Author Topic: Can a N feel 'true' attraction?  (Read 4694 times)

el123

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 50
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« on: July 10, 2004, 05:43:55 PM »
Just wondering what you think about this:  Can a N feel true attraction for a woman?  What about true feelings?  I've read the books, this forum, etc. which say a N can only truly 'loves' the mirror image he receives but still I wonder.

The reason I ask is because my N  BIL has always acted as though he was attracted to me.   It's been almost a decade now.  I know that it's not in my imagination as it's been pointed out to me by others.  He stares at me whenever I happen to be in a room with him.  I can feel his eyes on me when I'm not facing him (and sure enough, when I turn around, he's checking me out).  This happens even if there are other attractive women in the room and even if his wife and kids are with him.  My H has even noticed his brothers strange behaviour around me.  He gets sort of tongue tied and flustered around me.  Something I never see him doing around other people.  He's called me on the phone on occasion (to offer me help with stuff or to see if I need anything in a storm, etc.) and genereally treats me better than he treats others around him.  

Recently  there is this 'wierdness' between us.  A *strong* chemistry of some sort.  Now I would **NEVER** even *consider* doing anything with him.  I'm married and have children plus I don't even LIKE this guy.  But there is this unmistakeable chemistry nonetheless.

I've never been unfaithful to any man in my life and would not even *consider* cheating on my H.  I've never given my N BIL even  the slightest suggestion that I'd go with him.  I've never given him any 'supply' as I rarely interact with him at all.  So if he's attracted to the mirror image, the mirror image is one of avoidance as I tend to avoid him whenever I can.  He makes me feel very uncomfortable.

What is this?  Does anyone know what this is about?  Is he truly attracted to me?  And why do *I* feel this recent chemistry with him as well?  I truly do not like this guy.  You can't really hide chemistry I know but then why?  I give him NOTHING.
-E

mighty mouse

  • Guest
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #1 on: July 10, 2004, 07:10:52 PM »
Howdy El123,

My sister has NPD. She gets attracted to all sorts of men and fantasizes about them. She has stalked several men (all in university settings - she likes their intelligence and men that are older). By stalking I mean she sends email (wouldn't stop when asked to), and she fancies that these guys are her great friends. She gives gifts as well even though this isn't reciprocated. She alway seems to think these guys are in love with her. She has told me that so and so man type has looked at her across the cafeteria and that was enough to start her on this stalking behaviour. To me that sounds plenty delusional, but she acts just like it is okay. When I try to point this out (well I don't anymore since we are estranged which is good for me - whew!), she goes into an N regression.

If the guy gives her one iota of attention or tries to be civil or polite, she takes advantage. It's then impossible for them to get rid of her. She was actually kicked out of Harvard for this type of behaviour with her advisor - thought her was in love with her and started writing him letters telling him to stop (doing what I don't know - as far as I could tell he did nothing wrong in a concrete sense). She made up the wrongdoing in her mind.

She seems very benign if you don't know her. And she can even be nice to a certain degree. And she is smart as all get out. But she is mentally unbalanced with this either NPD or BPD or both.

I wouldn't give this guy even one scintilla of attention. He could wreck your life as my sister has done to these men. Be careful. I have seen this first hand and it's scary.

Good luck.

MM

Dawning

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 344
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #2 on: July 10, 2004, 09:29:01 PM »
Quote
Recently there is this 'wierdness' between us. A *strong* chemistry of some sort. Now I would **NEVER** even *consider* doing anything with him. I'm married and have children plus I don't even LIKE this guy. But there is this unmistakeable chemistry nonetheless.


Maybe you should work on gaining some insight into the *strong*  chemistry part.  If I understand correctly, chemistry implies something mutual.  If it was just stalking, he would be driving you crazy.  When I was stalked, I had to tell the person involved that if they didn't stop harassing me with letters and phone calls, that I would get our employer involved.  But I think if I had felt a chemistry as well, I would see it as *weird* too if that makes any sense.  

Also, never say never.  I've learned that recently.  If he feels that you feel a chemistry too, he is probably going to give you even more attention and it sounds like you don't want that.  So I would set about trying to  answer this question

Quote
And why do *I* feel this recent chemistry with him as well?


Maybe its exciting to you....or you like the attention....but I would definitely become mindful of what is happening at your end.  While investigating your own stirrings, I would treat him the same way as you always have not giving a hint of the questions you have about what is going on inside of you.

Hope this helps.
"No one's life is worth more than any other...no sister is less than any brother...."

el123

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 50
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #3 on: July 10, 2004, 10:11:47 PM »
MM,
Your sister reminds me a little like Glenn Close in Fatal attraction.  How bizarre!  I'm so glad you wrote because although I've never given my BIL much attention in the past, I *have* been civil and polite to him.  But he's not the kind of N that is outwardly so.  So pretty much everybody else is civil and polite to him as well.  Good advice about not giving even a scintilla of attention to him, though.

