Author Topic: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed  (Read 11733 times)

mjr

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 3
dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« on: April 15, 2007, 08:57:06 PM »
Hi,
I've been lurking a few days to see if my issues apply to this forum - tonight has been tough emotionally so I'd like some feedback if possible.  I don't believe that mother is a Nmom, I'm not sure what label(s) she's earned!

Here's a brief description...

-intrusive into my husband and my lives (asks questions such as "how much money did you pay for the house", "how much is his paycheck", "why do you talk to your friends more than you talk to me", etc...).
-overbearing (buys groceries for us without asking first and then gets angry if I don't come to her house to pick them up, tries to tell me what to do regarding calling lawn care people, cleaning house, etc...).
-jealous of my relationship with my husband, friends. (describes him as dominating and lazy - I think she mainly doesn't like him because he verbally puts her in her place).
-spiteful and negative (says that we will be horrible parents - I'm 8 months pregnant with my first child, says we only care about ourselves and friends because we are moving out of state).
 
On one hand, she is very giving financially - we NEVER ask for anything from her, she proposes a purchase and then persists until she buys it for us (a riding lawn mower, garage doors, clothes, etc...).  As I write this, I see her motives behind the purchases - she is able to force her way actively into our lives.

On the other hand, she is the most negative person that I know.  Granted she has reasons: my only sibling died a little over ten years ago, my father and she have been separated since I was 13 (I'm now close to 40), is retired and has no hobbies.  She has friends she talks with on the phone but never does anything socially with them. Thankfully, she does have siblings that live near and she does things with them on occasion.

I  avoid doing anything/talking with her on the phone because she is so negative and intrusive. I'm sure part of her behavior is due to that I don't want to do things with her - so it's a self-fulfilling prophecy.

She has been especially difficult lately due to major life changes my husband and I are undertaking (as mentioned, I'm pregnant with her first and only grandchild; AND we will be moving five hours away as soon as I can after the baby is okay to travel).

On Friday, she had a doctor's appointment and is furious that I didn't call her that evening (I had dinner plans that night with a friend and had been on a tiresome field trip with my class so I crashed instead of calling). I did call her the next morning at 10:00 - she was fuming and crying and saying how I didn't love her/care about her and that all I cared about was friends and my husband and how horrible we would be to a baby.  Long story short, I told her I don't like to talk to her because she is so negative and doesn't support us emotionally and then hung up. I called her two times today before she answered this evening - still crying and saying she couldn't believe that she had been treated that badly by me and started again on the negative verbal comments towards me, my husband and even her siblings. I told her that I loved her but that I wouldn't talk to her until she was more positive and learned some boundaries and then hung up.

My dilemma:  I call her everyday.  Should I not call her until I hear from her again or should I continue to call and say hello and once the negative begins then say goodbye?

I appreciate your considering this and giving your thoughts.


cats paw

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 440
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #1 on: April 15, 2007, 10:19:20 PM »
Hello, mjr !

  Welcome, and you came to a wonderful place.  I'm new here, too but was a lurker also.  Congratulations on your upcoming little bundle!  My goodness, how I can relate to you and so many others will be able to also.
   First of all, have you clarified what your boundaries are?  What specifically- like his paycheck is open for discussion, what is not, etc.
Have you communicated any of those to her, and have you held the line when she attempts to breach it?  The financial issue was one of the easy ones for me.  I told my mother that my and my husband's finances are our business, and have stayed firm with that despite her repeated attempts to glean information. 
   As far as telling you you will be horrible parents- how have you handled that one?  What would you say to anyone else who daid those things to you?
   
   My mother is intrusive also, and has accused me of being uncaring, asks why I do X or Y with A or Z but not her.  I love her, but she's very hard to like.  I'm guessing that it's not just you who has experienced your mother as coming across as negative, especially since you said she was spewing all that stuff about your H and about her siblings.

   You're ahead of the game by first telling ther that you loved her before you set a boundary.  To me, it shows that you're able to stay centered despite her hurtful angd guilt inducing tirade and not engage in slinging it back.

    As far as your dilemma-  What do you choose to do? What do you think would happen if you didn't call? Can you sit with the feelings that brings up, and let them be for a while?  How about if you do call, and as you said, she starts being negative as you said?  Can you sit with those feelings, and let them sit for a while?

