

thanks thanks!
(((Mum))))

Hops

mum

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1036
Re: Losing Daughter's Love
« Reply #33 on: July 03, 2006, 02:14:17 PM »
I'm not sure where that came from either, Hops. Someimtes I think I just channel energy or something...it's wierd. (You have probably noticed I am not all that smart all the time.)
I'm glad it meant something to you, though, so I guess that's where it came from (from you!) You see, I am not all that wise by myself...it's collective wisdom...I can't take credit for it (I'm referring to the kind words you said about my wisdom on another occassion).

ANewSheriff

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 174
Re: Losing Daughter's Love
« Reply #34 on: July 05, 2006, 03:30:30 PM »
Hi Hops,

It is nice to be back as I have been traveling for some time.  I am sorry to see this post from you, though.  Dadgummit, anyway.  These relationships (mother/daughter and father/son) are so tough.  We live such complicated lives.

Since I am drawing on such little history, it is hard to guess what may be bothering your daughter.  However, 25 is still a very young age and she may still be figuring out much about herself, her life, you and yours, and how all these things fit together.  Perhaps this is some attempt at atonomy?

You are pondering a couple of responses.  Since your gift is in your words, would a note or poem of sorts be appropriate? 

ANewSheriff
 

 
Change the way you see the world and you will change the world.

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13619
Re: Losing Daughter's Love
« Reply #35 on: July 05, 2006, 05:51:46 PM »
Hi, ANS, and thanks...
Actually I did write her last Thursday, and I am not calling or writing until she initiates. I am surprised that I'm at peace about it, but I really am. Below is some of what I sent her:

I am extremely sorry that I made such an insensitive remark when you were here. It just popped out, and I do regret it. I do not ever want to hurt you, rub your nose in anything or replay old misunderstandings. I'm sorry that it happened but I will make mistakes. I hope you'll forgive me. I'll forgive you, always.
 
I have been thinking and realize that all I can control is how I choose to treat you, and telling you how I feel. I love you very much. I am so proud of you. I have enormous respect for your hard work and determination. You have accomplished so much, and I hope you feel it.
 
I am in your corner whatever's happening and whatever you decide to do. I will always be here for you. I hope you'll share now and then what you're thinking of. It's hard to shuffle so many scenarios, isn't it?
 
I would love to hear from you more often. I don't need a response to "info & articles" messages, just the personal ones. I've been feeling lately as though you seem interested only when you want something. That hurt. I'll keep you posted on Grandma--I'd love it if you'd sometimes ask how I am too....

I want to treat you with a new level of adult respect and courtesy, and that is how I also want to be treated. Every single parent and child go through this passage, sometimes it flows and sometimes it's work. But it's worth it. I know we can create a good adult relationship. Respect and caring are a two-way street, and I'm totally committed to this. I also enjoy your company as ever. Nobody else really gets what's goofy. I love your wit and your mind and your affection.
 
You are my favorite human (and menagerie). Next time I'm down...(then I asked her to suggest a wknd that's good for her and I don't care if it's summer or fall, etc.)


She hasn't responded but I wasn't and am not expecting anything. It was probably a little too gushy but I am at peace with it. What may communicate more strength is my not obsessing over her response now...and surprisingly, I'm not. I did my best to communicate what I needed to, and in staying quiet while she takes her time, I hope I'll be giving her the space she needs to grow. My old narcissistic "guru" psychologist friend from work actually showed me again (over the phone...he's moved away) why I do appreciate him. I told him about it all and he was very supportive and perceptive. His blunt talk about her--and me--was strengthening. (I'm happy I don't interact with him every day any more, or in the workplace, but I see why I valued him.) He actually thinks she needs to sort of "hit bottom" in her own life in a way, and that my task is not to get hooked in again. He feels the question she asked me, when we were lolling in my room, was unconciously on her part...a set-up. My response may have hurt her, but on some level he thinks she wants to fight with me, because as long as she can blame me for everything, she doesn't have to face herself. So...to not allow her to be brutal with me, or to use me for money, is actually helping her "hit bottom" in a sense. He thinks I should stay neutral and unhooked when she does get in touch. That if she is hysterical or all seething about something, I need to stay neutral and NOT tell her what to do, just that I will support her in whatever she chooses.