Dawning,
I know, the strong chemistry part is kind of wierd to me.  Like I said, it's a recent thing (the past few months.  And he's shown attraction-like behavior to me for almost ten years now).  It's this odd primal type of response.  It's not something I'm doing.  It's literally like a sexual energy that he's sending to me and apparently I'm returning? I'm not sure why I have this reaction to him recently.  And like I said, I would *NEVER, EVER* act on it.  Maybe he *is* picking up on it.

Thanks, E

Anonymous

  • Guest
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #4 on: July 11, 2004, 02:29:41 PM »
Of course an N can feel an attraction. If your BIL finds you sexy, attractive, and if he wants to seduce you, I bet it's about a rivalry with his brother. His behavior is inappropriate, disrespectful, and oafish. I would stay very far away from him. He is totally bad news.

bunny

BlueTopaz

  • Guest
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #5 on: July 11, 2004, 11:11:24 PM »
El123,

I think everything that Dawning had to say is really valuable, and important to do.  I can't say much more.  

Take time increments alone to think deeply, and be really core honest with yourself.

el123

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 50
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #6 on: July 13, 2004, 08:18:44 AM »
bunny, I think you are right about a rivalry with his brother.  He's always totally ignored the basic boundaries with my H.  Why would this be an exception?

Blue Topaz,  I thought over what Dawning had to say and came up with this:  I've always had a problem getting truly close to anyone.  It's not something that anyone would necessarily 'notice' as I don't act any differently than someone who feels secure in the relationship.  I think because of my past with a N mom, I associate love with something bad.  :(  I think the fact that my N BIL is so *off limits* has made his attraction to me not unwelcome recently.  I may be totally off here but that's what I came up with.   I've always had a problem feeling good in closely intimate relationships.  My H and I have a good marriage in general.  I'm good to him and of course the kids as well.  But it's something in my head that's not able to embrace love relationships totally.  It's like there's a wall there to protect me from fully feeling so that I can't get hurt like I did with my mother.

-E

Anonymous

  • Guest
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #7 on: July 13, 2004, 11:56:06 AM »
I think it's flattering to be the object of a man's seduction. It doesn't mean that you're in love with him, you may even dislike him. Still, it's naturally flattering for a man to pursue us, especially a "taboo" man. My suggestion is to simply stay away from this manipulative creep. Don't feel bad about being flattered. Most women would be. Heck, I would.

bunny

BlueTopaz

  • Guest
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #8 on: July 13, 2004, 01:19:03 PM »
Hi E,

I don’t think you are off, if those are the thoughts that came to you, from within you, when you thought carefully and honestly.   Sometimes there are many layers of things, and we  find out even more of the puzzle as we think more on it…    

The great thing is that you have the time you need (while not changing your behavior overtly) to think on it, until you feel it is resolved within you.  

What you have realized so far makes so much sense.

The feeling of “dysfunction” and love together, may be what is feeling familiar to you, and familiarity, even when it’s around really unhealthy circumstances, can be extremely drawing to us.  

My mother was a weekend alcoholic, and I have noticed that although I am honestly repulsed, and do not want to be around very drunk people, at the same time I sense a part within me that is drawn to it (there is almost an excitement) because of the familiarity.  Sad to say (but happy to realize it!) a part of me feels at home when observing someone  like that.  

As insecure and bad as they are on the whole, certain situations build our sense of security as a children, just merely due to their consistency.

Another thing.   I have similar feelings as you do, about letting people really close.   I don't know if you will relate to this, but what I’ve noticed for myself, is that sometimes (when I was in a relationship\s- am not now), I would kind of flirt with taboo thoughts.   For example, if  someone was coming on to me, I’d imagine, and feel exhilerated about reciprocating (although I’d never do it- couldn’t be farther from who I am).  

What I’m saying is that I think thoughts like that can sometimes, for some emotionally guarded people, be the psyche’s way of feeling safer, by creating some emotional distance in one's mind only, between oneself and one's partner.  

I admire your willingness to get to the bottom of your feelings here....

Jaded

  • Guest
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #9 on: July 13, 2004, 01:35:01 PM »
Oh boy Oh boy!!!  Where an I begin on this one??  I agree with the others that it is a jelous issue with his brother (your HUSBAND) and I also think that he will continue to work you (better stated would be manipulate, seduce, work his ladies man talents) until you fall into a vulnerable position and he will jump on you like a fly on chit.  

May I ask you something?  If you think back to all of the things your husband has said about your BIL, would there be a mention of rivalry, jellousy, bitterness or previous other women your husband dated that the NBIL hounded on?