    What you actually do is totally up to you, and I know that others on this board will have some thoughts for you.
     As just my own curiosity, I wonder what would happen if you do go ahead and do something different by not calling her?  It might be the first step in not doing the same dance step.

     Again, welcome, mjr, and I'll bet if others haven't already responded while I've been typing, it won't be long until they do, and there is a lot of wisdom and kindness here.

cats paw
 

mjrm

  • Guest
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #2 on: April 15, 2007, 11:18:25 PM »
Wow,  Cats Paw,  thank you for asking some great questions and making some insightful comments.

No, I hadn't verbally set boundaries for her before this week - I think that is the reason for this current drama. And although I did tell her yesterday and today what I expect regarding boundaries, I don't believe she heard me because she was talking some of the time and also didn't comment on them.
It makes me really sad and resentful that she is the only negative in my life.

Her comments yesterday and today toward the parenting is what made me stand up to her - I didn't comment specifically on this at all to her because I was so blown away that she could be so cruel. Instead, I told her that she was being too negative to talk to and that I chose not to listen to her when she talked that way and that we could talk again when she was positive and then I hung up.

 I am glad that I posted. I appreciate your reply and feel validated in what I've done so far and feel like I have somewhat of a map to follow to proceed - not so scary and chaotic. Although, I'm still not sure if I will call her tomorrow or not. I'm leaning toward not but I know that the guilt will drive me bonkers. If I do call, I will have to fight my instinct to yell/curse at her because I don't want to also be immature and negative...my mantra is 'be neutral' .
Thanks again.

cats paw

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 440
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #3 on: April 15, 2007, 11:36:34 PM »
Hi, again-

  I'm just getting ready to turn in, and I saw your new post.  If you want to try out that new behavior of not calling, we'll be here for you.  The guilt is a really, really tough one, but just breathe.  I'm finding out it doesn't kill me, it just feels like it's going to when I'm in the middle of it.  Anxiety is normal when practicing new thoughts or behaviors.
  You're leaning toward not calling- try that out!  But which every way it ends up, let us know how it goes!

You and your little one rest well tonight- it'll be OK.

Goodnight!

cats paw

reallyME

  • Guest
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #4 on: April 15, 2007, 11:45:40 PM »
Welcome, first of all...I'm going to see if I could share some of my own thoughts on what I see from your post too.

Quote
.  I don't believe that mother is a Nmom, I'm not sure what label(s) she's earned!


I'm thinking I have to disagree on this, possibly.  Her behavior seems very controlling and self-centered if nothing else.
Quote
intrusive into my husband and my lives (asks questions such as "how much money did you pay for the house", "how much is his paycheck", "why do you talk to your friends more than you talk to me", etc...).

Seems more like a meddling mother-in-law situation, actually.

-
Quote
overbearing (buys groceries for us without asking first and then gets angry if I don't come to her house to pick them up, tries to tell me what to do regarding calling lawn care people, cleaning house, etc...).

A subtle undermining of your ability to care for your family and then a bait n switch, in having you go pick the groceries up...seems to be doing good things for you, yet expects you to allow them to take place and gets mad when you wont' comply.


-
Quote
jealous of my relationship with my husband, friends. (describes him as dominating and lazy - I think she mainly doesn't like him because he verbally puts her in her place).
-spiteful and negative (says that we will be horrible parents - I'm 8 months pregnant with my first child, says we only care about ourselves and friends because we are moving out of state).


Can you say "GUILT TRIP?"  It also might be some insecurity on her part and a feeling that she is going to lose some control when you are gone.

Quote
On one hand, she is very giving financially - we NEVER ask for anything from her, she proposes a purchase and then persists until she buys it for us (a riding lawn mower, garage doors, clothes, etc...).  As I write this, I see her motives behind the purchases - she is able to force her way actively into our lives.

Gifts under the guise of manipulation.  Not good.  Seems she is trying to make herself look good TO herself, by "buying" you.  Later she can use it to say, "After ALL I HAVE DONE FOR YOU, THIS is the way you TREAT me?"  Usually this comes complete with the tag-on of, "Someday I"ll be gone and you'll be sorry!  You will WISH you had appreciated me more while I was still here!"

