Author Topic: unrequited love - why is it so hard?  (Read 6064 times)

Dawning

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 344
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« on: November 08, 2004, 05:09:29 AM »
Hi.   :)   Does anyone have problems/issues in letting go of someone when the feeling is not mutual?  It is this area that I am so stubborn in and I get so mad at myself for my stubborness.  It has happened to me twice now in the last 6 years.  And I feel like I've made a real fool of myself.  

I think it has something to do with the loss of my father when I was around 4 years old...the loss of a proper father *figure.*  Some ancient part of me must still think that I can turn things around and suddenly the man in question - that I have strong intimate feelings for - will *wake up* and love me.  I want to let go of that hope or at least find a good way to channel it.  It really trips me up so to speak.  And I plummet into some deep place of melancholy and despair.  

I know I am not the only one who has felt unrequited love.  But sometimes it feels like that.  If anyone has any stories about what they did to overcome it and get less depressed over it, I would be grateful.  I do want a partner in my life but I don't want to settle and I am now 40 and thinking...am I really going to have to settle b/c I don't want to live alone forever.

Thanks.
"No one's life is worth more than any other...no sister is less than any brother...."

bunny

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 713
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #1 on: November 08, 2004, 10:39:22 AM »
Hi Dawning,

When you're about to addictively pursue the man again, tell yourself, "He isn't my father and that's who I really want." And stop all contact with the ambivalent man. This is very difficult as it is "counter-intuitive" to you, so I think being in therapy or a 12-step group really helps.

There is a newsgroup you might be interested in. It's also run by a psychotherapist: www.rhondafindling.com. There's a message board of women who are in dead-end relationships with ambivalent men. They are very supportive and I saw no disruptions like the ones here.

Re: having to settle. Are your expectations unrealistic? Maybe you don't have to settle. Maybe it's a question of making your expectations more grounded in reality. I'm guessing here.

bunny

Dawning

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 344
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #2 on: November 08, 2004, 10:56:09 AM »
Thanks, bunny.

I appreciate your wise comments about this as well as your suggestions.

Your question about settling has also given me pause to consider what the answer is.  

Thank you for all your support and for being on this board.

Actually, I was a hermit in a relationship w/ a man for 6 years and earlier this year, I had an encounter that confused me.  Now, I am working on letting go of that - and that addictive pursuit - (as you so wisely called it) and getting out more, meeting people.  Making a sincere attempt at responding instead of acting out or reacting.  Its not easy.  What is that called?  The imposter syndrome...I think I am dealing with that a little now.

I have decided to have no contact with my father and I'm setting limits with my mother.  It seems to be working.  Its just sad that the only way I can communicate with her is at her 6 year old level.  I time the conversations now.  Getting unconditional love from her is not going to happen either.  Detaching emotionally from one's parents is not the easiest thing in the world to do.  I guess we all know that.   :cry:  But, like you said once before, *we can learn.*
"No one's life is worth more than any other...no sister is less than any brother...."

flower

  • Guest
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #3 on: November 08, 2004, 10:16:02 PM »
Quote from: Dawning
Detaching emotionally from one's parents is not the easiest thing in the world to do.


You can say that again!!

Hi Dawning, good to see you!

I have had problems with giving up on extended relatives that didn't want to socialize with my immediate family - from my Nmom's gossip.  I kept reaching out to those relatives after they had made it clear by nonresponsiveness that they didn't want to socialize with me. I didn't get it for awhile that my mom had slandered me.  Anyway, I still loved my relatives and grieved that there were no longer  relationships. The way I gave up the hope was to, in my mind, think of them as if they were not there. The relationships were dead anyway. This might be a crummy way to cope, but it worked at the time and I no longer think of the relatives and grieve or think of them much at all. I guess I need to think of the happy times though...maybe that would just stir up the grief though... or maybe not after all these years... just some thoughts...

phoenix

  • Guest
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #4 on: November 09, 2004, 04:07:01 AM »
Dawning,

This is what I did with my onesided love. In the quiet of my heart and my own thoughts, I wished for him the best, for him to find the love he felt was right for his life. In loving enough to give him up  I was able to release myself. To continue to see him shortchanged myself, and kept him from having whatever it was he felt would be complete in his life. It hurt like hell, of course, but I was able to walk away with my dignity intact, and with still having the love in my heart. I didn't try to stop the feelings.

At age 37, I also had the misfortune to fall deeply in love with a married man. We both fell deeply in love. I walked away- actually I quit my job and moved two states away. That was difficult.

When I entered into another lesser relationship, because I too felt the pressure of passing time and loneliness, it was a total disaster.