I don't know how to explain this but it is almost like N people have the ability to perform voodoo on their victims.  First of all if he was a descent person he would take his wagging tail to a single woman let alone his married SIL.  Something is missing in his deck of cards to even attempt this one.

Hun, I am here to tell you that should the chance arrise with this viper, you should run as fast as you can.  He would probly bed you once or twice then turn his nasty venum on your husband and tell all.  

Tisk
Tisk
N never quit amazing me with their tactics.

el123

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 50
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #10 on: July 14, 2004, 05:59:07 AM »
bunny,  I'm glad that you wrote what you did.  I had been feeling sort of guilty about my feelings.  You're right, it is flattering to be the object of his attention.

Blue Topaz,  
Quote
The feeling of “dysfunction” and love together, may be what is feeling familiar to you, and familiarity, even when it’s around really unhealthy circumstances, can be extremely drawing to us.

 yes, I know exactly what you mean.  I used to only be attracted to guys with problems.

Quote
I don't know if you will relate to this, but what I’ve noticed for myself, is that sometimes (when I was in a relationship\s- am not now), I would kind of flirt with taboo thoughts. For example, if someone was coming on to me, I’d imagine, and feel exhilerated about reciprocating (although I’d never do it- couldn’t be farther from who I am).


I can definately relate to this!  I do the same thing.

Jaded, Yes I think that rivalry/jealousy has something to do with this.

Quote
May I ask you something? If you think back to all of the things your husband has said about your BIL, would there be a mention of rivalry, jellousy, bitterness or previous other women your husband dated that the NBIL hounded on?


I asked H this and he said "no" but maybe because his brother didn't know his past girlfriends so much.  But he did say that his brother was highly competitive with him.

Quote
First of all if he was a descent person he would take his wagging tail to a single woman let alone his married SIL. Something is missing in his deck of cards to even attempt this one.


Well, he's had numerous affairs, even going so far as to living with another woman on the side (he had a separate apartment and, since he's a doctor, would often be 'on call' at nights).  He's a total dog this way.

Update:  My H was not speaking to either his N mother and N brother.  It had been almost two months since his N brother and N mom had tried to contact him and about 3 months since my H had initiated contact.  Things got really out of hand with them and our marriage was suffering badly.  He decided that they were 'toxic' for him (long story but in a nutshell they were telling him to jump and he'd say 'how high, how long' etc even though it was destructive to our family. For example, getting my H to pay bills that his brother owed and his brother is a multi millionaire and my H would just do it even though we couldn't pay our bills because of it simply b/c N brother *told him to*.  Lot more but don't have time to get into it).  Anyways, since the break off, my N MIL and N BIL have tried grasping and clawing to get him back in their grips.  My MIL called him crying a couple of times saying that she was going to kill herself (she's been doing this for as long as he can remember and has never attempted, just threatens), and my N BIL called him to yell at him for stressing their mom out by distancing himself, etc.  But H was good and stood his ground (all his doing, I did not tell him to do this).  A month and a half goes by with no contact from them.  Our marriage has been good for the first time in a year since they weren't in the pic.  His stress level decreased significantly, etc.  

Then, yesterday, H told me that BIL called him at work, his recent MO since he has an unlisted number that he calls from and H can't get call block on his work phone.  Said "are you going to talk to mom anytime before she dies?"  My H told him that he would call her if and when *he* decided.  BIL was trying to force H to call her ASAP, saying that she had been in the hospital (for nosebleeds!  And he and his wife are both *doctors* and MIL lives in one of their houses with them! And *directly* across the street from a hospital).  H still stood his ground and restated his boundaries to his B.  BIL said that us sending his kids presents was 'repulsive and almost made him sick' (we sent presents for his sons b-day like we do every year) and that he almost sent them back to us, went on to insult his half brother (who he's never even seen and his half brother's in his mid twenties) for inviting him to his wedding.  Said "I should call him to yell at him for inviting me.  How'd he get my address?" Implying that my H gave it to him, which he didn't.   Apparently BIL is angry at his half brother for having the "misfortune" of being spawn of his father who BIL villifies at every opportunity (he wasn't that great of a dad, but wasn't *that* bad either and now is an absolute sweetheart truly).  Then my H said that BIL and their mother need to respect me (they *don't* at all!  They have constantly tried to get H to keep secrets from me and lots of other stuff that makes marriage even more difficult than it has to be).  

Then my BIL said to my H "She's not good enough for you" (meaning that I am not good enough for my H).  My H said "Why because she stays home with them kids, doesn't make money, and doesn't send the kids to daycare?"  BIL said "No, that's not it".  He never did say what "it" is.  Then my H said "Well, I think that she's good enough and you and mom need to respect her."  That's basically when the convo ended with BIL yelling that he was never going to  speak to my H again unless their mom died.  My H said "good".

