Author Topic: Struggling with decision  (Read 27832 times)

Plucky

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 800
Struggling with decision
« on: January 20, 2006, 01:38:36 PM »
For some months now I have turning over and over the decision to divorce ny husband.  We have 2 small children and I also know that in business he is ruthless.  Two factors which make me reluctant to start.  Every day I flip flop several times. 

Part of the problem is that I have no idea what is normal, since I have never seen a healthy love relationship up close.  I have only my imagination to judge how bad it is.  This morning we overslept, and I woke up obviously sicker from a cold and stressed because I had 20 minutes to do an hour's worth of getting ready.  In my mind, a normal husband would say something sympathetic about how I was feeling (I'm coughing, slept badly, dragging) or at least ask about it.  My H said nothing.  In my mind, a normal husband would offer to help me get the kids, breakfast, lunch, backpacks ready....my H announced he was going to take a shower, although he had also just announced he was working from home so he didn't really need to do that.  At moments like this, I feel I'd be better off without him.  Am I just reacting too strongly?  Expecting too much?
Plucky 

P as guest

  • Guest
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #1 on: January 20, 2006, 03:29:47 PM »
Hiya Plucky. Coincidentally my H is in the shower while I'm typing this. Does he yell at me when I say I have to shower in the evening, after I've been at home all day? And he's been at work? Nope. He let's me choose what I do, me him (both to an extent). If one of us ill, the other one does more, considers the ill one's needs - asks what help/chores they want the other to do. Mutual consideration, respect. A reciprocal relationship. That's to aim for, but nobody's perfect and we sure ain't! :D Very glad to see you posting this Plucky. Hope you get lots of replies. You will from me! that's all for now, gotta go. You trust yourself! take care, P

Sela

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1273
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #2 on: January 20, 2006, 05:19:45 PM »
((((((((((((((((((Plucky))))))))))))))))))))

Sorry you're sick with a cold and for all of your struggling.  It's not nice at all.

One thing.....do you ask?

When I was young and better looking ( :D), I used to think my H "should know" what to do....how to help...what to offer.....what I need.....etc.

Now......I'm not in that mode (and I can be ugly!! :x).  I try harder to ask.  "Please......would you?....I need help?........would you mind?........I'm too tired/sick/ugly/grumpy/etc to do ___________ and I'd really appreciate if you would.....can you?

I have learned that it's frustrating and can be depressing to exprect my H to guess what I want or need and it's been a real challenge for me to learn to ask.  But I'm getting better at that.

Maybe you're already done this?  Or maybe it will hurt more if he says "no" or ignors what you ask?

Hope you feel better real soon Plucky.

Sending you great steaming bowls of cyber-chicken soup.

Sela

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13616
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #3 on: January 20, 2006, 05:23:27 PM »
Hey Plucky,
It's the most painful decision imaginable. Especially with young kids.

I would be hugely hurt and resentful in that same scene. (Was. Now divorced.)
I only have two questions (forgive me if you've already explained all this in the past):

Have you been to counseling together? If not, that would be urgent, imho.

Have you told him out loud what you need? In what sort of way? In the situation you describe, unbelievable as this may seem...some people's spouses literally go deaf and dumb and do not ask the appropriate considerate, affection-engendering types of questions (such as, you're not feeling well and I'm working at home today, so what can I do for you?). But sometimes it's that they're in a kind of overwhelmed-by-life stupor or they're depressed...not necessarily acting out passive-aggressive disregard for their mate.

The only reason I mention it is that a husband who is seriously unaware of how self-absorbed his behavior is, but who would be horrified at the idea of divorce, might take a wakeup call about this kind of thing seriously. Some couples do battle back from the brink. (But it would take counseling.)

I know I would have resented it terribly. But I don't know how far you and he have gone (in actual spoken work together) to try to repair your relationship. Has it been a silent emotional struggle on your part....or is the trouble is out there on the table between you and he's deliberately blowing it off?

(((((((((((((Plucky))))))))))))))

Hopalong

"That'll do, pig, that'll do."

Plucky

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 800
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #4 on: January 20, 2006, 06:06:28 PM »
Hi everyone and thank you for listening.  usually I don't feel this kind of thing is urgent enough to warrant posting but I just feel stuck.  I cannot progress.  I need some clear thinking.  Gloves off, everybody!

Quote
Nope. He let's me choose what I do, me him (both to an extent).
hi P (Portia?  Piggy?  an new P?)   This is a hard one for me.  Generally he does not tell me what to do at all.  But my actions are determined by what he does not do.  Since we have small children, there are many tasks, practically  around the clock that need attention.   Since he does not seem to notice or take responsibility for them, they fall to me.  So I basically spend 100% of my time doing things I have to do, and then collapsing onto the bed, from which I will have to rise early to tend to our youngest, because my H never hears him calling.   Never.