Quote
On the other hand, she is the most negative person that I know.  Granted she has reasons: my only sibling died a little over ten years ago, my father and she have been separated since I was 13 (I'm now close to 40), is retired and has no hobbies.  She has friends she talks with on the phone but never does anything socially with them. Thankfully, she does have siblings that live near and she does things with them on occasion.


I know another person who is in your situation, with a mother whose friends have died long ago, and she doesn't go out or do anything, so she tries to live through her 50 yr old daughter even to this day.

Quote
I  avoid doing anything/talking with her on the phone because she is so negative and intrusive. I'm sure part of her behavior is due to that I don't want to do things with her - so it's a self-fulfilling prophecy.


Yes, self-fulfilling prophecy...they create the very thing they fear...abandonment, cause they are so hard to deal with, that ultimately, people let them go on their way.



Quote
She has been especially difficult lately due to major life changes my husband and I are undertaking (as mentioned, I'm pregnant with her first and only grandchild; AND we will be moving five hours away as soon as I can after the baby is okay to travel).



If she is narcissistic, she will NOT adapt well to change in her surroundings, so expect that, seriously.  They do not appreciate someone re-arranging their chess board, one iota!  how DARE we!?

Quote
On Friday, she had a doctor's appointment and is furious that I didn't call her that evening (I had dinner plans that night with a friend and had been on a tiresome field trip with my class so I crashed instead of calling). I did call her the next morning at 10:00 - she was fuming and crying and saying how I didn't love her/care about her and that all I cared about was friends and my husband and how horrible we would be to a baby.

Ah! the Martyr syndrome being played to the hilt! She seems like she might be a tad bit histrionic too (loves the limelight for drama)

Quote
 Long story short, I told her I don't like to talk to her because she is so negative and doesn't support us emotionally and then hung up. I called her two times today before she answered this evening - still crying and saying she couldn't believe that she had been treated that badly by me and started again on the negative verbal comments towards me, my husband and even her siblings. I told her that I loved her but that I wouldn't talk to her until she was more positive and learned some boundaries and then hung up.


more guilt trips, drama, martyrdom.  I believe you handled it just fine.

Quote
My dilemma:  I call her everyday.  Should I not call her until I hear from her again or should I continue to call and say hello and once the negative begins then say goodbye?


Once again, if she is truly a bonifide narcissistic person, calling her every day will give her the supply she is after.  She only wants to know that you aren't leaving her.  Narcissists are terrified of abandonment.  She will do what she can to keep you right near her.  Remember, a 6 yr old in an adult's body.

~RM
 
 
 

Gaining Strength

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 3992
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #5 on: April 16, 2007, 08:22:53 AM »
I am 100% behind your establishing boundaries.  I recommend that you keep the no call boundary that you established. (It is a great practise for being consistent that is a necessary practise for raising your child.)  I encourage you to clarify your boundaries for yourself.  What behavior is off limits?  What action will you take?  For how long or until what is rectified?

I found that I lay down very firm boundaries with my mother.  When she crossed them  I refused to communicate with her until she agreed to see a therapist.  She wanted to be in our lives enough so that she complied.  But once I clarified my own boundaries I then communicated them to her.

Believe it or not you may have to say specifically, "It is inappropriate for you to ask about my husband's pay check and about the price of our house."  If you cannot keep our boundaries then the consequences will be ________.  The clearer you are for yourself, the clearer you can be to her.  This will help you dramatically. - your friend - Gaining Strength

Overcomer

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 2666
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #6 on: April 16, 2007, 10:52:00 AM »
Welcome!  If your mom is not an n than she is certainly a meddling mother!  The N part would play out by the need to be important or the center of the universe.  If she fits that then I would say she is.  If she has succeeded in sucking the self esteem out of you than yes.  If she is just a poor pitiful mom looking for some time, appreciation and validation than consider yourself lucky , set some boundaries and be the best mom you can be and the best daughter you can be.
Kelly

"The Best Way Out is Through........and try laughing at yourself"

Margo

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 176
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #7 on: April 16, 2007, 12:09:50 PM »
Hi,
I've been lurking a few days to see if my issues apply to this forum - tonight has been tough emotionally so I'd like some feedback if possible.  I don't believe that mother is a Nmom, I'm not sure what label(s) she's earned!

