Author Topic: What is emotional incest ?  (Read 13326 times)

Chicken

  • Guest
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #15 on: September 10, 2005, 04:26:01 AM »
Hmmm....
I personally think he should get out of the bed if the teenage girl gets in!  I think it's not enough to just wear your pyjamas!  I mean we all heard the details about the Micheal Jackson case...  It's not safe for a man to be in bed with a young girl who is not his biological daughter, not in this day and age...

Sallying Forth

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 523
  • No longer a venture off the beaten path ...
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #16 on: September 10, 2005, 06:37:08 AM »
Hmmm....
I personally think he should get out of the bed if the teenage girl gets in!  I think it's not enough to just wear your pyjamas!  I mean we all heard the details about the Micheal Jackson case...  It's not safe for a man to be in bed with a young girl who is not his biological daughter, not in this day and age...

I second that. PJs and get out of that bed! Eek!

Also Joe make a second copy of the notes Jeni has kept and keep those in a safe deposit box. Never can be too cautious. Think like a "N" ... but don't become one. :)
The truth is in me.[/color]

I'm Sallying Forth on a new adventure! :D :D :D

David P

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 118
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #17 on: September 11, 2005, 04:10:12 AM »
Here is an update from Joe( and Jeni)
They had a huge donnybrook three days ago over a pile of simmering issues. Jeni left the house for two days with Kaya when Joe was absent and returned today to 'talk it out' with Joe.
She accused Joe of "wanting her all to himself" .
She also complained that some of the main reasons that she is unhappy are that "We do not have my friends over for dinner often enough" ( This is somehow Joe's fault) and that he does not do enough in the garden !
Jeni also reports that it bothers her that Kaya does not like him ! News to Joe ~

She refuses to go to a counselor and asked Joe to sleep in the guest room -oops! Not a good sign.

Joe is now on anti-depressants and told me this morning that recently he had begun to feel as if he had no control over his own life ," I feel like I am balancing on the edge of a waterfall -anytime I can fall over and  I feel helpless to prevent it".
He cannot reconcile the vast contradictions that he sees in her behavior.She was his princess a year ago and now he cannot believe that she is acting this way. What kind of person keeps a secret 'shame file' on their new husband while publicly acting as if she adored him( which I saw many times).  He is in a bad way and I think that it is going to get worse. He has no confidence in anything that she says and does not know what to do next and what to believe.
Some of your posts have mentioned that she is an Narcissist -maybe so but whatever she is, is not good..
Any tips for my bud?
BTW his father is also an Army officer - Major now retired. He and I lived on the same base when we were kids ..

David P

Chicken

  • Guest
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #18 on: September 11, 2005, 06:07:37 AM »
My only word of advice is to get out!
Easier said than done, but he needs to aim in that direction, start building up the courage, strength etc to finally make that move...
I would recommend counselling so that he can become aware of what a terror she is, he is probably blaming himself and is probably blind to her faults.  I think he needs to start educating himself on the situation he finds himself in, by reading, counselling and maybe even as introduction to this site? 

Wishing him the best of luck, he has a long road ahead of him...

longtire

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 564
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #19 on: September 11, 2005, 12:07:33 PM »
DavidP and Joe, I am sorry to hear what is going on in your situation right now.  It sounds like there may be some splitting going on, for you to go from great to horrible in her eyes.  It may help you to check out the book "Stop Walking on Eggshells" for information on Borderline PD and splitting and why it happens.  Of course, it sounds like there is even more going on in your situation.

The best thing you can do is trust your perceptions, what you see and hear, and trust your feelings.  Trust your own experience and what you observe, not what is said.  Do waht you need to do to take care of yourself in this terribly difficult situation and know that even though you haven't posted here directly that we are supportive and consider you "one of us."

God bless you and the kids.
longtire

- The only thing that was ever really wrong with me was that I used to think there was something wrong with *me*.  :)

amethyst

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 155
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #20 on: September 11, 2005, 03:34:03 PM »
Hi David, The reason that Joe feels loss of confidence and confusion is that he is being gaslighted by someone with evil intent. The fact that Jeni is unwilling to go to counseling is indicative of a severe personality disorder. She is very hardened in her ways and has NO intention of changing. I don't think she is a borderline, btw. I think she is a narcissist or worse. He needs to get out and get counseling to deal with all this.  Joe needs to understand that Jeni is incapable of loving anyone; her loving behaviour was an act, a sham and a manipulation.   Go Joe, go!

Amethyst

October

  • Guest
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #21 on: September 11, 2005, 06:17:58 PM »

Jeni was married for ten years to M an alcoholic -she paints a picture of herself as a long suffering wife doing her best to raise two children while M drank the profits and and neglected them.
There is something not kosher about her whole story.