So from his point of view, which he has indeed expressed, I am always dictating what he does and he hardly has any time to pursue his own interests.  Which of course he still cultivates.  Me, I can hardly remember what my interests were at one time.  Of course his interests include sports, music, which involves spending money and time, and computer games.  All solitary pursuits, not including his children or, and this never crossed his mind, his wife.  Do I sound angry?  I hate being a nag but that is the only time he listens.

Quote
One thing.....do you ask?
Oh yes.  I used to ask nicely and give him a choice.  He always chose not to do it, or at the very least, to put it off.  Then, I started to bypass any polite way of speaking to him, and go directly to giving orders, sarcasm, and bitchiness.    This worked very well, but then I had to be angry all the time.    Now I just explain in very elemental terms why it needs to be done and why it needs to be done now.   I don't even feel any anger any more, I just know that  I cannot count on him knowing why the baby has to be fed now, instead of 2 hours from now, I have to explain the consequences in terms he will relate to:  "He'll get too hungry, little kids have faster metabolisms than you do, and 2 hours is a very long time for them.  So he will start to cry and scream, and you won't be able to hear your game anyway.  Then he will wake up early and I have to leave so you'll have to get up and feed him."  This seems to work, although sometimes he acts as if I am condescending.

So he does do lots of things I ask for, but in the way a bad minimum wage employee would - no initiative, no memory, no understanding, no willingness, no helpful attitude.  And each time my disdain for him grows.  In the recent past, this was anger but now I generally just feel ickiness.

Thanks for the soup! Yummy!

Quote
Well, if this were an isolated incident, I would suggest you might be reacting too strongly to use it as a reason for getting a divorce but even as an isolated incident, I think you are well within your rights to feel hurt.  Somehow, I think it is not an isolated incident.  It probably sums up in one episode a lot of what is going on in your marriage?

Hi Sugarre,
Correct.  This is a slice of life for me.  If my H were home all day, it would be thing after thing just like this all day long.   But then I think, if I get divorced, I won't even have the reluctant help I do have!  However, I think my spirit will be a lot lighter!

I know for a fact that my H is completely different in other contexts.  At his job, he uses a kind tone of voice we never hear him use at home.  For people working for him, he speaks so much more kindly than to his small boys!   He is so good at being considerate at work, so conscientious, so thoughtful.  They love him there. 

At home, he cannot remember what his children like to eat, what their schedules are or what their fave colors are.  But he can memorise the entire sports schedule for the season, all the matches at different times, time zones, etc, stats, you name it. 

[I just went off to moderate a dispute between my kids.  I told the oldest one that he had inflicted a boo-boo on the spirit of the youngest and that he did not put a bandaid on it by showing concern.  I said I didn't want him to grow up to be someone who didn't care about other people's feelings.  He replied, "But Daddy is growing up to be that kind of person."  (They think that Daddy is just the biggest kid in the house.  Hmmm......)  Anyway, I would not have believed it...What timing.]

Quote
And, I stayed for my kids but you also can leave for your kids.
Well, as usual,  the nuggets of wisdom are mind-blowing!

And my H has a drinking problem too!  not so pronounced now but I wonder once he is living alone??????  I used to enforce a drinking limit with him, but now I just let him do whatever.  As soon as he really figured out I was not going to  say anything about his drinking, he did stabilise at a certain amount.  As far as I know. 

Quote
Have you been to counseling together?
Thanks Hoppy,
We went for several months about a year ago, as my condition for not seeking a divorce right away.  It made a small difference but it was more of a band-aid.  Even though we identified major problems and simple things to work on, he still would never change anything really.  He claims he cannot remember.  But underlying it all, and he has told me this more than once, he thinks he is just fine the way he is.  In every respect.

Finally, after I realised he was cutting, I convinced him to go to a T alone and this seems to have led toward him accepting that our relationship was over.    I need for him to be looked after so I don't have to deal with cutting, drinking, whatever when the time comes to really do it.

Over years I have talked and yelled, and begged, and explained, and waited, and tried to do more, and be happy with less.  I have tried to shut down my needs and wants and just be a robot looking after everyone else.   I've tried to seek outlets in reading to sublimate my need for adult contact and communication.   Nothing works too well, and I feel like I'm walking dead...just waiting to finish my work and die.   That last little spark of life is finally clicking in and my children are very perceptive.   I might be trying to act as if things are normal but they know better.

Hoping I'm still
Plucky
« Last Edit: January 20, 2006, 06:20:14 PM by Plucky »

Surrounded

  • Jr. Member
  • **
  • Posts: 50
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #5 on: January 20, 2006, 07:20:11 PM »
It is exhausting taking care of everyone and while you are at it trying to figure out what you are doing.  It is exhausting.  I'm sure you can handle the physical demands of the kids.  You are a tough lady.  Although, it seems to be the mental stuff that is tormenting. 

