Write,
Like Ami, I am hesitant to comment, but not because I am apprehensive about what I want to say...I just tend to lack TACT at times, and am concerned at this not coming out right...however, that will not stop me from giving it a shot here. I am hoping I do not sound pessimistic or cynical. I just try to speak with honesty and forthrightness, my views on things, based on my own experiences.
Ami,
I'm GLAD you gave your comment. You made an EXTREMELY good point! I currently live with someone who has some wonderful traits and even had more when we first met...it's the subtle things I never noticed!
I did tend to OVERLOOK the part about "this man's father molested both his daughter and step daughter, and has abused my husband and his brothers in the past." I overlooked also, the fact that he was "more than willing to give you references" right up front, telling me "anyone in my town will let you know about my flawless reputation." (smacks self in head soundly)
I overlooked the fact that he resented my daughter and took his frustration out on her in the form of abuse (BEFORE I MARRIED HIM)
I overlooked the fact that he would refuse to eat anything that was fancy, spiced, nice, formal and INSIST that he always eat "what mom always made me"
I overlooked the fact that he LIVED FOR WORK! (workaholic, even at the expense of family)
ALL BECAUSE HE SEEMED TO FIT THE WONDERFUL LIST I HAD MADE UP:
I wanted a man who was RESPONSIBLE, FELL IN LOVE WITH MY DAUGHTER BEFORE HE FELL IN LOVE WITH ME (oh yes, till she interfered with something he was doing)
One who treated his mother well, cause after all, if he did, he'd treat me well too, right? (when it came down to it, his mom always came BEFORE ME in our marriage...or else his SISTER did)...now for your list:
1. attractive/attracted
>>>my opinion here...NOT a good first trait at all. The ones who are ultra attractive tend to KNOW it, FLAUNT it and USE it. A little bit good-lookin doesn't hurt though. You don't want to marry Atilla the Hun or Big Foot either.
2. manages their life
>>>This seems reasonable. Just be careful that he doesn't manage HIS life, but trying to control YOURS.
3. spiritually in balance
>>>THIS SHOULD BE FIRST! My opinion
4. lives a healthy lifestyle
>>>This is a very good one, until he imposes it on you, insisting that you look a certain way or weigh a certain weight or eat only certain foods. (be lookin for that)
5. is happy
>>>As long as it's not at YOUR expense
6. we have significant interests in common: music, writing, nature especially
>>>Awesome!
7. compassionate/ kind / non-abusive
>>>Excellent to look for
8. likes children & pets & family life
>>>YES
9. shares my values: eg. faithfulness, monogamy, interfaith, feminism, love of G_d, social responsibility, commited to personal growth
>>>That sounds dreamy! very good ones!
10. good sense of humour, good-humoured!
>>>As long as you are not the brunt of cruel jokes, I say YES, go for this one!
I pray for you that BEST that God can give

~Laura