Here's a brief description...

-intrusive into my husband and my lives (asks questions such as "how much money did you pay for the house", "how much is his paycheck", "why do you talk to your friends more than you talk to me", etc...).
-overbearing (buys groceries for us without asking first and then gets angry if I don't come to her house to pick them up, tries to tell me what to do regarding calling lawn care people, cleaning house, etc...).
-jealous of my relationship with my husband, friends. (describes him as dominating and lazy - I think she mainly doesn't like him because he verbally puts her in her place).
-spiteful and negative (says that we will be horrible parents - I'm 8 months pregnant with my first child, says we only care about ourselves and friends because we are moving out of state).
 
On one hand, she is very giving financially - we NEVER ask for anything from her, she proposes a purchase and then persists until she buys it for us (a riding lawn mower, garage doors, clothes, etc...).  As I write this, I see her motives behind the purchases - she is able to force her way actively into our lives.

On the other hand, she is the most negative person that I know.  Granted she has reasons: my only sibling died a little over ten years ago, my father and she have been separated since I was 13 (I'm now close to 40), is retired and has no hobbies.  She has friends she talks with on the phone but never does anything socially with them. Thankfully, she does have siblings that live near and she does things with them on occasion.

I  avoid doing anything/talking with her on the phone because she is so negative and intrusive. I'm sure part of her behavior is due to that I don't want to do things with her - so it's a self-fulfilling prophecy.

She has been especially difficult lately due to major life changes my husband and I are undertaking (as mentioned, I'm pregnant with her first and only grandchild; AND we will be moving five hours away as soon as I can after the baby is okay to travel).

On Friday, she had a doctor's appointment and is furious that I didn't call her that evening (I had dinner plans that night with a friend and had been on a tiresome field trip with my class so I crashed instead of calling). I did call her the next morning at 10:00 - she was fuming and crying and saying how I didn't love her/care about her and that all I cared about was friends and my husband and how horrible we would be to a baby.  Long story short, I told her I don't like to talk to her because she is so negative and doesn't support us emotionally and then hung up. I called her two times today before she answered this evening - still crying and saying she couldn't believe that she had been treated that badly by me and started again on the negative verbal comments towards me, my husband and even her siblings. I told her that I loved her but that I wouldn't talk to her until she was more positive and learned some boundaries and then hung up.

My dilemma:  I call her everyday.  Should I not call her until I hear from her again or should I continue to call and say hello and once the negative begins then say goodbye?

I appreciate your considering this and giving your thoughts.



Congrats on the new baby.  I'll share some things about parenting I found important at the end of this post if you're  interested in reading them.

About that mom of yours...... she sounds a lot like my twin sister.  No sense of boundaries.  No ability to empathize with others.  It's always someone else's fault and in my opion...... some distance between you is a WOOOOOOOONDERFULLLLLLLL thing.  

I'd call her when I felt like it and end the conversation when she offended me or behaved innapropriately.  Maybe she'll learn that she has to at least TRY to curb her bad habits if she wants to have a relationship with you.  I don't talk to my sister much these days and sometimes she'll hit a nerve and I just lose my patience in a second and neither of us can get off the phone quickly enough.  She doesn't understand why..... she just knows I'm being unfair and that she knows all the secrets of the world that us stupid people can't begin to fathom and she doesn't have the time to begin explaining them to the great unwashed, which is me.  Hey...... limit your exposure and use phrases like......."ya know mom.... I like talking to you when you aren't asking me innapropriate questions or accusing me of doing something I haven't done to you so...... if you're going to do that I won't be able to talk to you/see you/ whatever applies.  Call me when you can be polite and civil.... I won't listen to the other anymore."  That sort of thing.  When she get's innapropriate..... remind her that she can't have an audience when she does that and politely walk away, say goodbye whatever you need to do to end contact.  

I found some information under Borderline Personality Disorder and sent it to her/my sister a couple years ago.  She laughed as I pointed out things she's done that were obviouse symptoms.... ie talking about suicide.  She admitted she's done the things BPD people do.  She normally turns her behavior around and explains that everyone around her is weak.... we're blind...... we care nothing for anyone else but ourselves....etc etc.  She's actually talking about her own behavior, which is ironic but she can't see it.  