I can totally relate to a lot of what you are saying.  The mental torment is the worst of it it seems.  Is today the day?  Or can I stand this another few years?  2 years?  5 years?  Ten maybe?  No....today. 

Sometimes I feel I stay only because H would be harder to be divorced from than married to.  Hang in there, you will know.  Mostly, I hope (pray in my heart) constantly for peace.  Just peace.  The rest I can handle.  And I know I will know what to do when the right time comes.  And in the meantime, protect yourself.  Detach, a little.  You probably won't change him.  But don't let him change you. 

I am starting to stand up to H just recently and although he doesn't like it and pulls out every behavior he can think of to pull me off center,  I WILL stand my ground.  And inch by inch, gain back myself and my self respect. 

No, he doesn't help with the kids.  Ever.  All 6 of them.  He has probably changed maybe 20 diapers all together.  I, too, stay for the kids.  But I am SOOO worried that they will see this sick game we play trying to be a family.  I can see some of them as voiceless.  Although I try to keep that from being the way they are, they still have to deal with this N H who is just a big child.  I stay to keep as much of his torment from reaching them as possible. 

For now.   

Just hope for peace of mind and heart and some sort of guidance or sign or anything.....whatever works for you.

jordanspeeps

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 193
  • tiffany
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #6 on: January 20, 2006, 08:09:59 PM »
Hi Plucky,

I'm sorry to hear you're struggling emotionally, and you are in my thoughts and prayers.  When I'm agonizing over decisions I use time-tested mantras and cliches to help me through confusing times.  Because I never really received motherwit or other little life lessons from my grandmothers, aunts and mother, I began to cling to tried and true laws and -isms in difficult times.  And lately, I remind myself:
 
that A tree is known by the fruit it bears, translation:
"If it walks and talks and acts like he's incompetent for husband-hood, then he probably IS a duck!!  (my own) :o

to Trust your instincts, they generally don't lie,

and that Doubt means Don't.

I hope you find some encouragement in that. I hate to know that such a thoughtful, kind, long-suffering person is hurting so.  (((((((((Plucky))))))))) and best of luck whatever your decision.  Listen to Plucky's heart and remember, your kids will probably find suprising security and esteem in having an emotionally available, satisfied, mother rather than a depressed, exhausted, and resentful one (kids tend to be practically psychic in picking this up in their parents).  Best wishes to you.

Tiffany

mia

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 37
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #7 on: January 20, 2006, 08:55:55 PM »
((PLUCKY))

So sorry.  I wish I had some good advice to give. 
Just know that you deserve better and that you have tried and tried to make it work.

Best wishes.
mia

Plucky

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 800
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #8 on: January 21, 2006, 01:23:08 AM »
Quote
Just hope for peace of mind and heart and some sort of guidance or sign or anything.....whatever works for you.

Thank you Surrounded.  Especially for stepping up to soothe me when your own situation sounds totally vomit-provoking.  Your man sounds like such a jerk and you have 6.....I am in total awe of you!

I feel that the statement my son made was a sign.  Just as I was finally writing about it to you, my friends with whom I can discuss it all, he comes up with that gem.  And in the process reminds me in his innocent way that to them, Daddy is one of the kids.

My H even argued with me whether the queen in the most powerful figure on chess!  Come on!

I bought a book today about telling kids about divorce.    One small step for me, one great step for the divorce process.

Plucky

Plucky

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 800
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #9 on: January 21, 2006, 01:28:13 AM »
Thank you Tiffany,
I was having trouble hearing my inner voice.  My inner voice was saying, leave.  No, it's not that bad.  Well actually, it is pretty bad.  No stay, it's going to be too hard.   It's partly your fault anyway....etc.    I was exhausted trying to hear a clear message.  Now I am starting to feel a little clearer.   

One thing that helped me along was hearing people with horrible childhood experiences talk about the wondeful relationships they have now.  Thank you for that glimpse into your world.  Of course I am jealous.  But the main thing I got out of it was that what I have is so far from what is possible that I am really settling at a low point.   So thank you for that.
Plucky

Plucky

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 800
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #10 on: January 21, 2006, 01:34:59 AM »
Quote
The only reason I mention it is that a husband who is seriously unaware of how self-absorbed his behavior is, but who would be horrified at the idea of divorce, might take a wakeup call about this kind of thing seriously. Some couples do battle back from the brink.

Hi Hoppy,
my husband would rather break up than change.  I hoped for ages he would open up, see the light, etc.  He now says that he cares for me but the way he cares for me is not enough for me.  His way is to go to work and some home on time.  That is a good thing.  But I would also like a person who talks and listens to me, who touches me now and then, who spontaneously notices that I need help, am not feeling well, or got my hair done, at least sometimes, and who makes eye contact and responds audibly when I talk or ask a question. 