I was at the grocery store this evening. I came upon a couple walking  with their arms around each other. It made me quite wistful. It has been a long time since I've had that. You can't fake that kind of connection. I hope I will never try to settle again. Take care, Phoenix

Dawning

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 344
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #5 on: November 09, 2004, 10:03:15 AM »
Hi again bunny.

Quote
When you're about to addictively pursue the man again, tell yourself, "He isn't my father and that's who I really want." And stop all contact with the ambivalent man. This is very difficult as it is "counter-intuitive" to you,


Ah, yes.  Very, very true.  I've been repeating this quote all day today.  Because what I hold on to in my heart is very similar, if not the same, to the feelings that I still hold for my dad.  All the contradictory messages, the insensitivity and the *hope.*  Hope is a hard thing to detach from.  Hoping that the person who gave you half your DNA will finally *wake up* and realize his responsibilties.  But he never will.  And I look around and see what appear to be very responsible parents who have raised children who are sure of what they want and don't feel the impulsiveness to deal with their pain in unhealthy ways.  Therapy in this city is hard to come by.  The last one was more like a drug pusher.  12-step programs don't exist.  There is one for sex addicts but I don't think of myself as a sex addict.  I don't crave it.  I guess if I crave anything, it is sharing my life with a like-minded person who wants to live with me and not contemplate his navel on his own (I seem to meet alot of the spiritual types who are *too young* or *too old* and aren't ready to live with someone.) Sorry, I'm whining now.  I never used to think that it was *his loss* - whoever *he* represents - because my father never seemed to feel - and certainly NEVER, EVER expressed - a loss of me.  It was almost as if he was happy to have me out of his life.  In his twisted mind, he probably confused me with my mother.  And my mother treated me as a nuisance when I was growing up unless we were having our picture taken together and then she *looked* full of love which I didn't feel coming from her.  

Hi flower.  Thanks for your response too.  

Quote
The way I gave up the hope was to, in my mind, think of them as if they were not there. The relationships were dead anyway. This might be a crummy way to cope, but it worked at the time and I no longer think of the relatives and grieve or think of them much at all. I guess I need to think of the happy times though...maybe that would just stir up the grief though... or maybe not after all these years... just some thoughts...


I admire that you have that much control over your thoughts.  What I think I need are more positive activities that stimulate my creativity and get me involved in tapping into my inner self and moving further and further away from the dark shadow of my parents.  Whenever I *think* at all, I just immediately go right back into the sense of loss, that there is something wrong with me (and this is very much a self-fulfilling prophecy as I set myself up with the last two persons who broke my heart) by refusing to see their actions as actions that truly, truly hurt me.  I did that a little the last time and PTSD was triggered.  It was awful.  But got me to a place where I remembered the awful things by father did to me.  And I wanted to share it with someone - so I reached out - too soon and in the wrong kind of environment.  

Quote
I kept reaching out to those relatives after they had made it clear by nonresponsiveness that they didn't want to socialize with me.


I am getting to the point where I can truly say that it is *their loss* when this happens.  But, goodness me, has it been a long, long road.  What I try to remember now is what I learned from these situations/encounters/relationships with mean family members and others.  One thing about the *slandering type* that I have learned is to consider the source.  Slandering people are usually insecure and do so for selfish reasons.  I write alot of hateful stuff - that I don't send to those people (or I voice it out here) but actually saying it is something different.  I just get so frustrated sometimes.  If I could be as stubborn and persistant about doing what I love as I am about not letting go of *hope* that I will get my childhood needs met,  I might still yet be happy.  I did find a place to order prozac from the USA and I'm waiting for it to arrive.  At this point, I *do* think I need a little help in the form of meds.  Just to get my serotonin up a little.  

Hi phoenix.

Quote
To continue to see him shortchanged myself, and kept him from having whatever it was he felt would be complete in his life.


Thanks for that.  Its very beautifully put.

Quote
I didn't try to stop the feelings


I understand about the value of this.  However, I am such an HSP that oftentimes my feelings overwhelm me and it has been like this most of my life to my detriment and times as I then begin to wallow and become unproductive.  I want to express them but in a more, shall we say, controlled way.  I'm curious to see if the prozac helps with this.  

Thanks also for sharing your other stories.  I can imagine how difficult it must have been to walk away.  I've never done that.  But I know people leave countries b/c of this and fly away.  

I also went out on a few dates late last year with a very lonely, divorced older fellow.  We had nothing in common.  I couldn't imagine living with him.  *Total disaster* is right.  But now...sometimes the fear of not being looked after really gets to me.  More inner child stuff.  I think I just need focus.  