Change of tone and subject.......
On parenting I'll share a couple of things.... take what you will and leave the rest.

1)  Getting baby secure in his/her own bed...... is a good thing.  You don't want baby and secondary caretakers up all night screaming bc baby is used to being breast fed to sleep, right?  I got baby used to bottle feeding as well so that we had a routine others could follow.  Less trauma for baby is better and you don't want your husband sobbing when you're sick and he's doing all the childcare, lol.

2)  Get your child used to holding your hand in parking lots and near roads..... even before they're walking.  That way..... it's a habit before it becomes an issue and they're in the phase where they're asserting themselves and wanting to do everything on their own.  You'll still have to be triple proactive about having your hands on them in unsafe areas but.... it helps if they're cooperating on a regular basis and understand the dangers of being squished by cars that can't see them bc they're so short.  Talk about listening for engines and looking for reverse lights even before they understand it.  Make a game of being aware.  My 6yo won't get out of the car until she has my hand...... even if I asked her to at this point, lol.  She KNOWS how dangerouse a parking lot is.  If your child runs into the street say.... for a ball...... don't spank her. Figure out where you failed her and be thankful if she's unharmed.  Fix the problem, move her play area boundary for instance, and talk to her about it before playtime and during playtime and after playtime.  Of course, children require a lot of supervision and if your child does get into the street.... it's time to rethink your supervision habits..... not spank.  ::wondering if they know how I feel about spanking by this time::

3)  Help your child through transitions by remaining calm steady mom.  Keep working towards your goal..... calmly and consitently..... eventually jr will understand that this is the way it's gonna be and soon the new habit is formed...... everything settles down again.  Until the next transition, lol.  

4)  Be consistent with routines and don't start any habits you don't want to continue.  Changing a habit is 100 times harder than thoughtfully introducing one everyone will enjoy in the first place, ie.... bedtime ritual that includes walking by crib in low lights, laying baby down in crib and gently touching face for a few minutes while whispering comforing words and leaving while baby is relaxed and sleepy. Keep in mind that running that baby up and down a staircase for an hour every night might seem worthwile for a moments peace in the beginning but..... it's going to get really really old after a while, lol.  15 minutes tops is a good goal, IMO. That transitions to the addition of 10 minutes reading to ritual.  Then gum care.  Then bathtime, etc.   You can tweek and add to it instead of having to start over again.  Keep in mind Das Kinder is going to get used used to whatever it is your doing..... so you may as well make it enjoyable for all concerned.  And oh ya...... did I mention you should make it reproducable for secondary caretakers, as well?

5)  With toddlers and older children...... Know that if you give in, every once in a while, it's like intoducing gambling to Jr.  They don't know when you're going to give in, but they know you are, so they push and push all the time till ya do, lol.  If your tired and can't stick to your guns on popcorn at bedtime.... just say yes to it instead of saying NO 40 times then giving in.  See?  Then..... you say No every other time when you have the strength to calmly enforce your words.  

6)  Discipline, in my opinion, is about gently guiding/training/teaching your child how to handle emotions and learn coping strategies and conflict resolution.  How you handle conflict and stress will be how your child handles it.  In other words.... if you're running around screaming and swatting at people..... that's how you deal with stress and conflict..... that's what your child learns to do, as well.   Quite the parent teacher conference in store for you, in that case.  ::nodding::  

If you're using your words and instituting logical consequences.... (read that as a consequence that has something to do with teaching them how to make better choices after a mistake) then your child will use those problem solving skills at school and throughout their life.  You'll recognize success in your efforts when Jr. quietly says...."use your little voice, mommy" from the backseat in rush hour traffic that has you frazzled.  

You're trying to teach your child to do better...... not punish them because you've failed to teach and you don't own any skills yourself.  Research.  Learn.  Read and think about what you want your parenting to look like 5 years down the road.  Ask people you admire how they parent.  How do they handle discipline and difficult transitions like potty training and getting jr to stay in a toddler bed.... sleep through the night..... give up their binky or leave a playdate.  It's your job.... and most people end up doing what their parents did.  Not good enough, in most cases.

