Where I live in Pa. The Amish neighbors do have community based relationships, the church family is decided by where they live. Church is a their homes and they take turns, and they don't have regular medical insurance, the church pulls together and does fund raisers if they can't collect enough from the church family to help one of their own. If they have a problem that the family can not settle the church elders take over...it straitens things out pretty quick! They still have their problems just like the rest of us, but the support keeps it to a minimum.
The pastors are chosen and don't volunteer themselves, they have to be asked, that keeps the N's from running things.
So, SilverLining...they are living your fantasy...you should become Amish! That is if you don't mind getting places going 4 miles an hour down the road behind a horse!!!