He is stressed out and said yesterday that ,"this is not how marriage is supposed to be, nobody hears me."

David


Reading through all that has been written so far, I can see that the advice given is very good, and I would second it.  I would also like to add a bit on Jeni's behalf, though.  I do not see her behaviour as N.  More that of an abuse victim who is not aware of the impact of the abuse she has suffered.

I too was married for many years to an alcoholic.  Someone here said that it is never one sided.  Sometimes it is.  We all make mistakes, and we are all human, but anyone married to an alcoholic who tries to make that marriage work for year after year, and finally fails, will be damaged in the process.  The damage to me has left me with ptsd, and unable to form healthy relationships with available men.  I am fine with married or gay men, but single men really bring out the worst in me, and I become highly defensive and aggressive, both at the same time. 

Coupled with this, a major factor of my marriage was protecting my child from her father.  And the  need to do that breaks your heart at the same time as you know it is the only thing you can do.  Like the day I closed the door on my husband when he visited our daughter on her birthday when she was about 4 or 5, but he turned up drunk.  I would not let him into the house and closed the door on him, and she was distraught.  But what else could I do?  This kind of situation destroys the soul, piece by piece. 

Ultimately, the need to protect her from the abuses she faced helped me to see the abuses I suffered as well, and led to my deciding that a separation and divorce was essential for both her sake and mine.  I tried not to use her for emotional support, but the two of us were alone facing the world for such a long time, and we became very close.  I hope I did not resort to abusive behaviour, but I am sure the whole situation has had some kind of impact on her.  Certainly she can be anxious, and she can react badly to stress, as I can.

We are two separate people, and as she grows into a teenager she becomes more and more her own person, which is beautiful to see.  But there is also a core; a shared experience where she and I were all that was, and nothing else existed.  Maybe this is stronger for me than for her; she was so young, and had so much else apart from the nightmare that was her dad in the house.  She had school, and friends, and a life with much joy and happiness.  My own existence became less and less free and happy, and more and more defined by the experiences I had until much of my own self was destroyed.  Or perhaps lost might be a better way to describe it.  Mislaid.

I can imagine that a woman who has gone through similar experiences to mine, and who marries again, may well find that the feelings of defensiveness that she needed with her first husband, will come back with the second.  In fact, without therapy it may be inevitable.  Her learned behaviour will be that her children can be trusted, when men cannot, and she will continue to act out that learned behaviour until she is made conscious of the impact of this on the whole family. 

The abuses that this woman will be very sensistised to will be in the area of trust, betrayal, lying, stealing and perhaps also violence.  She will have learned not to trust her own senses, by being told that she is wrong about things she suspects to be true, and only when she finds actual evidence will her senses know that she is right.  This woman is highly damaged, and I would recommend that anyone who wants what is in her best interests and the best interests of her children would recognise this, and ask her to consider therapy because of the hidden impact of her abusive first marriage, which is leading to emotionally inappropriate behaviour now.

Therapy may also help her children; if the mother has been damaged, then the children are almost certainly also damaged.  Many of us are reluctant to enter therapy, but I doubt if many mothers would refuse if it were in their children's interests.

The journal is the key to this.  It shows that there is an inner tension in this woman; wanting to be happy in her marriage, but afraid that if she is not careful she will miss the signs that she missed the first time round.  So she writes down every small detail, hoping that this time she will find the clue in time, and not be hurt as she was hurt before.  I do not see that as a sign of narcissism.  Ns don't have the uncertainty and confusion that I feel from this woman, even at third hand.

This may all be projection, but I thought it was worth putting an alternative viewpoint.  I agree, however, that this man needs a lawyer, and needs PJs, and maybe also needs some space from this relationship for a while, so that both parties can work out what they really need for the future, and whether the other person is able to provide that for them or not.
« Last Edit: September 11, 2005, 06:32:27 PM by October »

amethyst

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 155
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #22 on: September 11, 2005, 08:54:55 PM »
((((October))))
Ah, but there is a huge difference between you and Jeni. You recognized how traumatic your marriage was and that it had damaged you. You realized you needed help and got it, also dealing with your earlier childhood trauma. You didn't lean on your daughter. You are allowing your daughter to have her own life and try out her wings without expecting her to fix you or be there for you, even in those times of depression and despair. Instead, you have taken the high road and are behaving as an adult. You and Jeni have victimization in common, but nothing else. 