It never seemed logical to me that a parent would take their small child's favorite bunny binky boo because they refused to clean up their toys...... or..... hit their child because they were throwing a tantrum.  How does that teach the child to do better?  It doesn't, IMHO.  What's the goal here?  Punishing or teaching?  Question your motives, actions and goals..... always.  You'll be adapting your parenting skills as you gain skills and on the job training.  You may even find you don't know much at all about parenting..... ::whispering:: babies don't come with instructions.  We aren't born knowing how to parent.  It's Ok.  Learn and be willing to bob and weave with your beliefs.  

One more thing..... about shots at the Dr.'s office.  I have my 6yo calmly taking shots and hardly grimacing.  She knows she's lucky to get good medical care and that it will be over quickly.  I was proactive about having that discussion long before we got to that point and I asked other people for advice.... then used it. So glad I did as holding my screaming child down while strangers hurt her was no longer an option for me.  I'm trying to get my 4yo into that groove but the last shot session I didn't stick to my guns with the nurse that ordered me to lay my body accoss dd's and hold her down.  Darnit.  

Keep in mind that Dr and nurse don't always know better and you know more about your child than they do.  If you want to see a specialist..... don't leave or stop yapping until you get a referral and don't allow them to do things that you said not to do... ie try to shove tylenol down the child's throat when you haven't been able to do it yourself.  If you don't mind being covered in pink and having it run into their tears and cause the doctor to miss an ear infection diagnosis because they think the blood is tylenol and they send you home bc they can't see through it.... then go right ahead and do as they suggest.  After all..... that ear will seep blood all night while your child cries and whimpers and you canmake the dx later on yourself.  ::shaking head, disgusted:: Right?  True story, btw.  Stick to your guns.

::End rant.... stepping off soapbox..... going back to working on temp hearing papers for tomorrow::
Margo  

Margo

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 176
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #8 on: April 16, 2007, 12:13:24 PM »

-
Quote
overbearing (buys groceries for us without asking first and then gets angry if I don't come to her house to pick them up, tries to tell me what to do regarding calling lawn care people, cleaning house, etc...).

A subtle undermining of your ability to care for your family and then a bait n switch, in having you go pick the groceries up...seems to be doing good things for you, yet expects you to allow them to take place and gets mad when you wont' comply.



Just remember...... "help is the sunny side of control."  Margo

mjr

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 3
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #9 on: April 16, 2007, 11:21:20 PM »
Update on the call/don't call standoff...

Well I didn't call and didn't go crazy with worry (thanks for all the support from this board!).  I usually call her between 5 and 6 pm and just didn't today. My mother called around 9:30 tonight - much calmer, tail between the legs sounding.  I put effort into interacting with her and being more offensive and actually enjoyed the conversation.  She asked that I take it easy on her that she's having a hard time right now and I said that I would but that I needed her to be thoughtful of what she says and how she treats me as well. She didn't comment on that...oh well.

I'm usually quite an impulsive person and want instant gratification for just about everything.   Therefore, I am surprised at myself that I'm able to stay calm and not try to "fix" everything all at once. I think this is a result of reading the postings on this site as well as a deeper understanding of my own self that I've been developing since finding out I'm pregnant.  Whatever the cause(s), I appreciate all the support the posters on this site have provided. I don't know that I would have had the stamina to have not called nor the confidence in how to proceed and the dedication to establishing boundaries without having had read the postings.

 :wink:

mjr

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 3
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #10 on: April 17, 2007, 01:24:10 AM »
CB,
Thank you for posting. I know that it must be hard to let kids (no matter their ages) go about their lives and be left feeling abandoned, not needed. I can't say for sure how your kids feel, I can only speak for my own experiences. I do love my mother very much and I do appreciate what she has done for me financially. However, what I want/need from her is her to have her own life.  Her neediness and desire for me to be her "everything" is so depressing and frustrating to me - even when I do try to make her happy by doing whatever she desires, she is still not happy.  That makes me want to give up and shut down when I have to be around her.  To see her being active socially and with hobbies would inspire me to look forward to my own future. I would be very proud of her and would want to be around her and to learn from her.

I have been trying to look at this conflict between my mother and myself from her view - your posting helped to give me insight to some of her feelings.

