Author Topic: Is it ok to say: "I hate you."?  (Read 32625 times)

reallyME

  • Guest
Re: Is it ok to say: "I hate you."?
« Reply #120 on: September 26, 2007, 06:54:19 PM »
Quote
Carolyn: Laura, I just want to tell you that I think you've set some awesome examples here on the board and I've learned a great deal from you through all this. About that ball flyin into my face fear... lol.. I was hopin for a slightly shorter name for it, but okay : )
Thing is, words flying at me have the same effect as small round objects... but maybe not so much anymore. Thanks.

Guess how I knew it was fear?  Cause for years I was the child who ran from those balls and ducked and screamed. :)

Stormchild

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1183
  • It's about becoming real.
    • Gale Warnings
Re: Is it ok to say: "I hate you."?
« Reply #121 on: September 26, 2007, 08:59:14 PM »
Stormchild,

I am not sure why people would want to go back and read anything, when the issue at hand is here on this thread.  What are you trying to prove?  Whose feelings are you protecting yours and others, or only yours?  Personally, my motive is to protect everyone's feelings, not just my own.  I have a hard time understanding your motives since you rarely apologize, and seem to want to prove something.  Criticizing is not what my friends typically do to me, either, so not sure why this is considering gentle or loving?  If there's a need to criticize, OK, but at this point in my journey, I believe I'm doing just fine, thank you very much.

I would like to modify my original request to you.  If I address you directly, I think its only fair that you should get the opportunity to respond.

What I hate (I admit it, I hate this behavior, but not you) is when I post a very sensitive, very thought provoking and personal post about something painful that is happening with me, either at home or work, and it seems you minimize the pain by announcing to others (not me, but others) that I need to do something.

You criticize and use me as an example, it seems, and I find this dehumanizing.  That is the behavior that needs to stop as I feel harrassed by it.

This dialogue is the exception to the "do not respond to me or talk about me" - what I meant by that is please do not refer to me in an oblique manner, or use me as an example.  This feels like a personal attack when you do this.  can you understand?  do you understand?

bean

Bean, get over yourself. I've been working on this post for the last hour. Sit on it and rotate, I'm not here to meet the schedule demands of abusive twerps.

Now.  IF you went back and read those threads, you would see that I do indeed apologize. There on those threads I apologized to both Sela and Hops, in great sincerity, for things that definitely merited an apology on my part.

They then acted in breathtakingly bad faith towards me, in a matter of minutes, and they have done so, where I am concerned, ever since.

It is they, at this point, who are long, long overdue to apologize to me.

But we're not really interested in facts here, are we? We're merely interested in indulging our personal dislikes. Facts might interfere with that. Facts might get in the way.

Now: let's get down to it, shall we.

Here's the problem in a nutshell.

Sela and Hops, and CB as well, all have at least one alienated child.

I, by contrast, AM an alienated child of an abusive mother.

Well... right there, you have the potential for a nice combustible mixture, not to mention a good old fashioned middle school level three-against-one girl gang.

Hops has made much loud lamentation about her lost chick. Much garnering of sympathy, much clucking and fussing. Much theatrical tearing of hair and rending of garments and wondering where it all went so wrong...

Sela has also put in a great deal of time and effort detailing how cruelly she's been treated in the past...

But ah, you'd better not respond by asking, no matter how gently, if there might be anything Hops or Sela did that was dysfunctional, counterproductive, or harmful in their situations. You'd better not respond by wondering if perhaps the child had reason, or thinks they did, to be alienated in whatever way they have been. In Sela's case, you'd better not even speak critically of phoniness, or condescension, or anything else that reveals your ability to recognize abusers in disguise.

God, no. It's all, always, other people's fault. Hops and Sela are wronged innocents unjustly suffering, who never had an unkind thought or did an unkind thing to anyone in all their exalted, saintly life.

What is wrong with this picture?

Look at the viciousness here, and their EXULTATION in it. Look at the orgy of meanness that has been indulged in, here, over the past 24 hours.

This is not the behavior of wronged innocents.

It is the behavior of stone solid 24 carat 99.99% isotope enriched abusers.

I can't come out and say that, though. There's a taboo on that much directness here [unless, of course, it's aimed at the reigning bullies' current preferred target].

Well, the hell with the taboo. I'm going to say it, right here, in front of God and everybody.

My experience of Sela and Hops is that they have both been as dishonest and abusive in their dealings with me, as mean and as vicious to me, as they are capable of being.

My experience.

Starting with those threads that you are too good to read because they're irrelevant. Sure they are, kid. Sure they are. And the check's in the mail, and he'll respect you in the morning. Yep. Sure.

And they cover it up with a phony veneer of gushing goodwill, which fools most of the people most of the time, because most of us still haven't learned that this kind of behavior - this gushing, gooey, phony sweetness - is the bait that abusers use to get us to lower our guard.

I don't hate them any more than I hate wasps, scorpions, or rattlesnakes. But that's pretty much where I have them pegged, at this point. Firmly in the category of Nasty Venomous Creatures.

