Author Topic: Am I being 'cheap'?  (Read 1694 times)

WRITE

  • Guest
Am I being 'cheap'?
« on: May 21, 2007, 11:26:25 PM »
A friend asked me to help organise a party for his girlfriend, another friend.
I was happy too and offered to get balloons and the cake as my gift.
However the whole thing has now spiraled as these things do.
First we were getting bowling shirts, they were $45 each so I said I didn't want one and the host got me one as a thank you gift.
Now the 'party' is going to cost $32 each.
So that particular evening will cost me around $80.

I don't mind exactly but I have a lot of friends and this scenario is getting more and more common that they want expensive things.
The last one was a Greek restaurant costing $100 for my family....

I don't remember this being an issue before, we used to just have a few drinks or a BBQ and throw in a few pounds each for a gift and a cake.

I sort-of resent being expected to spend money I haven't budgeted for on things I don't see as essential.

Am I being unreasonable?

Hopalong

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 13619
Re: Am I being 'cheap'?
« Reply #1 on: May 21, 2007, 11:36:44 PM »
Imho, Write...NO! You're not being unreasonable!

People can be very entitled about others' finances when it's "for a good cause" or to "celebrate someone's something." I really resent it.

And I've finally learned to speak up, say No, say I'd be happy to spend $10 or $20 or whatever my limit is.

Good for you.

Hops
"That'll do, pig, that'll do."

Portia

  • Guest
Re: Am I being 'cheap'?
« Reply #2 on: May 22, 2007, 06:20:57 AM »
So many people seem to spend money they don't have, too. It's like an attitude of approaching doom, so spend and be damned. It shocks and amazes me. £30,000 of debt on the credit cards? No worries.  What will we do when the empire falls this time? i have no idea!

Are you being unreasonable in not wanting to be profligate with your hard-earned cash?

If other folks want to spend their lives in debt, it's up to them. I just won't join them. I call it being irresponsible and in the end, selfish. Someone has to pay, sometime.

If it was me, I'd say no thanks to the shirt, seriously. It would be of no use and an unwelcome gift (do these friends of mine know anything about me and my life and do they care?) edit in: someone did once give me a shirt as a gift/payment in kind when I'd specifically requested something different (something in the $5 range). Yah, that said a lot. So, bit of a sore point there write!

No wonder I don't have many friends eh! :roll:
« Last Edit: May 22, 2007, 06:30:28 AM by Portia »

poetprose

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 159
Re: Am I being 'cheap'?
« Reply #3 on: May 22, 2007, 06:32:57 AM »
No!! you are not being cheap at all

In fact I would go as far as tallying up all the cost of this bash, (with exception of the cake and balloons), as you did offer, but tally up the cost of the entire party and divide it all between everyone, then get the money up front , book your spot, restraunt etc..

Portia

  • Guest
Re: Am I being 'cheap'?
« Reply #4 on: May 22, 2007, 07:03:12 AM »
I went away wondering why this annoyed me so:

Quote
First we were getting bowling shirts, they were $45 each so I said I didn't want one and the host got me one as a thank you gift.

Write, you said didn't want one (to the host?). What is in the person's mind when they get you one, if it was the same person? I was thinking: is this like 'charity' because they think I can't afford one; is it because they want to coerce me into this group thing where we all wear the same shirt etc. I feel like I'm being bullied into wearing a dumb shirt that i don't want and have said I don't want. I'm being ignored and controlled in the nicest way possible so that I can't complain. Hmmm. What would I do....if it were me... I'd back out, but then that's what I do. I'd rather not go than be - all that stuff. It sounds too much like enforced fun!

JanetLG

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 681
  • 'I am NOT 'difficult'!
Re: Am I being 'cheap'?
« Reply #5 on: May 22, 2007, 10:41:53 AM »
Write,

How you spend your money is YOUR business - can you bring yourself to work out a 'return version' of what they have done to you, and explain it back to them, using a scenario that they might understand?

My husband and I went out to dinner once, with another couple that we knew well. Between arranging it in the morning and going out that evening, a mutual friend who had just split up with her husband was added to the night out (that was no problem). Then another couple, that we didn't know, was added to the group. Not quite so 'cosy' a meal out, then, but we didn't mind too much.

At the restaurant, though, this last couple ordered every course on the menu, the most expensive stuff, with wine (me and my husband don't drink), and at the end of the evening it was this couple that suggested 'let's split the bill 7 ways'. Now, the original couple we'd agreed to go out with knew that we don't like doing that, as we have small appetites, so often leave out one or even two courses, so it's not fair to split the bill. But we were embarrasssed, so we paid up, and spent THREE TIMES what we would have paid for just what we ourselves ate.

We promised ourselves after that, that we'll always say up front that our bill for the two of us is all we're paying, and others can make their own arrangements. It might sound mean, but it's amazing that once you've said this, the meal choices of others get less extravagant!

One way we explain it is like this:  suppose me and you went into a clothes shop. I chose a pair of jeans, and you chose a pair of socks. When we get to the checkout, I say,' Let's go halves on this!' Not fair, is it? Any 'sharing of expenses' should be MUTUALLY agreed, otherwise it's just financial bullying, in my opinion.

I think what I'm trying to say is if this kind of thing is becoming a habit amongst your friends, then let it be known that you have a policy, but others are welcome to decide for themselves. Difficult at first, but they'll get used to it.

Hope this helps a bit!

Janet


debkor

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 1070
Re: Am I being 'cheap'?
« Reply #6 on: May 22, 2007, 11:57:37 AM »
Write,

No you are not being cheap.  I hate when things get so blown up and expensive.  It takes the fun out of things and the enjoyment turns to anxiety about what you are spending. What we do (friends) is we all chip in together 10$,20$ and give a gift card for the person to get what they really want. Then we have cake and coffee just sit and talk, laugh.