Jeni is unwilling to get counseling. What does that say about her? Jeni has presented a loving face to Joe, but has kept a book of hate behind his back. What does that say about her? Jeni is incestuous with her children, using them. What does that say about her? Jeni is setting Joe up to take a horrible fall...and as far as I can see, Joe was a loving husband to his previous wife, who died, and has acted in a loving way with Jeni by willing to get counseling and work on things...yet Jeni does not want to. What Jeni has done, her refusal to even admit she needs help, smacks of someone that is getting so much benefit from her behavior and the power she derives from it that she is unwilling to change. I don't think she is a borderline, either; I think she is a full blown N (or worse) and that she is evil. A borderline would probably not send her husband to the spare room. I think Jeni has APD.

I am sure that Jeni was abused as a child and that her first marriage was awful, but she is not willing to do any of the footwork that it takes to heal and also to have a healthy relationship. The difference between you and Jeni is profound, as if the difference between the people on this board and the N's in their lives. No doubt all the N's have had trauma in their childhoods too. Despite, or because of their trauma, people like Jeni and the N's is identify with the abusers and take on abusive characteristics, take on the power of the abuser rather than admit that they might be abusive. They become very hardened....and narcissism, like alcoholism, is a progressive disease, which is why it gets worse with age. It is also the N's who will scream loudest about being victimized.

Lkie you, I was married to an alcoholic; he was more high functioning than most of them, but he could not go a day without drinking, and when he drank, watch out...he became more hateful and rageful than he was without the booze.   It took me a long time to realize that my ex was an alcoholic. He had a whole repertoire of addictive behaviors, including rageaholism, workaholism, being abusive, being cold, never admitting to any fault, taking off for the night or locking me out of the house if I disagreed with him...and he eventually  molested my daughter after I left him. My parents were alcoholic, so I am an ACOA, and I had an extremely traumatic childhood.  I went to Alanon first and then realized I had a problem with alcohol too, so I have also been in AA for years. Like you, I left my husband and realized like you that "The buck stops here." Yes, I was a victim, but like you, I realized that I was responsible for getting my life and my soul back together so I wouldn't pass it on. On the other hand, despite years of entreaties from me, my ex refused to get help. He has never been to counseling, except for one session we had together with our daughter's therapist, and he refused to see that therapist again because she told him that he was controlling, abusive and that he was refusing to let go of me, instead using our daughter as a pawn. My ex would be the first person to scream loud and long that he was a victim and he used his woundedness as another way to hook me in. My ex is an N and has APD. If he could get away with murder he would. His only fear is that of discovery. 

Like Jeni and you, I hung in for a long time. I didn't hang in simply because I am a hopeful, good, loyal and trustwothy person, although that played a part. I hung in for some selfish reasons like being scared to leave, economic security, not wanting to admit failure or that I had made a mistake, not wanting the world to know that I was being abused, not wanting to deal with my own issues and drinking problem. My ex could also be very charming and exciting to be around, and that hooked me in. After being terribly abusive, he would shower me with gifts, or we would take a trip to Europe...and that hooked me in. I also hung in because we had a beloved dog that I did not want to leave. I hung in because I was totally confused about reality; like many people, I looked really good on the outside and I was very invested in that. I didn't realize that truth often has very little to do with how things look. Even though I was in an awful situation, I was deriving some perceived benefits, so I didn't want to leave...until it got so bad that I could see that I was reliving my parents' marriage, which became glaringly obvious after we adopted our daughter. I also hung in because of the erroneous messages I had learned in my family and because I wrongly believed that I had the power to change others. (What a shock to discover I don't.... :shock:) When I left the marriage, I was shocked to discover that I had even taken on some of my ex's characteristics, like workaholism. I was a f*cked up mess. I don't see hanging in with an abuser and alcoholic as an act of courage and selflessness, but I have seen plenty of unrecovering co-alcoholics, both men and women, use it as a form of moral oneupsmanship. Hopefully, they will get past that and realize that it takes two to tango. 

I remarried several years later after intensive work on myself. One of my major tasks in the new marriage was not to bring the garbage from my first marriage into the relationship with my new hubby. There were times when it would have been very easy to do that. Right after the wedding, I got this overwhelming feeling of being trapped and had the urge to run...and I had to work very hard to realize that it was coming from my own past trauma and had nothing to do with my husband. 

I don't know if full-blown narcissists can ever get well and it is not the responsibility of someone who is involved with an N to stick around to find out, despite the fact that narcissisits were victimized kids.  I know that alcoholism is curable...and that alcoholics were victimized kids. I don't think the victims of a practicing alcoholic need to stick around to find out if they will sober up and change, either.  I know that PTSD is curable, but once again, I don't think that anyone needs to hang in if they are being victimized by the woundedness of someone with PTSD.. We know that BPDs were victimized kids and some of them are curable, if they are willing to do whatever it takes, but nobody should have to hang in with the crazy behavior of someone with full blown BPD.  In any case, when people use their wounding, their past traumas, to remain a victim and therefor hurt others, why hang around?