It helped. I am not sure about all of why....but I know I feel I've done the best I can.

Thanks for asking...

Hops
"That'll do, pig, that'll do."

pennyplant

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1067
Re: Losing Daughter's Love
« Reply #36 on: July 05, 2006, 06:50:41 PM »
Hi Hops,

You sound very at peace.  Your letter is loving and honest and it's no wonder you feel satisfied with it.  You have done a great job.  How interesting that your old "N" guru buddy has so much insight.  There is goodness in some of these people, maybe all of them, if only one knows how to approach them without losing oneself completely.  Someone else here, maybe LoH, said there is the same amount of love for Ns, but just from farther away.

It seems like you're working your way up the staircase and now there's some satisfaction along the way too.

Just a wonderful letter, Hops.

Pennyplant
"We all shine on, like the moon, and the stars, and the sun."
John Lennon

ANewSheriff

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 174
Re: Losing Daughter's Love
« Reply #37 on: July 05, 2006, 09:02:33 PM »
Hops,

Thank you for sharing that most personal and very heartfelt letter.  It was well written (no surprise) and I can see why you are at peace after sending this.  Your psychiatrist friend makes some wise assumptions.  If your history is that your daughter scapegoats you for all of her life's ills, then whatever happened may very well have been a subconscious or even semi subconscious set-up. 

If she is angry and resentful she is looking for an outlet for those emotions.  As Forrest Gump said, "Sometimes there just aren't enough rocks."  She knows you are safe, but you have grown a lot emotionally and spiritually so perhaps you are not as easy a target as you may have been in years past.  Perhaps she came at you through the back door - mentally setting up a scenario which would evoke a response so she could justify her anger and confirm her core beliefs.

Whatever the cause, she is fiercely loved by her mother and she will be okay.  Growing up is a very difficult process.  My hunch is that she just needs some time.

ANewSheriff       

Change the way you see the world and you will change the world.

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13619
Re: Losing Daughter's Love
« Reply #38 on: July 05, 2006, 11:17:07 PM »
Penny, ANS, TT--

thank you soooo much.
It was a deep comfort to read your posts about my letter to her.
I hesitated to post it and then thought, they knowit all, why not share how I tried to resolve it?

I'm glad I did.

Support is just a ... word. But I can feel it like strong arms.


thanks again, and love to you...you strong wise women.
Hops
"That'll do, pig, that'll do."

moonlight52

  • Guest
Re: Losing Daughter's Love
« Reply #39 on: July 06, 2006, 02:12:15 AM »
Hops ,
I am sure your daughter will reconnect.

I have had time with my oldest girl where she just was not going to speak to me .
Then before you knew it we reconnected.But it was hurtful .

My oldest daughter finds my gentleness a weakness at times.
But again when I speak to her in what penelopebean calls gentle strength she does respect that.
Its has taken time .Your daughter is younger than my oldest so I am sure just a little time is needed.
When you said in your letter  'I am in your corner " they are words of such protection .

Much Love,
Moon
« Last Edit: July 06, 2006, 04:17:58 AM by moonlight52 »

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13619
Re: Losing Daughter's Love
« Reply #40 on: July 06, 2006, 06:38:14 AM »
THANK you, Moon! ((((((Moon))))

PP: What's interesting about my N-pyschologist friend is that most of his Nism seems very unconscious, but he is also very smart and knows (and says) that he has a very N-istic side. What allows me to keep valuing him as a friend is that he has honestly done fierce battle with this part of himself.

Then again, at times listening to him about that is funny (you supply the accent): "Now, I am going to acquire humility. There, I have done that so fast! Excellent, I am completely happy!"  :)

That's an exaggeration...but anyway, there's a good person in him. He's both greedy and generous, selfish and sweet. I do find it MUCH easier to be long-distance friends though!

