This is a really important thread, Strength. I'm so glad you posted it...I imagine that even people who dont respond on the board will be challenged by what you have written here.
I think one of the things that keeps this kind of "I'm no good" thinking alive is that we all are in a constant mode of figuring out Who I Am. And we think that we we DO is the clue to Who I Am.
If I have a messy house, then I am A Person Who Always Lives in a Messy House.
If I have trouble with organization, I am A Person Who is Unorganized.
If I am late to work, I am A Person is Always Late.
So, every "failure" becomes a brand on my forehead. Oh, no! I'm not organized today? That means I am going to have recognize myself as who I really am: A Person Who Is Unorganized.
For me, the only way I could break that cycle was to refuse to label myself. Today I am unorganized. But it's not who I am. This weekend, I did not visit my mother (Hopsy), but I am NOT A Person Who Leaves Her Mother in a Nursing Home and Doesnt Visit Regularly.
I think that the "oh, no!" that we feel when we are unorganized, or over-extended, or struggling with finances, is that we are sucker-punched with the thought that this is who we ARE. The person we are. The flawed, unable-to-be-fixed, person. And all we REALLY are is tired. Or late. Or preoccupied. Just like everybody else.
Is this our black-and-white thinking rearing it's ugly head again? There are two kinds of people in the world: organized and unorganized. People who are late or on time. People who are financially responsible or financially irresponsible. We desperately want to fit into the "good" category, because to do otherwise is to be in the "bad" category. We don't allow for a middle ground that says that we are just human beings.
Anyway, that's the way I have dug myself out of this pit of despair. I am still incredibly sensitive to what I think OTHER people are thinking about who I am. I have a long, long way to go...
Love
CB