 My advice to you is to let your kids know you love them and that you will let them live their lives and make their own decisions/mistakes, unconditionally. Be sure to stand behind what you say - it is so confusing to me when my mother will say she's supportive of something and then a few hours/days later be mad at me for what I thought she was fine with me doing (passive aggression).  I believe that you are making the right steps toward being the parent you want to be by learning from sites like this one and for writing honestly about your own concerns. If events in your life are like mine, then you might see that once you truly let your kids go  (and you develop your own hobbies, relationships with others) you'll find them wanting to spend time with you.  And, if not, then you'll be so into your own life's adventures that that will be okay.
 :)

cats paw

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 440
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #11 on: April 17, 2007, 07:50:11 AM »
mjr-

   So glad this went well for you.  I can so relate to the feeling of wanting to give up and shut down when around my mother also.

   Glad things went well, and thanks for the update.

cats paw

Margo

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 176
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #12 on: April 17, 2007, 02:16:04 PM »
Margo,

You've got some good parenting advice there!  You've obviously been doing it for awhile.

One caveat I'll offer--I recognize the philosophy of putting the baby to bed to self-comfort to sleep and I sure see some benefits to that.  But something else to think about:  many of us who grew up in N families, particularly with N mothers, are at severe disadvantages when it comes to emotional health.  It is hard to pass on emotional health to our children when ours is so fragile. 

I have parented kids both ways, and I found the attachment parenting model to be more helpful to me.  I struggled with bonding with my babies because I had been so damaged as a kid.  Nursing on demand, sleeping with my baby, wearing my baby did a lot to help me develop my parenting skills.  They also taught me to trust my intuition and I sorely needed that encouragement.  If someone is emotionally healthy, probably any parenting style (used consistently and lovingly) is of equal value.  But for someone who is very damaged, as I was, as many of us are, attachment parenting can be god-send.

If you want some info on that MJR, you can probably google Attachment Parenting or anything by Dr. Sears.  A bit of following of links should give you the info. 

Love

CB

I couldn't figure out how to solve some problems I saw my sister encounter with "attachment parenting."  If I could have....... I would have.   The most important thing to remember, no matter what your style.... is to research your options and be proactive.... always thinking ahead to the next phase. Margo

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13619
Re: dealing with mother who is intrusive, overbearing, depressed
« Reply #13 on: April 17, 2007, 09:56:06 PM »
Hi MJR,
I've read here only spottily so please forgive me if I missed something pivotal.

I was having a fantasy monologue with your mother:

"Mom, I need to tell you something important. I think it may be very difficult for you to understand what I'm going to say, and I want you to know I realize that. I also need to tell you that I am going to hold fast to my decision because I believe it's the right thing to do. It is very hard to disappoint people you love, and this is going to disappoint you.

Mom, I am realizing that I am trying to fill up the gaps in your life by calling you every day. It's not your fault that this is causing me stress. I am responsible for taking care of myself, I'm an adult. But I have realized that whether we want it to be true or not, this is the truth. It is too stressful for me to try to prop you up with calls every day.

I will be calling you day after tomorrow, Mom, but I'm going to make it every few days now. I won't be calling every single day.

I love you and I'm sorry to disappoint you. But I can't give you all the attention you deserve right now."

I don't know if this makes any sense in your case. I did want to mention that the last line has been invaluable in helping me negotiate some breathing room from my very Nish mother. She would suck up all the attention I had in me, not only daily but several times a day, and then as I finally left the room (or the phone), would make some remark like, "I do wish I had more of your TIME."

One day it occurred to me to accept her version of reality (that she never gets enough attention). I sat down and said to her very sincerely (but internally, without any guilt): I can't give you the amount of attention you deserve. I know you should have it [this is acknowledging her worldview]...but I really can't do it. It's a shame, but ... etc.

And that really began to turn the tide. Nowadays, I give her the responsible attention she needs but not the level of doting she's always wanted. And she accepts it...even without the guilt trips. She's sensed me declaring a new boundary around my own life, my own self. It took many stumbles and false starts...but it's now our new relationship.

(Only took me YEARS...but I hope that key sentence might be a shortcut for you in your negotiations with your Mom. The real key I think is to accept their delusions about what's reasonable...but actually NOT negotiate. Just explain the facts. Your limits are your limits, unfortunately, and it's like the weather...not to be argued with.)

Good luck, keep us posted...

Hops
"That'll do, pig, that'll do."