It sickens me, though, to see people so easily fooled. So easily duped by the gushing and goo, so easily taken in by the sugar coated s--t, as someone brilliantly described it. So utterly oblivious to the viciousness. The meanness. The unholy joy taken in it.

I can't fix that. I didn't cause it, I don't control it, and I cannot cure it.

But oh, honey, I can blog about it.

Not about them. There are millions just like them. About the behaviors. About the disguises. About what makes up the pretense, and what's really likely to be beneath it.

I ought to know, after all. I've been fending it off all my life. The only thing that keeps the abused from becoming an abuser is insight, awareness, and sheer determination not to go there.

I don't always succeed, but I'm way the hell ahead of the competition on this thread.


« Last Edit: September 26, 2007, 09:06:43 PM by Stormchild »
The only way out is through, and the only way to win is not to play.

"... truth is all I can stand to live with." -- Moonlight52

http://galewarnings.blogspot.com

http://strangemercy.blogspot.com

http://potemkinsoffice.blogspot.com

reallyME

  • Guest
Re: Is it ok to say: "I hate you."?
« Reply #122 on: September 26, 2007, 09:27:47 PM »
Storm:
Quote
Bean, get over yourself. I've been working on this post for the last hour. Sit on it and rotate, I'm not here to meet the schedule demands of abusive twerps.

Woah Storm!  What is wrong?  You sound so angry and hurt here.  Is that how you are feeling about all this? 

I think Bean has been doing some good work with her therapist to reclaim her dignity and voice, from what I've seen and Hops just is one who speaks her mind and shares her feelings.

Do you also have anything that upsets you about me?  I'm leaving myself an open target to take some of the blows for the others here...a sort of "savior" if you will.

It's good for you to get your feelings out and to be heard.  So, I'm listening, Stormchild.

~Laura

Sela

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1273
Re: Is it ok to say: "I hate you."?
« Reply #123 on: September 26, 2007, 09:30:54 PM »
I have emailed Dr. G


Dr. Richard Grossman

  • Moderator
  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 858
    • http://www.voicelessness.com
Re: Is it ok to say: "I hate you."?
« Reply #124 on: September 26, 2007, 09:39:23 PM »
Hi everyone,

I'm going to give Sela, Hops, and Bean one more chance to respond to Storm's latest post, and then I'm going to lock this thread.  I think everything that needs to be said will then be said, and I would ask that the parties in conflict refrain from contacting each other on the board or by PM--and that they refrain from referring to each other either directly or obliquely.  I will also lock Bean's thread "Feeling harrassed or feeling bullied", and cats Paw's thread "On Stormchild--my thoughts", since these threads refer to the ongoing conflict. 

Best,

Richard
« Last Edit: September 26, 2007, 09:42:04 PM by Richard Grossman »

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13616
Re: Is it ok to say: "I hate you."?
« Reply #125 on: September 26, 2007, 10:37:46 PM »
I don't need to address Storm, have already placed that boundary. I'll just update my story for people who weren't here then. I will talk about Storm here but then not again. I am sorry for her bitter view of monstrous people everywhere, but I'm sure her life has given her reason to feel that way. I'm just no longer participating as one of the Objects of Explication. Not willingly, anyway.

I had a huge crisis with my D (26) about a year ago. She raged at me and blamed me for all of her suffering. (I divorced, twice, as did her father, and I moved with her, and he was alcoholic, and then he died...while they were in conflict, so she never got to resolve things with him. And, she had made some excruciating choices she was still struggling with.) It was terribly painful to be the target of her pent-up rage. She'd never gotten any help, other than from me. I was exhausted from work stress, frightened, deeply hurt, and full of guilt. We had been too close for too long, and...well, she differentiated herself but good. I worked a lot of it through by posting here.

On the thread Storm posted, I responded to Storm's declaration that she wanted to PM me an "important but upsetting" message by saying, "you're welcome to tell me whatever" (I didn't recognise a pattern then)...and "on the board is fine". (I didn't know why it needed to be a PM...was this a secret?) She PM'd me anyway, and it was a message suggesting that my daughter had been abused and had likely come to me in her childhood wanting to tell me about it over and over but had given up on me because she found I wasn't there for her, wouldn't hear her, wasn't her ally, and I was in denial and had rebuffed her.

I have no idea where Storm got this notion (my D was never abused) except for projection, and for me that's a sad story that belongs to Storm. But her facts were off, her instincts were off, and the message was so predatory and destabilizing that I couldn't read through it at first. I felt ambushed in a private space, as though a bully had dragged me under the stairs for a swift beating. That's how critical or angry PMs strike me, so I don't send them, and if I feel someone has sent me that sort...I would block them too. For me, PM space is only for friendship. Once I eventually did read it, soon afterward I posted on the board to Storm, politely but firmly, that I had come to realize that I was not a person who could dialogue with her effectively. I just wasn't capable. And asked her: "I am asking you, sincerely, to leave me alone." I set a boundary.

