Hi everyone:
I've been thinking about this discussion quite a bit today. In a way, it needs discussion to be fully voiced. The more voices...the better because it's not like one person has all the answers, knows all there is to know, or will say it all without missing stuff or even correctly. And it's a good thing to consider all the different viewpoints/arguments for and against/methods in regard to positive vs negative thinking. Or.....it's a complete waste of time......depending on what you decide (heehee

).
Butterfly:
Thankyou very much for the hug. I like hugs. Hugs are almost as good as chocolate (just kidding

--they really are better--besides, you can't send me chocolate over the net

). Even a little cyber hug can make my day, sometimes,

because I can imagine the person, you Butterfly, smiling, reaching out, hugging, offering warmth and kindness, security, safety, maybe a bit like mothering (because mothers hug....or they're supposed to and we are supposed to learn from them that those hugs mean something good)...and because all of those thoughts that go with that little hug are good and I feel good after that. That's a lot of yapping about one little cyber hug but I really mean it. Thanks!!
What do you do in this case:
a mother tells her daughter not to think about the boogey man in the closet when the mother leaves the room and turns off the light. Inadvertantly, the child can't help it but think about the boogey man in the closet. When someone tells you not to think about something, that's the very thing you think about.
Well, I'm with Portia in that children may not realize the power they have inside their minds because they haven't heard about it, experienced it a whole lot, or been aware that such a thing as choosing to think a certain way might help...and they don't know that they can face their fear, look for the facts, and deal with the demon head on...and live through it. They need knowledge and experience (wisdom) to fight off such scarey stuff, which usually is gained through life. So it can be very difficult for a child to deal with such a suggestion....unless they have learned the information/gained experinece about such things... elsewhere/or if they have a natural tendancy to deal with such matters in some comfortable way, which might be possible too? Mind you, a positive mother would say something like:
"Dream about good stuff tonight" or "have a nice dream" and might even ask if the child would like a night lite on.
In the real world, I know someone who's son was terrified of the boogieman (heard about it on tv) and the mother was really having a time trying to soothe her son. Finally, she bought a giant poster of Mr. T (do you remember Mr. T??) and hung it on her son's wall. Once, I visited and asked about the poster and her son said, very confidently:
"Oh...that's Mr. T! He won't let any bad guys into my room! Not even the boogieman!!! He beats 'em up while I'm asleep!!"
Like when your friend tells you don't think about an apple, think about an orange instead. Inevitably you gravitates towards the thought of an apple.
Unless, your friend is trying to help you and you realize it and so you decide to tell yourself that oranges are the best, you love the colour orange, the smell, the vitamin C, the sweet juice, the way they are like the sun...just before it sets/rises, that they have a wonderful orange firey glow, that round is lovely, that the seeds are white and clean and are great for spitting at pictures of you enemies and........
Inevitably, (to steal your word), your thinking will be focussed on oranges and apples may become less appealing, especially if you take the time to discourage your desire for apples (by thinking that apples get mushy too fast, contain worms sometimes, are often too tart, have thick skin that gets stuck in your teeth, and their seeds are dark and small and hardly ever germinate when planted in a cup of soil, and that you don't like the smell of apples as well as oranges, and apples aren't as round as oranges, and you can easily bruise and apples aren't worth thinking about.........).
And double especially....if you do this consistently, with specific frequency, giving your full effort to it because you know it will help.
That's how I would handle it, as an adult, if I wanted to think about oranges (as my friend suggested I do, and if I thought that was a good suggestion, that I wanted to try to implement). It is work...no kidding.
I find this is true for negative vs. positive thinking. I try to think positive, but the very thought of trying to stay away from the negative sneaks up on me without my control. What would you do in this case?
Honestly, as Portia said...sometimes you can't ignor the negative and as Brigid said....trauma/loss takes us to a negative place. We do have to deal with the feelings and the nasty junk that upsets us....we have to grieve and release our feelings...we have to be negative sometimes... but we don't have to deal with it alllllllllllllllll of the time....even when we're going through it, imo. We can stop and give ourselves a break. There's no law that says we can't!
There is no time limit and no way to estimate when a person will, if ever, feel like they have returned to the state they were in previous to the trauma/loss (or any state near it)....so what's the use of staying in soley in negative mode? We do have to grieve our losses and do so thoroughly and release the feelings that trauma and loss generate but.........
Not alllllllll today.....all the time......every single day.
That's mho. Sometimes......a little at a time....is enough because it allows for healing inbetween grieving.
So.......you're trying to think positively and the negative just creeps up and sneaks into your head?
Stop. Do you have to let those thoughts take over? Or....Do you really need to go there for awhile and get something out? Only you can decide.
If it feels so strong that it just won't quit then it might be time to get those bongo drums out, a box of kleenex, and a pad and paper.....and write, write, write...negative crap for 15 minutes without stopping. Feel worse??
Cry, cry, cry and really feel the hurt and really let 'er loose. Now you're mad?? Wipe eyes with kleenex and proceed to bongo drums and beat the you know what outta them for a few minutes, an hour, a couple of days......(just kidding again--

).
Whatever it takes to deal with the feelings......good. Do it! As Larry the Cable guy (who I really shouldn't mention) would say: "Get 'er done!!!"
But I might add.......not all at once...it can't be done!!(did I say can't?? well...maybe it can....I don't know for sure

). It just seems to be more sensible to rest inbetween agonizing.

Give nourishment to our emotional state......feed ourselves some good thoughts....inbetween all the yucky stuff.
So after the great bongo beating, pillow punching, paper ripping upping episode seems to have released enough agony for one sitting/stomping/jumping session.... then......decide.....ok enough. Time to do something else. All doesn't have to happen in one episode.
Then there is a conscious....stubborn.....persistent......attempt made to focus on something else.....something positive.....something you like, enjoy, want, dream of, remember that was nice, will be doing soon, someone you enjoy being around, something that makes you smile, etc...anything......to take control of your thoughts and be in charge, in a positive way....for a period of time that you......
choose.
And when those little nasty, negative thoughts start creeping back in, the sneaky little buggers

......you have to take control and say to yourself:
"Wait a minute!! I'm not going to think about that right now! I'm busy thinking about this........." and do it!!
Or: "No way. I'm done thinking like that for awhile. Now where was I....oh yes.....chocolate!!!!!!!! UMMMMMMM!!! Yummy!"
Takes practice and patience, like everything else. The benefits???
Guaranteed = some pleasant, comfortable, enjoyable moments in your messed up, traumatized, grief striken life. Those moments are entirely up to you/me to create...at will....with effort...over time. They are ours to seek out and embrace and keep in mind.
Ofcourse, there are lot's of other things to do besides a few fleeting positive thinking sessions to help ourselves heal...it's just that it seems to really begin...with a thought.
I will heal.
And another thought.
I don't have to think about this any more.
ETC.
I know I stay in the same cold, dark, lonely, awful place....without that one initial positive thought....which if I grab ahold of it.....if I choose to hang onto it......will lead to another and another and soon....I am crawling out of the pit of despair and onto rich soil (that's why my fingernails are kept short---

---it's easier to brush 'em clean!!!).
The point is....others can suggest all they like.....but IIIIIIIII have to do the actual thinking. I have to decide to take the suggestion or think of a better one. I have to start my own positive thought process...
(unless.....someone like Butterfly....gives me a cyber hug.....and then it just seems to start up like magic)...and after that....come the positive feelings that follow those good thoughts.....and maybe after that....a little positive action (on my part!!!

)....and sometimes, life is good.
The most serious of all statements:
Think what you choose.GFN