I don't think that I can ever see/speak to my BIL again.  I'm so ticked that he would tell my H that I wasn't 'good enough'.  This really hurt to hear.  I don't even know why.  He's a complete a$$ and I shouldn't take it personally.  I just feel so bad that he would say that about me.

 I know that my BIL will try to contact us/ my H though since my H had been his best supply and my MIL's as well.  I think that I need to extract myself from his family.  It's too destructive for me and the whole family.  Thanks for listening,
-E

Onyx

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 67
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #11 on: July 14, 2004, 12:22:05 PM »
If there is a chemistry between you, then you must be giving something back in return..........even if it's only a smile(s).....right? You keep saying that you don't like him, but persist in saying that there is chemistry between you.......so you must be slightly more invested than you think!

Anyway, if he is an NPDer..........then no, you're just an object.....a challenge! He may be Somantic in which case it is purely sexual......he interacts and expresses suedo feelings this way! In actually fact, who could be seeking satisfaction in destroying your marriage........very sick

David

Anonymous

  • Guest
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #12 on: July 14, 2004, 01:39:01 PM »
Quote from: el123
Then my BIL said to my H "She's not good enough for you" (meaning that I am not good enough for my H).  My H said "Why because she stays home with them kids, doesn't make money, and doesn't send the kids to daycare?"  BIL said "No, that's not it".  He never did say what "it" is.  Then my H said "Well, I think that she's good enough and you and mom need to respect her."  That's basically when the convo ended with BIL yelling that he was never going to  speak to my H again unless their mom died.  My H said "good".


Your husband did well here. He'll do even better when he ends the conversation at the first hint of abuse. Even if he has to hang up on him.



Quote from: el123
I don't think that I can ever see/speak to my BIL again.  I'm so ticked that he would tell my H that I wasn't 'good enough'.  This really hurt to hear.  I don't even know why.  He's a complete a$$ and I shouldn't take it personally.  I just feel so bad that he would say that about me.


You're surprised that your BIL insulted you? That was predictable actually. When he couldn't seduce you, he had to find a different way to hurt his brother - by dissing his wife. This isn't really about you. He's testing to see how much crap his brother will take.

Stay away from this creep, that's all I can say.

bunny

Portia

  • Guest
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #13 on: July 15, 2004, 07:04:15 AM »
Hi El, maybe any “chemistry” is simply that BIL smells like, or moves like, your H. After all, you married his brother, so there must be some genetic attraction to the type. Who knows.

Whatever, even if there is some mutual genetic attraction, it’s nothing magical or special, just basic hormones. A bit like bad PMT when you want to commit violence: something to be aware of but not to act upon. P

el123

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 50
Can a N feel 'true' attraction?
« Reply #14 on: July 15, 2004, 08:39:10 AM »
onxy,
 
Quote
In actually fact, who could be seeking satisfaction in destroying your marriage........very sick


On thinking about what you said here, I think you are right.  I think that he gets some type of thrill thinking that he has power to break us us.  I don't think I'll be speaking/seeing him anytime ever at this point ever since the "not good enough" comment.

bunny,
I'm so glad that you said my H did well with BIL b/c I wasn't sure of that.  In my anger on hearing about the convo wished that my H would have gotten more angry but it's better that he stayed calm and just restated boundaries.
Quote
You're surprised that your BIL insulted you?

Yes, ridiculously I was.  He had never done this before that I know of and I guess I'm just naive.  You'd think I'd know better coming from a Nmom, huh?  You're right to stay away from him.  It's what I completely intend to do!  

Portia,
Quote
maybe any “chemistry” is simply that BIL smells like, or moves like, your H.

You know, I never thought of that!  But maybe you're right b/c early on in our marriage I was strongly attracted to a co-worker and realized later that this co-worker looked and acted extremely similar to my H and reminded me of my H.
Quote
Whatever, even if there is some mutual genetic attraction, it’s nothing magical or special, just basic hormones  

Yes, it's just a sexual thing.  Definately nothing special and nothing I'd act on.  I have no fear of that (especially now!)

"Not good enough", "not good enough..."  dammit, I *am* good enough!  LOL!  His comments just really struck at me hard!  I've never said or did *anything* unkind to him or anyone in the family.  It's not like I'm an addict, sleep around, or do *anything* to warrant this comment (I'm kind of boring, actually).  Sh..t, I even am mother to his two nieces and one nephew.  How can he say that to my H who has never said anything bad to me about his brother in his life?  I know, he's a N.  A classic,  it's all about him, has no empathy, doesn't give a rat's a$$ about anyone but himself N.  But d@mn!  This comment still hurts!
-El