Hi Pandora,
I just wanted to write to let you know you are not alone in feelings of not knowing if his changes are permanent, not knowing if you can live in a marriage without emotional respect... Not knowing how to catagorize your marriage because your not sure if it fit the criteria for "overt" abuse. Not knowing what you will tolerate in marriage. It is incredibly painful... I don't think you are being a wimp at all! I can relate to the same kinds of questions, and am still struggling with them.
Thankfully, I think I am over the depression part of it. But in reading your post, I can relate and remember those feelings so vividly. I think seeker has some great advice. The things that have helped me to get over the depression are getting emotional support and validation outside of marriage... doing things that made me smile without my husband, writing in a journal... These sorts of things have made me strong enough to stand up to my husband and set very strict boundries. I can tolerate his neglect, lashing out, and making nice more now because I see it as his problem, and not mine. But it is a slow process for me. I still feel sad and afraid about it (but not constantly depressed anymore).
I have started to think of myself as the parent of a 6 foot 4-year-old. instead of a wife. (not exactly what I thought I was signing up for) Nonetheless, suddenly I am the mean mommy who sticks to boundries. I hope that over time he will change permanently, but if not I don't know what is going to happen to our marriage either. I don't know how it will be before I have clarity.
I agree with seeker in that one cannot compare oneself to anyone else. That is certainly not my intent here. We all have to trust ourselves. I just wanted to share in hope of offering comfort in knowing you are not alone. If any of this sounds familiar you might be interested in reading
The Solo Partner by Phil Deluca.
Do take care of yourself! you have my empathy!
Peace! sjkravill