Tupp:
My friend's dh was about 12 years older..... very sweet and his language of love was the same as mine.... acts of service.
I THINK he felt a bit defensive about ME doing the things he wanted to do for her and their new home, as well as a bit shamed by the fact he was a procrastinator, which my friend and I understood and stepped around so as not to hurt him. There would come a time when she'd say..... I NEED this or that done, so we're going to press it this trip.... like her and I painting the trim, me caulking around the double oven or ripping out the bedroom built ins...... she'd give me the wink or have a word earlier.
If she was still hemming and hawing about pushing something, as to avoid upsetting her beloved, and he was beloved and cherished by her.... he felt the same about her...... I'd offr to do something then let it go if he said NO, not now, I'll get it, which he normally did, reflexively.
I also want to say he had 6 Catholic sisters and a very strong mother, so it was super easy to overwhelm him with what was large female energy aimed at him. Certainly, I hid my light a little less than my friend, who was invested in being cherished and cared for in a traditional way, even though she earned as much as him and was every inch his equal..... she wanted the traditional marriage they agreed on and built.
Had he been a beligerant drunk..... I'm sure I would have said it in front of her, where he couldn't hear, and hoped she sorted it out herself. HAD SHE CONTINUED to put up with behavior I couldn't put up with.....I would likely have spoken my piece then removed myself, as you did.
From that point on..... it would be difficult to continue listening to the friend complain, let her talk then bounce over it without giving advice, even if asked for. Once I get the feeling I've said everything I had to say 10X or more..... I need to say it a different way OR just remain compassionate listener if it doesn't compromise my own mental health. I think it does, at times.
I'm learning just how important boundaries are, bc I think it builds a framework of safety for me..... takes the guess work out, awkward moments and most of all..... any mystification around what's happening in a relationship like this.
I know it takes me a while to GET a lot of concepts, particualrly when my heart and nervouse system are involved. I don't want people I respect and care for to give up on me...... I also don't want them to stop trying to help me understand something I truly would benefit from understanding. Since I sometimes have to hear something 5 different ways to understand and internalize it..... I think about presenting information differently, or accepting the person just isn't ready to make a change.... and that has to be OK too.
It's OK for your friend to carry on with the pig. That's not your job.
What IS your job is to state your boundaries, the consequences of not honoring them and then follow through without hesitation if the boundary is breeched. You don't have to be around the pig, for instance, but you also don't have to listen to her complain endlessly, to the exclusion of all else, over and over again after you've said everything you can think to say...... more than once, IME.
If you can think of a way to say it..... differently..... maybe your friend hears something that pings for her. Other than that, it's not good for you to force yourself to sit silently and endure the complaints, IME. You can say that, with compassion, while restating your concern.....
she's worthy of better... better treatment, of safety, a reciprocal relationship with a partner and.....
maybe this is the most difficult to wrap one's mind around.....
of feeling safe and at home in her own skin without a man in her life.
You can't save her from herself. Sometimes I understood a message when people stopped trying to convince me and let me feel the weight of carryng a bad relationship on my own....... once I understood they were done trying to save me, I freaked out and ended one of my relationships, bc I was suddenly alone...... everyone around me stopped stepping up and making me feel they were helping me carry the responsibility. They did it with shrugs.....
"We guess you really do love this unstable, violent man. Let us know how that works out for you."
BAM! like a lightening bolt..... I got it. All their words and reasons did NOTHING to convince me where stepping back.... did.
Hops:
I've learned a lot about myself, how I view women and about my friend..... my own family... dysfunction and how important boundaries are. How simple everything gets if we know what they are, use them and enforce them. It's been a process and all the fear, obligation and guilt built into my nervous system has to be quieted long enough to pull pieces out of the eair and get an eye ball on them, IME.
Learning how to be gentle with myself and TRY to stop judging is part of figuring out things I've nevr made sense of before. Getting comfortable with acceptance is certainly helpful. Such a relief..... like putting down a big weight I never had to carry and resisting the urge to judge myself for picking it up or my parents for not teaching me to do better.