I think the problem here was that I broke that boundary on impulse. (Bad ide.) I chose to speak up on Sela's behalf, objecting to Storm's post criticizing Sela's painful past problems (a year and a half before) with her daughter. Well, that was addressing something in Storm's direction, even indirectly. I find that to defy Storm's authoritarian laying down of "what the facts are" is a risky business, and dangerous particularly when you're feeling vulnerable or going through a crisis. There is...always...sooner or later, payback. So much bombast, and so much abuse of her tremendous literacy and intellectual gifts that I think could be one day, by other influences than mine, turned to love.

My D and I are not alienated at all ... haven't been for a good while. If anything, that crisis blew out a lot of dreck and we're cooperating and communicating better than ever. She's been here for a wonderful week, we call and write, we share stories and laughter, she tells me she loves me (and she has never doubted my love for her), and she's planning a dinner with her friends to celebrate her birthday when I'm down there next week. And wants me to make sure to get there in time for a private lunch with her first. I am looking forward to it.

I'm sorry about all this Sturm und Drang, but I guess it was unavoidable. I do feel better that slick pattern of stating as fact what other people's inner reality is, what their feelings are, and what their motives are, has been described by multiple people, so perhaps newbies can take whatever precaution they feel is appropriate for them. I think things would go better for everyone if Storm would stop using others' experience in such a cold way as parables, even though it's sprinkled with "...and of course she has every right to feel that way" and other friendly-sounding reassurances.

Anyone is welcome to head for the stacks and do their own hunt through old threads to see a larger view, in the context of a longer stretch of time. But I don't feel like offering any evidence other than my words here and now. That's because I'm not in a courtroom, I don't fear unkind judgement from others here and I know I am safe in this community. I trust the board.

Thank you, Doc G. I'm sorry you had to be dragged in, but I don't think people complain to you unless they feel well and truly violated, and I think you're judicious in how you manage things.

I'm sorry about the whole mess and my part in triggering it. And one last thing I will also say to Storm: I wish you peace, wholeness, trust, and many many readers, and respect and acknowledgement for all you contribute to knowledge in your blogging. In your own life, I wish you safety and love.

Thanks for listening.

love,
Hops
"That'll do, pig, that'll do."

Sela

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1273
Re: Is it ok to say: "I hate you."?
« Reply #126 on: September 27, 2007, 12:03:46 AM »
Hello everyone,

Thankyou Dr. G for your immediate help!  Truly, I did not expect such a quick response and I am really grateful that you interupted whatever you were doing to help here.

My update is similar.  My daughter and I are not alienated and actually were never alienated.  We did have some difficulties, which we worked through but we never stopped expressing our love for eachother or communicating (and I take the blame for not having the best communication skills, which I have often admitted to her, as well as here on the board).  She is away at university now and so I don't see her often and do miss her but we keep in touch, pretty much daily by text messaging and less frequently by phone calls, occasional visits, etc which helps to keep us close and connected.  I am also close with my younger daughter who will soon be going off, I expect, to further her education too.  I will miss her very much too but I am very glad my girls are going for their dreams and very proud of the wonderful people they are.

Hops, thankyou again for bravely speaking up in my defense.  You are such a wonderful friend and I am so very glad to have been blessed with experiencing your grace and kindness.   You have braved the Storm, on my behalf and for that....I can't thank you enough.  I'm so sorry you've had to endure such wrath.

Bean, thankyou too.  I'm sorry for your sadness and disappointment.  I feel the same.  At any time, Stormy, you could have stepped up to the plate and said you didn't mean to cause hurt and I might have softened.  I usually do when people take responsibility for their actions.  It's when they refuse to do so that I feel I must protect myself from further....of the same behaviour.

CB, so sorry you got dragged into this.  You said it so clearly and accurately:

Quote
You take things that are said in a moment of pain and use it to further wound the poster.

I would only add: ....... and then cry abuse!! (when people choose not to tolerate it any more).

I'm sorry for my part in this conflict in that I did yell and call out for help and I know that any conflict upsets some people and probably always will.  Thing is......when someone hurts me......I usually give them the benefit of the doubt.  When someone hurts me again, I start to lose trust big time.  When someone keeps at it and then tries to make out that I'm causing the trouble........I stop interacting.  But when someone then waits for a time when it seems I'm not here and then subtley goes for my juglar......I feel compelled to try to put a stop to it (which I knew would likely not work without Dr. G's help....once again, thankyou so much for stepping in so quickly Dr. G!).

Stormy, I'm sorry for the pain you carry and I repeat what I said awhile ago......I will pray that peace replaces whatever it is that resides in your heart.   You can have the last word if you want on this thread.


Quote
I would ask that the parties in conflict refrain from contacting each other on the board or by PM--and that they refrain from referring to each other either directly or obliquely.

I hope you will do as Dr. G has asked and leave me alone now.

Sela

PS:  Carolyn, thankyou too for your sincere post.  You have nothing to apologize for and I'm so very glad that the fear is dissolving.  (((((((Carolyn)))))))  So glad you are here!