This is just a book review, written by an ordinary person who'd read the book by Cloud and Townsend,
titled Boundaries: When To Say Yes, How to Say No To Take Control of Your Life
I'm including it here because so much of what she said was true for me... and, besides, it really is a great book.
Carolyn
This book is highly recommended. It's one of the most valuable purchases I've ever made.
Saying we should not set boundaries is saying that we should not be human. Traffic lights are boundaries. Laws are boundaries. Work hours are boundaries. Marriages are boundaries. Bounced checks are boundaries. Prisons are boundaries. Locked car doors are boundaries. Those reviewers who argue against setting boundaries are themselves, most assuredly, setting and respecting boundaries every day of their life. So let's be honest here. Let's not live in ivory tower concepts, twice removed from reality.
None of us is Jesus. If we were Jesus, we would not need Him to begin with. Codependency is * not * Christian love. Being a doormat is not spiritual. One cannot expand boundaries if one does not know how to set boundaries to begin with. This book is about learning to do just that. Boundary-setting is about being authentic to your own heart: "I am a child of God, and my feelings do matter here. I am being led to do this, even though it may contradict what you desire me to do." Do people sometimes bristle at the truth? You bet! It's human to want our desires fed, even if it is at another person's expense. It's not pretty; it's human. That's why we need boundaries.
In my experience, failing to set boundaries was a form of people-pleasing, and people-pleasing was a form of unconscious deception and false idol worship. I tried for many years to be a "good girl." That got great reviews. Never mind that I usually did things for other people without checking to see if it was what God was instructing me to do. Instead, my impulse came from selfish reasons, "I'll do this for you. Don't I look good? Now do you approve of me? If you do, then maybe I can approve of myself." What rubbish! My behavior was not motivated by Christ. My behavior was motivated by refined selfishness.
You see, I wasn't interested in you. I was interested in what you could give me: your approval. I was an approval junkie, and I was no more morally superior than a drug addict, no matter how much praise my actions brought me. I was worshipping a false idol -- the approval of others over God's direction -- and that false god failed me time & time again. Sorry folks. That's not Christian love. No wonder I hurt all the time! God never intended for me to be dishonest and unhappy. God never intended for me to get my worth from man.
Now that I've begun to listen to my heart, I am learning to tell the truth to myself and to others. I am learning to accept my limitations -- be humble -- and learning to be balanced. The truth does indeed set you free. This process has brought me what I never got from others' approval. It brought me the fruits of the spirit: joy and peace. It has also made my relationships with others more genuine and peaceful. People do approve of me, now, but it's the * real * me. That's how I know that this book teaches principles of truth.
Incidentally, it's wrong to hate people as you are setting boundaries. That's not what this book is proposing. Your intention in setting boundaries does matter here.