ooohhh persephone,
don't blame yourself.
It's quite amazing what a big voice the formerly voiceless can develop while they're trying to catch up!
My favorite, errr...worst...example was my church's Joys and Sorrows moment in the Sunday service. For several years, I felt COMPELLED to get up and share something, quite heartfelt but what characterized it most was the sense of urgency...with the congregation. At least every couple months. Mind you, about half a dozen people did this every Sunday. In a congregation of over 200.
It took a long time for me to recognize I was:
--using way way more than my "fair share" of the voice-time (despite how warmly and touchingly my "self-revealing" remarks were received, and they were...I still felt uncomfortable
--not actually on Oprah
Several years ago I told myself, that's it. No more, unless there is something very compelling that is truly a life changing moment or concern. And over time, the urge to disclaim (and have a crowd's attention) finally mellowed. So I'm just one. One of many. One of the members. One of the family. No longer needing more air-time than anyone else.
Where that's different is when I'm what we UU's call a "worship associate" (I don't like the term, sounds like a law firm). You do that (assisting the minister, co-planning his or her services, signing up for one about every six weeks) for two years. Once a year, you are invited to give your own sermon.
And that's where my desire to be heard by a crowd DOES make sense. It's not narcissism to have a gift for public speaking or poetry, and use it in that way. So that's been a good use of my voice.
Anyway, I so understand the cringing struggle to get a sense of balance about attention.
It does mellow, and balance, and begin to take its healthy, happy perspective, as you work on it. And your self-consciousness about it will change to self confidence. And that's grand.
Secondly, corny as it sounds, I recommend Toastmasters for a lovely, equal-sharing exercise in being heard (and supporting others).
love,
Hops