Quote
It has been a long time since I've had that. You can't fake that kind of connection. I hope I will never try to settle again.


I hope you don't either.  Having things in common and proper conversations is really important to me.   It sad to let go of a love you want to express to someone.  And know that you may never, ever see them again.  I thought at my age that I would be in a fairly healthy relationships but I'm not.  

The image of letting go seems so painful t me. But I don't think one has to let go all at once.  I think we can build goals and work towards them and, in that, the letting go happens.  In the meantime, I can do things like initiate no contact with the *ambivalent man* and remind myself that it is really my father that I want.  I think that will get me to a good place.  (((bunny))))

This has been a long one and all over the place.  But, again, it helps to voice this whole thing.  ((((((((Hugs))))))

And one last thing...I've been having dreams this last day or two about being at concerts with the man in question.  I looked up *concerts* in my dream book and there was no entry there.  Does anyone know a place where dream interpretations are discussed or know what a concert image in a dream might mean?
"No one's life is worth more than any other...no sister is less than any brother...."

Avril

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 9
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #6 on: November 09, 2004, 10:47:11 AM »
Quote
Hope is a hard thing to detach from.

This is something I'm really struggling with at the moment:  giving up the hope that my NMum will ever be loving/nurturing/supportive-Mum.  I feel such a sense of loss.   :cry:   But it helps so much to have found this message board (found it a week ago).  Now I can share my feelings and learn from others who understand.  :)

Avril
Av

Avril

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 9
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #7 on: November 09, 2004, 10:48:32 AM »
Oops - not used to doing this!

Only the first line was a quote, the rest was my message!  See - lots to learn!
Av

BlueTopaz

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 113
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #8 on: November 09, 2004, 11:24:38 AM »
Instead of sharing the ways I feel the same, or offering any suggestions,
I just wanted to say how awesome you all are...

All comments on this thread, some other threads in general, and several members on this board, are like me looking directly into a mirror...   It is helpful beyond words, to know how much people are going through some of the same things, and also to read such insightful, incredibly wise advice/sharing...

For whatever other trying things that seem to be going on, on the board at this time, there are still some wonderful & helpful exchanges happening too...  

BT

flower

  • Guest
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #9 on: November 10, 2004, 01:46:58 AM »
Quote from: Avril


This is something I'm really struggling with at the moment:  giving up the hope that my NMum will ever be loving/nurturing/supportive-Mum.  I feel such a sense of loss.   :cry:   But it helps so much to have found this message board (found it a week ago).  Now I can share my feelings and learn from others who understand.  :)

Avril


Welcome Avril! It sure can be hard sometimes. Glad you are here. :)

flower

  • Guest
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #10 on: November 11, 2004, 04:12:23 AM »
Dawning,

Hope you are having a good day.

Thanks for your words above in response to my post. They were helpful to me.  :)

Dawning

  • Sr. Member
  • ****
  • Posts: 344
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #11 on: November 12, 2004, 10:54:21 PM »
Hello recent posters...

flower,

glad my words were helpful to you.  it took me a long time to learn that what these people were saying or thought of me was just a way for them to get their supply.  i am slowly starting to see that the whole world is not full of people like them but there are lots out there and i am learning to be discriminating.  its painful, i think, when it happens in your biological family because these people are *supposed* to love us.  And giving up on that is painful.  I've searched for this kind of unconditional love from others much too intensely over the last few years.  And then I began questioning what *love* is.  

what happened with my mother, was that she would withhold her love from me (at a very young age) as a control method.  then, I would start demanding it - (to survive?) - and I guess now when I like the person more than they like me, I can get demanding.  Its like a straight shot right back to my early childhood.  Like Phoenix said, you give up in the quiet of your heart and let go.  

The reality is the love *is* one-sided - coming from me.  And I was so used to this throughout my life that I would invent a fantasy to make the love mutual.  Even if the person was not around to meet my needs, I would *pretend* that they were.  This is *not* grounded in reality as bunny suggested.

the sense of loss must be mourned.  the emotional detachment must occur.

I don't think my expectations are unrealistic once I get into a relationship.  Its getting over the ones that are one-sided that potentially gets me in a rut and I feel like I was in one for most of my thrities so I am really into taking a pro-active approach these days even if that means I have to take meds.  

Btw, the prozac is working in the sense that I can stay focused on the here and now and not drift off into some land of melancholy and despair.  So that's good.  Yes, I do miss this guy.  I miss him alot.  I wonder what he is doing now and it hurts that he doesn't want to be with me but he's not my father and that's who I really want.

