Oh, (((((Amber))))).
I can so imagine how painful this has been:
I feel like the whole "request" to dis-invite Buck from coming here was a huge ungrateful, betraying slap in my face. Couple that, with the implied criticism of my judgement, perception, and ability to take care of myself...
It's no wonder there's new distance between you and Hol. As horrible and strange as it must feel, perhaps in some way that feels "wrong" it's also "right." Intense closeness and too much analytics between parent and child can so backfire. I know my D (which isn't fully parallel but maybe in some small way) went nuclear and extreme to finally individuate herself, and in hindsight, I saw how much too involved and enmeshed I was...and how out of desperate anxiety over her well being as the bipolar deepened I advised too much, analysed too much, talked too much, and so forth. And in the long run none of my "helpful" wisdom saved her. Her being fully in charge of her own destiny hit me in the face like a dead fish, and I know her life is an enormous struggle to survive. Character wise, as I experienced how she'd treat me, and to me her entitlement and cruelty were huge disappointments and also my fault--I felt responsible for everything. I kept forgetting that she'd had TWO parents, and the influences that created her were partly me but also many others, including genes she could not help. She found and claimed her own highway and she is on it. Sometimes painful things happen in families no matter WHAT one's good intentions are.
I forgave her long back and forgive myself too, but I've never been through a more painful reckoning. You and Hol are very different people and I'm NOT thinking total estrangement will happen to you. But that is why (hope this isn't just pure projection, so take it all with a shaker of salt) I think a bit more distance between you would perhaps be healthy. When a child is one's biggest focus and biggest "project", stuff warps. Adult distancing and practicing regular boundaries keep things the right shape or help them re-shape into a more viable form.
You love her so much and your mountain compound dream has been full of love and energy and creativity. It may still turn out that way, or it may become a simpler "live near" kind of thing. A grandchild might still come along, or new friendships with people who live nearby, who can come out to visit post-covid and sit on the porch with you or you and Buck and talk and be your present friends. Your peers. I wish that for you.
Be good to yourself. You are not just building a rock wall, you're climbing one. One step at a time, keeping your balance, and trying to enjoy the climb itself...that's just about where you are.
Something I was perversely glad to read was you acknowledging how very much it has HURT, bringing you to tears. You sound always so knowledgeable and competent and in control and directing and planning...all of which is TRUE about you. But you seldom portray your vulnerable side, the simple hurt of being mistreated or misunderstood. Much less by the person you love most in this world.
I know what happened with Hol would really hurt my heart in your shoes. And I'm glad you're not suppressing that. You will heal and there's every chance you and Hol will eventually find new tracks individually that will result in your relationship working a lot better. But I don't think you can MAKE it happen. Once she is deeply into her own growing up, say in a few years maybe? (sorry!) she'll have more insight and maturity than she does now. Getting T will help and doing it entirely independently of you and not processing it with you would help even more. Girl's got to grow up.
I think a parent acknowledging their actual helplessness to steer their children's lives after a certain point (surely, age 40 is that point) -- releasing the outcome, is the only power we have left. Letting them go. Even in the most functional families, letting go is a gift. But it huuuuuuurts. It's a muscle we didn't know we had to use.
Oddly, that pain can lead to peace. Even relief.
Meanwhile, you and B deserve your own time, your own shared spaces, your own private happiness that is literally NO one's business but yours. I hope you won't discuss your relationship with B with Hol. I hope you will just live it.
And if she ever begins to comment on it again, I would Shut That Door firmly. More importantly, not open it in the first place. She'll share it with S or others in her entourage and it's not private and she is not your friend, she is your child. Likewise, if you can keep your talking about Hol to B as simple as you can for the sake of you both. He'll understand that bruise and be tender with it. But you don't want it to dominate your new beginning together.
Best of all, imo, would be whether or not Hol chooses to find a T, that YOU do. For yourself.
You've been through enough on your own.
hugs and comfort,
Hops