Hey all... I WONDER:
how much "objectifying" has to do, with a predisposition to collect clutter??
and might it involve a passive-aggressive attempt to "control" or be top dog in an emotional power struggle????? Perhaps even an inner one? Or a way to "force" acceptance of self on others - "love me, love my clutter" - in a living situation????
I wonder.
As far as I can tell - everyone has clutter. Somewhere - either visible or hidden. Once, when looking at this house, I did notice that the previous owner had organized so completely, that there was a labelled shoebox for "open snacks" in the cupboard. That's a bit extreme in the OTHER direction, methinks...
Garden variety clutter happens when things aren't "put away" where they belong. Maybe they don't have place where they belong; maybe life & fun or work & kids or friends or exercise or a thousand other possible things distracted one long enough that one "forgot" to put things away. Or it a was a project: and materials & tools were left out because life called one away to something else. Or one just doesn't find filing a stimulating way to spend time! It's not shameful; it doesn't need a self-help book; there's nothing wrong with the person who has this kind of "clutter" in their lives, you know?
Yes, I know there are extremes - and I sometimes feel I've been fighting my whole life against those! But don't you think, that just like societal pressure to be thin, fit, and barbie-doll attractive... we're being programmed to "expect" our living spaces to be so clean, attractive & neat that it looks as if no one lives there???? I wonder.
I also wonder how much our "stuff" enables - in a passive-aggressive way - one to claim space; express oneself; allow oneself to dream or anticipate or force acceptance of oneself - "just as one is" - on others; or to substitute sentimentality in objects for real relationships; real life. As if "stuff" is some cosmic by-product of being who we are.... and some of us take more or less responsibility for the impact of our stuff on others... and some are simply oblivious to it.
My own quirk that way, is having "stuff" - just in case: what if the power goes out? I have a propane camp stove/oven... just in case I get the urge to bake something (????????) I have a shelf full of herbs/spices for ethnic food that I only cook occasionally. I have several boxes full of first aid "stuff" - tho' I haven't yet bought the back country suture kit!!

And I will only say that for 20 years I have dedicated storage space to art & sewing "stuff" - some of it still unwrapped - that I "might" use.... someday. And I've even put together baskets/jars of "stuff" in my guest rooms.... in case someone forgets toothpaste, needs an aspirin, etc.
I have been so primed and groomed to be self-sufficient, it's rediculous, in it's own way... Walmart is a mile from my house.