Hops
"That'll do, pig, that'll do."

lightofheart

  • Guest
Re: Losing Daughter's Love
« Reply #41 on: July 06, 2006, 09:17:52 AM »
Hops, thank you for sharing your beautiful letter, and the trust in that.

Quote
It helped. I am not sure about all of why....but I know I feel I've done the best I can.

That sounds like peace? Hope that's how it feels, and there's less rattling in your good heart.

imho, you sent her a gift, one long on courage and vulnerability. As much as this estrangement hurts, you still put yourself on the line and reached out. At the risk of sounding too gushy (good company there  :) ), I think you're amazing, Hops. Whatever place your D. is in, I think that letter will give her strength to fall back on, even if she can't respond yet. You told her exactly where your heart is.

Blessings to (((mother and daughter))),

LoH

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13619
Re: Daughter's Love
« Reply #42 on: July 09, 2006, 01:31:52 PM »
After I managed to keep my mouth shut for a week or so, my D sent us an envelope of pictures from her trip with nice captions on the back...  :D  That's contact!

Ordered a book on dealing w/a prickly young adult daughter, and one of the first "rules" it talks about is not to pepper them with questions about their lives. MOI?   :shock:

(Yes.... :oops: )

Will report more when I've read it (I read what I could on Amazon).

Anyway, it feels good. Haven't been obsessing and feel so much better since I'm not crowding her.

My brother is here and so far things are peaceful. I've let go trying to control anything and am just being pleasant and busy. Taking advantage of his visit to run around and do some self-care, just for fun kinds of things. Got my hair cut, did someting stupid to my eyebrows and painted my fingernails. (Unfortunately, every time I do that it looks like a 4 y/o just stuck her fingers in a pot of paint, but it's fun anyway).

And I got flirted with at church this morning!  :shock:  Guy nearly herniated himself trying to find out if I was wearing a wedding ring! Holy moly.

Happy Sunday, all. I'm off to see A Prairie Home Companion with my friend who's got metastasized ovarian cancer and her partner. It will be good to laugh together, as heck, what are the alternatives.

Hugs,
Hops
"That'll do, pig, that'll do."

mountainspring

  • Guest
Re: Daughter's Love
« Reply #43 on: July 09, 2006, 03:11:25 PM »
Hi Hops.... I'm so happy for you.  I think things are going to work out well for you and your daughter.  I remember you were worried about the visit from your brother and I'm glad you're having a good time doing some fun things for yourself while he's here. 

Hey.... do you know him?   :D  Did you flirt back?  :D  Was he nice looking?  :D 

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13619
Re: Daughter's Love
« Reply #44 on: July 09, 2006, 05:22:12 PM »
Thanks, MS! It really has been fun to be nice to myself.

I don't know the flirter, and I'm not sure I flirted back very well, I'm rusty. But I'll see him again so that's nice. He had beautiful eyes, and seemed quite open. Described himself as a loner... It wasn't a long chat though so I ain't gonna fantasize. We shall see.

I did run into my exNbf today for the first time since our relationship ended a year and a half ago. I felt so clear about not being interested in him in the slightest. He waved me over so I was polite and said hello and inquired about his children. He tried to turn on the charm and it felt like BS. Having it feel like BS felt good!

Funny, Nthings I didn't notice before. I simply asked, how are your children doing? And he said oh, fine. Well they're doing spectacularly well, actually. He does this thing where he uses a studied tone of awe in his voice...when he talks about someone else's reponse to his work or when he talks about his kids...but it's a sort of they-are-so-amazing-it's-just-beyond-dazzling kind of thing, rather than straightforward pride and love. There's no warmth in it.

Brrrrrrrr. I do not like him and even though we know people in common I do not want anything more to do with him, ever. I haven't been in a relationship since him. I think that's good, that he was my last N...but I'm still a little bitter (catch myself saying, "that bastard" now and then).

But I'm ON MY WAY to indifference! I actually felt good that I handled myself as I did, no grinning, no fake pleasure. I was not glad to see him and I didn't act like I was. Sounds supid, but that's an achievement for me. I overrode the social programming, and I tell you, sugah, that's raht thick down heah!

Hops
"That'll do, pig, that'll do."