Avril, please talk more about your sense of loss here if it will help you.  I'm listening and so are the others, I reckon.   :)
"No one's life is worth more than any other...no sister is less than any brother...."

flower

  • Guest
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #12 on: November 13, 2004, 12:23:21 AM »
Quote from: Dawning
 its painful, i think, when it happens in your biological family because these people are *supposed* to love us.  And giving up on that is painful.  I've searched for this kind of unconditional love from others much too intensely over the last few years.  And then I began questioning what *love* is.


Hi Dawning,
Yes, like you said they are *supposed* to love us. I see that my parents' love = control.  Yesterday, we received a package from them with no message inside. Inside the package was a photo of my great grandmother and her sons. (dad's side of the family), a political periodical and some collectibles my mom keeps sending my children. I plainly told them to stop giving us gifts. They refuse to listen. It seemed almost silly of them. But they did break a boundary again. They do not respect me. I see that love has to have the element of respect to be healthy.  I told them once that they didn't respect me and they just had blank looks on their faces, like the word respect wasn't connected to me in any way.
 
Quote

what happened with my mother, was that she would withhold her love from me (at a very young age) as a control method.  


The same here. Sometimes, especially in the past,  I about suffocate when my husband doesn't respond to what I say, especially when I am sharing my heart.  I have been learning to give him space and not always expect a response.

A book that helped my husband and me was  "Men are from Mars, Women are from Venus." At least I saw that my husband was being "normal" when he had to retreat and spend time by himself. This guy time alone was hard for me to accept because it triggered the hurt I received by my mom - the old silent treatment. When I just let him be and have time in "his cave" he really responded and when he was there, he was really there for me.
He is learning that I sometimes need to just talk without him trying to fix things.

Quote

Btw, the prozac is working in the sense that I can stay focused on the here and now and not drift off into some land of melancholy and despair.  So that's good.  Yes, I do miss this guy.  I miss him alot.  I wonder what he is doing now and it hurts that he doesn't want to be with me but he's not my father and that's who I really want.


I'm happy the prozac is working! I almost went to get meds this down time I'm just crawling out of - exhaustion from stress, menopause stuff etc.

My sympathy goes out to your loss of this relationship. Some of us just feel things more deeply than others and take longer to get over things. I'm one of those people myself. I wish you all the best for your future relationship with that special someone. You deserve respect and an equal relationship.

JPBill

  • Newbie
  • *
  • Posts: 13
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #13 on: November 13, 2004, 11:44:18 AM »
Thankyou Dawning. I've been away from the site for a while, and being impatient and lazy only read some of this thread before I just had to respond.
For me, there is something at work inside that's not healthy, I know. Funny you wouild mention the loss of your father, for I Lost mine at age 5.
I have most of my life had a terrible time letting go of both lost, and hopeless loves. It seems the worst when I'm not taking care of myself and feeding myself with acceptance, friendship, and persuit of that for which I have passion, like my work, hobbies, etc that give me positive feelings. Stil though, to this day, I go there. I'm now separated from a girlfriend of three years, who was the inspiration for coming here. I've tried everything I know to win her trust, her interest, and compel her to open up to me, to offer up affection, attention, maybe words of encouragement and nurturing..Intimacy. Mutual friends who know the deal between us say "If she only could see.." I am pretty convinced she never will. Problem is, there are some things she does that put a crack in the firm belief that it's truely hopeless. Like her thoughtful birthday gifts, the occasional touch of her hand on mine when i'm driving. The words I lLove You when we say goodbye. The painful look on her face when I do not ask her to stay with me anymore when the weekend comes. Yet when we were together, it was always about her, her needs, her fears and worries, her accomplishments, opinions, etc.
Anyway, I'm beginning to feel pathologically addicted to grieving, a state I learned about at such an early age. The Bonnie Raitt song 'I Can't Make You Love Me" turns me into a sobbing fool, no matter where i am when i hear it. For it describes how this relationship has felt from day one.
I'm so thankful for this sight and the people like you on it, for it's here that I think I can see what I'm doing, and with each new revelation had reading the posts, see healthier decisions I can make about myself and about this relationship. For today, saturday, I'm still afraid of that hope, of how I'm going to hold my ground and not open up to having her over tonite. ugh.

Anonymous

  • Guest
unrequited love - why is it so hard?
« Reply #14 on: November 13, 2004, 12:45:50 PM »
JPBill said:

Quote
I'm now separated from a girlfriend of three years, who was the inspiration for coming here.


Quote
For today, saturday, I'm still afraid of that hope, of how I'm going to hold my ground and not open up to having her over tonite.


It doesn't sound like you are separated from your Ngf to me.  Separation from a narcissist partner has to be total, else you risk getting sucked back into the relationship.  Make it a clean break JP.