Right now when I say something to him, I have to say "did you hear me?" because he normally says nothing and does not look at me.    Couple this with his unacknowledged hearing loss and for me it was maddening but now I just force his answer and move on.

I'm grateful to have a place to blab on.
Plucky

Marta

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 281
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #11 on: January 21, 2006, 05:29:51 AM »
Hi Plucky,

First of all, how is this not urgent? You are thiniing about a divorce, and you are sick! Don't be so apologetic in talking about yourself!

While men do happen to do weird things sometimes, the little voice in your heart also tells you whether he has crossed the line or not. I am all the way with Sugarre, its not this one thing alone. He won't even TALK to you. NO, that is NOT normal in a healthy relationship.

Quote
So he does do lots of things I ask for, but in the way a bad minimum wage employee would -

This is terrible. Why not insist on some hired help for the household?

I also agree with Sela, you have to ask for what you need. FOr this, you have to know what your needs are. Why not ask him tomorrow to help out with house chores as you are sick? THen you'd have taken this one step farther and the answers will become clearer and clearer in your mind.

If he is ruthless in business, he'll probably be ruthless in divorce settlement, he's already given you an inkling of that. However, courts don't run according to his likes and dislikes. There are laws. It means that you may have to put up a fight, unfortunately.

If the basis of this marriage is you being subservient, then why not become more assertive and see where it goes? BTW, why is music a solitary activity, unless he chose to make it so?


Cadbury

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 248
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #12 on: January 21, 2006, 06:00:51 AM »
((((Plucky))))

This is such a hard situation for you. I know how you feel, my ex-husband was a really nice man (not N) and when I was thinking of divorce I was thinking all the kinds of things you are thinking now. I have been divorced fom him for over a year now and although I am having huge problems with the exN idiot sperm donor, I am over all a lot happier.

It sounds insane but to be honest, having no help at all is a LOT easier than having unwilling help, or non-existant help. I find I am a lot calmer even if I am busier because everything is down to me. I don't harbour any resentment towards someone else, because there is no one else and this does seem infinitely better than when I was with either my exhubby or my exN. Everything is on my terms and I am getting to like that more and more. I feel I am finding out who I am after so long of trying to be what others moulded me in to.

Yes, it may well be hard for a while. Your children will be happy if you are happy. I told my children (now 5 and 3, plus baby) as much as I felt was appropriate to their ages and always made time to listen to their worries and they have coped fantastically well with it all. The two girls see their father twice a week and we still get on well. There have been hard times when things got on top of me, but over all I am better for having made the break. I think it is because I have finally done what was best for me. THink of yourself first and make yourself happy... :)

Take care, I hope it is okay. You are definitely still Plucky!

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13616
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #13 on: January 21, 2006, 08:01:55 AM »
Sounds to me like counseling for just a few months really might be abandoning ship...I wish he hadn't quit on you.

All those things you describe seem so much like communication problems, they truly do.

He says he cares for you...but you're exhausted and angry. Same time, you do want him to spontaneously recognize what you need. (You're right, it should be obvious. But I recall hearing/reading so many people say that this--wanting "mind reading"-- is where so many marriages get derailed...in not being able to communicate clearly and with a cooperative spirit.)

Makes me so sad to think that your spirit is crushed. I know it can heal.

And especially with young kids, running everything (remember what trouble you have with perfectionism, dear Plucky), can run you into the earth.

I wonder...could counseling for your own sake on the subject of perfectionism (regardless of what you ultimately decide about perfectionism)...be a good step for you to take?

I have thought back a thousand times about whether or not I should have stayed married to my child's Dad until she was 18 (I left him when she was six). There is no question but that she was deeply scarred by our divorce. She cried herself to sleep every night for six months...and at 25, she's still not healed.

But at the time, I felt that my own spirit was breaking. So I still can't think of what other way I could have found. (We did marriage counseling too, briefly. But when the counselors asked him to have an alcoholism evaluation, since I said he had a problem and he said he didn't, he refused. And that pretty much did it. The last straw was when he was cruel to my D one night--wouldn't say goodnight to her in order to hurt ME--and let her cry herself to sleep. The next day I told him it was over.)

But if he had not had that moment of being cruel to her, I don't know...

(((((((((((((((((((((Plucky)))))))))))))))))))))))

"That'll do, pig, that'll do."

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13616
Re: Struggling with decision
« Reply #14 on: January 21, 2006, 08:03:27 AM »
Sorry, I meant this:

on the subject of perfectionism (regardless of what you ultimately decide about the marriage)...be a good step

Hugs,
Hopalong
"That'll do, pig, that'll do."