Love
Deb

WRITE

  • Guest
Re: Am I being 'cheap'?
« Reply #7 on: May 22, 2007, 03:16:49 PM »
I think part of it is I hate being micro-managed in any way shape or form.

But part of it is around gifts in general, in fact at my last therapy session my therapist left me with a comment on a book I had rushed to read so I could lend it to her...I suspect she thinks I give away too much or have too many expectations around gift giving/receiving.

It does all seem to have become a stress-fest in recent years.

Didn't we used to be quite pleased just to receive something or give something? I do remember slight disappointments on birthdays but in general it was the whole festival atmosphere I enjoyed- which now seems to be lacking because everything's all plastic-packaged, over-trimmed, high maintenance and expensive!

Janet, I learned when I first emigrated to keep costs separate, in our culture it is common to do this politeness dance over shared expenses with each trying to pay. Do it here and the other person looks at you, says, okay, and that's it- you pay!

Several times when there's been a splitting of the tab I have seen people stiff the tip or once the hostess tried to get me to pay as if it were full-price for my son, when it was just a kid's meal, the difference was about $12 and the accountant sitting by me immediately intervened.

I probably wouldn't let something spoil an event but it does make me choosy about who I go out with and how the finances are set up. I never get really close to someone who is very mean with money though so it doesn't matter relationship-wise.

afraid that they "won't like you'

no, I know they like me Ami, and if I do speak up they will wordlessly pick up the bill for me. I have a bit of a reputation for speaking out, these are people who when they first started dating each other I pulled them on one side and said they were embarrassing me with their touching, I've also told the group not to drink so much around me! No one would be a bit surprised if I said no, but I also know that I can be a bit fanatical so I was trying to go with the flow.

It's just the flow seems to get out of hand....

It sounds too much like enforced fun

exactly Portia.

They also want me to join the bowling league they set up which is what the shirts have morphed into- a weekly commitment. I have declined that, though I am appreciative that they want me around too. When I first came here I knew no one, it is nice to 'belong' a bit.

You know over the years I have hosted tons of good parties and I can tell you the secret- spontenaity. If someone starts the singing or dancing, go with it, if it is a great conversation let it carry on. A successful party 'flows', the host just pulls it together when things flag or there's a problem.

If other folks want to spend their lives in debt, it's up to them. I just won't join them. I call it being irresponsible and in the end, selfish. Someone has to pay, sometime.

the whole debt thing is scary isn't it.
I know people who will perhaps never be out of debt....and it's  not just in the US. Ex's sister has had so many lucky breaks financially over the years and blown it every time on unnecessary stuff and holidays. She is always looking for someone else's money to spend!

I don't know what I think about the shirt being 'charity' Portia. I don't feel bad about wearing it so long as I haven't had to buy it! Part of our culture was this strong 'pay your way' thing even when it wasn't necessary and over the years I have been pretty bad about taking things and receiving things, always felt better about being on the giving end.

I have been trying to get away from that because it can feel like no one does something nice for me....then I have to remind myself I didn't let them.

Some of my friends and I have arrangements on financial things, like we go to somewhere cheaper now I am not rich, or eat at home, or one friend always buys me lunch at my favourite place on the condition it's the one near her home so I have the long drive there and back....ex and I have an arrangement for the summer that he gave me extra money because he wants me to work less and be home with son. I couldn't do that if he didn't.

People can be very entitled about others' finances when it's "for a good cause"

that's funny Hops, I got a letter just yesterday from the UU church I used to attend saying they have identified me as a non-member who shows an interest in the church, so can I pledge some cash please! I get charity requests almost every day, often in the form of pretty labels accompanying a 'donation' envelope. My son's school I spoke to the PTA a long tiem ago and reminded them the children have far more than enough there, we really don't need to raise so much money; some people were shocked I think, they had never thought there could be 'enough'....

The whole topic is much more emotional than I thought.

edit in: someone did once give me a shirt as a gift/payment in kind when I'd specifically requested something different

this is my experience with ex. I am so easy to please for gifts, a CD or book of poetry, yet he often gives me what he thinks I should want. In fact recently I have found myself putting off his gifts, they have felt very much like a display of 'look what you are missing!'

It's worth it  :D

How you spend your money is YOUR business

to finish this essay (! ) I don't think it is Janet! The common sales tactic here is find out how much someone is willing to spend- note I don't say 'can afford'- then add some on and sell them what fits the price.

It always feels dishonourable and disengenious to me.

I want to look at a proce- the FINAL price- early on in my thought processes and be left alone to make my mind up, not have a game. Other cultures are different about this of course.


Portia

  • Guest
Re: Am I being 'cheap'?
« Reply #8 on: May 23, 2007, 09:04:33 AM »
Write

Quote
You know over the years I have hosted tons of good parties and I can tell you the secret- spontenaity. If someone starts the singing or dancing, go with it, if it is a great conversation let it carry on. A successful party 'flows', the host just pulls it together when things flag or there's a problem.


I'd come to your party :D Agreed. Fun happens!

Quote
The common sales tactic here is find out how much someone is willing to spend- note I don't say 'can afford'- then add some on and sell them what fits the price.

There was an older film with oh i forget, about two men selling metal cladding for homes in the US. And one guy goes to buy a car. The salesman says: " and how much would you be willing to pay for a car like this?" A car! No way! Cars have fixed prices within a couple hundred pounds and that's it!

I really dislike haggling and yes, i like to see a price and pay it. I don't like the 'game' in haggling, I think it devalues both parties. And it wastes so much time!

(About the shirt, i thought you really didn't want it, and now i see it wasn't that cut and dried, your views understood. Glad you do want it! The shirt I got - too small. Wahh! Another waste!)