Ah... Boat... you ask an important question about whether the "process of processing" is the right path to healing. And what you've written is so clear and simple to understand, eloquent even. So much of your post connected with me and my experience. I especially can relate to this:
It has felt like playing a soccer game in pitch darkness sometimes making contact with the ball and other times not, all the while kicking like crazy in case the ball comes along in my direction.
I read your description yesterday of being interrupted while appreciating the sunset and there's a useful contrast in that I think, with this question of process/processing. As I fumbled around in the dark - like you described kicking like crazy just in case the ball was there - my T put me onto a book/author that Dr. G had mentioned, a few years ago. It's NOT a self-help book, yet it's become quite useful in how I understand how my brain works, how my processing works or doesn't - where the tracks had been ripped out so the "train" had to detour making things cumbersome, awkward and uncomfortable for me... resulting in over-processing or compulsively processing.
I'll try to describe my "theory" for you and see if it might have some parts that you can make use of; see if anything helps or fits - or not. Sometimes, it doesn't even seem to apply to me! And then, after some time has passed... I do see places where it fits. It helps to remember, that as humans, we don't ever reach a "status quo" - a place where we are done learning, we know everything, where we have all the answers. Even when I thought I did have an answer - duh - later on, I've decided I was wrong. Even the *quote* NORMAL FOLK *quote* aren't neat, complete, tied up packages of personality and characteristics... there's no "done" for being a person with senses, self-reflection, creativity, the ability to connect/share/appreciate... that "awareness" is called being alive. Not everyone who breathes is alive, tho... and you know I mean the PD zombies.
[Enough preamble, Amber!! god, I'm such a didact... maybe my verbosity is related to over processing.]
I'm sure you've run across the book or idea of "drawing on the right side of the brain", right? And you know about the mainstream idea that people are predominantly left or right brain beings, right? Well, most of us actually were or are integrated brain beings... in that we can shift quickly from different "specialities" in those parts of our brains... we aren't limited to only one orientation (L or R) as our main way of perceiving. That's where we're most comfortable... in that fluid shift from emotional Rbrain to analytical, process-oriented Lbrain... even using both at once, say while painting or sewing. Your ability to appreciate and be totally absorbed by music or the sunset - is a Rbrain speciality. Your laser like ability to use words together in such a clear way to express your Self and your meanings... is more Lbrain oriented. Your ability to knit is Lbrain... but your color combinations are Rbrain - instinctive and emotional.
This fluidity of being comfortable moving back and forth from one specialty in our brains to another can get disrupted. The train tracks get ripped out, in a small section - maybe on a sharp curve or over a very deep ravine. Poor, abusive parenting can be part of the explanation for what happens to that section of track; trauma; or even something physical or biological - like stroke or disease. [For the best intro explanation of L-R brain stuff, I'd refer you to the book "Stroke of Insight" by Dr. Jill Bolte Taylor. She's a neuro doctor who experienced a severe stroke and describes her own brain workings during the stroke and recovering; it was my starting point to understanding what you were saying about the compulsion to process...]
The second part of the "theory" is based on studies done by a doc, Daniel Schore. He studied the effects of neglect, abandonment, and "good enough" parenting on children from infants to toddlers. Maybe he's doing more now. Basically, he's found just this kind of disruption [the ripped out train tracks] in folks like me and others who were vulnerable enough to our poor parents that it screwed around with how our brains developed. Sometimes, it's not noticeable - people learn to "cope" with things like mild dyslexia, you know? Or sometimes, people will develop their own, idiosyncratic "workaround" to function close to "normal". Mine was healing itself, about the time I was 11; I had "substitute moms" that I was subsisting & surviving on... and then, when I experienced trauma & how my mom dealt with it and me... it re-opened that problematic "attachment" wound I had suffered as a much smaller child and made the wound more significant... the orginal weak point in my train tracks, to go back to my analogy.
Before I get into full lecture mode [duh] - my point here is that sometimes our brains get "stuck" into open-throttle processing BECAUSE at a young age we quickly learned that it was dangerous, or scary or "bad" or "not allowed" -- or anyway you describe it -- a problem with "us" that had to be fixed -- because someone ELSE was uncomfortable with the fact that we were able to access that place in our Rbrain were well-being - just being - exists. Jealousy, envy... inability to comprehend the reality of that place... I don't know why some parents are like that.
But they INSIST and browbeat and push and isolate these kids into believing that the ONLY right way to be.... is that Lbrain compulsive processing, computer-like programming. Maybe those parents are ashamed of their own emotions and therefore think it's their responsibility to beat those emotions out of their kids. I don't know; this is just my theory - and it still needs work.
This is too long for one post, already. And I probably haven't explained things with all the details to make myself clear. It's taken me a few years to put what I have of the theory together. But I have to also make the point that this isn't a hopeless, irreversible, brain-based, lifelong "disability". It IS possible to teach ourselves to be comfortable in those Rbrain, well-being places again. It is possible to re-connect the train tracks... re-engineer how they're built, so they're stronger.
The SELF's lack of confidence = more processing?
I think you're right about this; and I think it fits into my theory... but I'm not sure - or able to say yet - how. Maybe you've got some ideas about that. I have one idea that I've been working on related to confidence of the Self - and that is, that if we are accepted by a parent as WHO WE ARE (complete with our individual "do knows") then, we automatically grow that confidence of self... and we don't second-guess ourselves... we trust that self... and there's no need to spend all that time processing... because there's really nothing WRONG that needs to be FIXED.
So whaddya think? Am I over-processing myself into complete craziness????? LOL... some days I wonder about that. I think I'll just lay in the pool today and try to decide what the clouds look like.