 However, as I have said several times, I don't think Jeni has BPD.  I believe that anyone who is incestuous with children or who uses kids sexually has APD, which I know is not curable. Jeni is using her kids in a sexual way. I don't think Jeni can be helped. It's too bad about the kids, but Joe needs to save himself.  If Joe hangs in because of the kids, or because Jeni was a victim in the past, which she will probably use as a hook, he will be destroyed. 

 

Plucky

  • Hero Member
  • *****
  • Posts: 800
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #23 on: September 11, 2005, 09:45:33 PM »
David P,
Joe needs to come up on this board and read about everyone else's experiences to get a perspective.  Is it really working to do this secondhand?
Plucky

David P

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 118
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #24 on: September 12, 2005, 05:33:45 AM »
OK -thanks guys, I will ask Joe if he can type and join in here.
I got my own problemo with my parents to handle soon,too.
DavidP.

October

  • Guest
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #25 on: September 12, 2005, 06:48:42 AM »
((((October))))
Ah, but there is a huge difference between you and Jeni.

You may well be right.  On the other hand, it may be that Jeni is on the same path as I am, only a few years further back than me.  I may now realise the damage and be seeking help, but there was (for all of us) a time before this, when I was not, and when what I needed was a direction and compassion, rather than condemnation for not being other than where I was.  So all I am saying is, there is another side to this, which we are not yet hearing.

I know I would certainly not allow (nor would she herself!!) my 12 year old daughter naked in bed with any man, even her own father, let alone a stepfather, but I also know that people have different ideas about the meaning of nudity within a family.  I don't think we can necessarily deduce sexual abuse from such information, especially when we know so little.  It could well be major boundary violation and enmeshment.  But it could just possibly be a family environment which is relaxed about nudity.  Same with handholding and use of endearments.  I call my daughter darling, dear, poppet, angel, lovey; all sorts of things.  Intimacy of language does not necessarily equate to inappropriate intimacy of behaviour. 

I know a lot of what she is doing does resonate with me, and I can see myself in her.  Beyond that, I am not able to say anything about what her state of mind might or might not be, apart from traumatised.  There but for the Grace of God go I.

What I can be certain of is that I am very sorry to hear about your terrible experiences, and I am full of admiration for your strength and resilience.  ((((((hugs)))))

CeeMee

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 139
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #26 on: September 12, 2005, 12:48:03 PM »
October wrote:

On the other hand, it may be that Jeni is on the same path as I am, only a few years further back than me.  I may now realise the damage and be seeking help, but there was (for all of us) a time before this, when I was not, and when what I needed was a direction and compassion, rather than condemnation for not being other than where I was.  So all I am saying is, there is another side to this, which we are not yet hearing.

October, I couldn't agree with you more on this point.  I have been the condemnor because people weren't where I thought they should be in their journey.  I've learned there are people who still have a long way to go and there are people who are light years ahead of me, and so I still have lots of work to do. 

And yes, we usually get only one perspective, from which we cannot know the whole story.  When we don't have the whole story, it is very human to project or attribute negatives. 

One reason I continue on this board (even though I have the very tendencies that members have been victimized by) is to give readers another perspective.  I want to know the victim better to help me in my recovery process.  Maybe some victims or voiceless can learn something from my posts that can help them with theirs.

CeeMee

October

  • Guest
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #27 on: September 12, 2005, 04:02:18 PM »

October, I couldn't agree with you more on this point.  I have been the condemnor because people weren't where I thought they should be in their journey.  I've learned there are people who still have a long way to go and there are people who are light years ahead of me, and so I still have lots of work to do. 

CeeMee


Thanks CeeMee.  I think I come here because there are lots of those 'light years ahead of me' people to be found here.   :lol:

I have a tendency in life to be far too critical and judgemental of everyone around me - you know, like when every other road user is an idiot and shouldn't be allowed on the roads at the same time as me.  I am struggling against this particular Ntrait in my life, to exchange it for acceptance and giving space to others to be who they are, even if they are terrible drivers.   :lol:  This thinking contaminates a lot of who I am, and I am trying to root it out bit by bit, but it is very, very difficult, and mostly I fail.  Pretty well always, but I am starting to try not to.

CeeMee

  • Full Member
  • ***
  • Posts: 139
Re: What is emotional incest ?
« Reply #28 on: September 13, 2005, 01:49:31 AM »
October, 

Hang in there.  I know what you mean.  You are not alone, but you may be amongst the few who recognize this trait and seek to change it.  Catching yourself at something as simple as raging at another driver is one small step.  That's how change happens I believe.  It is not this monumental event that transforms you.  Rather, it is a series of efforts we put forth until eventually it starts to come naturally.  Of course, old habits can rear their ugly heads at any moment and that's why we must continually strive to be our true selves.

CeeMee