Welcome to politics, Bones...
there are seldom straight answers... and one thing I've learned over time, is that no matter what is decided, what rule is enforced (or loosened)... someone somewhere isn't going to be happy about it. The people making decisions need to understand that it's not possible to make or keep everyone happy, all at one time. You simply have to point your sails in the direction of the best outcome for the most people.
Just because there are no simple, straight, b&w answers... doesn't mean (all the time) that the "game is rigged", or that there's something nefarious going on. It's very, very true that sometimes it does. That's why I cling to my research, look for data -- and do my own analysis -- and listen to a lot of people's opinions. The very same skill I learned in healing - to find out as much as I can, look at it a lot of different ways, then let it SIT for awhile - seems to work pretty well with political issues, too. Remember you have those skills, are an expert at using them even (!), and you'll be OK.
I still think you're going to do a lot of good on the board.