Teja, you been in my head?
That was my EXACT pattern for 20+ years with men.
A year ago I ended my last Nbf relationship. He was overwhelmingly haughty, but swarmed me with instant fusion on our first date...all those flags. Silly beagle, I walked right into it, but I look back and truly do believe he was my LAST N. Or last deeply distubed man, at any rate.
This has been exciting and I want to share it: in the last month I have said NO after two first dates. The first guy was pompous, curt to a very sweet waitress (she was invisible), and presented himself as a victim. I knew I didnt want another date. He emailed asking for another and I replied very courteously that I had enjoyed meeting him (it's true, he was interesting) and it was a pleasant lunch, but I honestly didn't feel that sense of "fit" for me. But I thanked him sincerely for driving to meet me, wished him a peaceful winter, beautiful spring, etc. (I was kind and gentle, iow.) He wrote back a BLAST of accusation, blaming, accusation. Jekyll and Hyde. Saved myself a whole bad relationship! I held firm and that was that.
Same thing, much shorter, with another man. He took me for tea. First thing he talked about was how he wants babies (he's 59 and said there was nothing inappropriate about that at all, he just hadn't found an interested 35 y/o. And how he hates and was victimized by his Ex.) I decided right away. So he called a few weeks later asking me to do something and I said no, just too busy to schedule anything at all.
I can't believe it. It really did feel all right. I figure I'm saving them some anguish too so in a way it's probably a kind thing. They were both pissed, but I really feel for the first time in my life I'm catching on to this thing... I really am not hostile. But I'm catching on that just because a man wants something, I don't have to go against my instincts to please him. It has to be reciprocal or I don't want any part of it.
Hopalong