My sister and I spoke anout all this earlier and decided our parents DID model healthy boundaries a lot of the time. They were mixd in with dysfunction and difficult to tease out, unfortunately.
Like I said....my parents did what they could, regarding my traveling with little kids, then released outcome. I might still need a text or 3 rings, bc I would be the person who sent out the search crew IF someone I loved needed help. I'll always be that person, even if I need to find healthier ways to express it..... and remain authentically myself. I get to do what's important to me and I know depending on exterior things to be at peace isn't helpful. I'm striving for balance, here. Likely always will.
About your friend.... you are committed to deep listening, but it shouldn't cost you your equilibrium. For me, that's about balance, again. I think it helps our loved ones when we're able to be compassionate AND honest. Show them how to say difficult things without inflicting more harm..... maybe they can use that particular skill to help solve the BIG problem they've been dealing with through the years without change?
Interesting you talk about my friend "going flat."
My thoiughts are..... she knows me well and has listened to me shift into default savior problem solver mode...... and I move fast, fix and clean and suggest things she's already thought of..... it's frustrating for her, or anyone, to BE at the end of that, IME. I know, bc my sister aims that fixer/savior/clean work SERVE reactivity at me....
and I recognize going flat, myself. It's a defense mechanism. I can block my sister's efforts more quickly, shut down her reaction and steer things back to things I CAN solve or work on or address without dissociating. Maybe it's..... just losing all ability to pretend, Hops.
I want to say I haven't figured out all the fine mechanics of being nice, keeping things flowing, making things OK..... esp in social settings where I used to NEEEEED everyone to get along and create good memories for the kids..... whatever or wherever we are.
We're all grown arsed adults now. It's time everyone learn how to state a boundary appropriately, enforce it and not blow everything up or go flat or take heads, IMO.
My father was a taker of heads. My mother was too, come to think of it. Golden Children. They were scoffers and laughed and ridiculed and I don't like it.It doesn't belong in relationships I care about and I'm working on creating new languages.... for asserting boundaries with love...... but asserting without compromise when necessary.
I'm brought face to face with consequences..... your friend and Tupp's friend likely fear losing their relationships with the problematic men in their lives. They're not just thinking about what they deserve or are worthy of... they aren't thinking about teaching people how to treat us..... they're likely thinking about losing those relationships, of being alone, of what that fear will feel like and that brings up mor and more fear, IME.
WhenI think about my friend and my family..... I have to accept also the consequences of doing so. I might not get what I need or deserve. I might get shut down and told I'll never be honored or respected in the way I require.
There's the possibility relationships and family will change in drastic ways I didn't intend or want to live with.
There's the possibility I'll be cut out, or discarded or abandoned...I chose those words, bc I think those are the words my nervous system would choose when fear''s driving my boat.
If I'm relaxed and thinking clearly..... I might not receive peace or respectful treatment over boundaries, but I see alternatives.... not endings to relationships I value. There can be all sorts of solutions, when I can see what's there and not worry into the future or ruminate int he past.
Your friend and Tupp's friend.... might always be stuck in past or present and NOT be able to problem solve creatively. Maybe that's the biggest problem....not the men, who'd likely be turned in for similar men IF the freind's don't figure out the root of the problems..... or symptoms, IMO.
If I allow a man to behave badly, and I don't require better or remove myself....
if I continue living with an abuser.....
if I make excuses and allow bad treatment......
that's a different problem than adjusting my expectations in a difficult relationship.
Understanding I'm free to require better treatment is different than doing it while feeling safe and confident enough to be on my own.
In order to GET what I deserve, I have to state my boundaries AND consequences I'm willing to follow through with........
maybe I have to first accept the possibility the relationship would end..... being alone/losing the upsetting relationship would have to be something I've made peace with and that's a whole nuther piece of the puzzle. Some people would never leave a relationship, ever... esp a marriage they're committed to.
in that case, they have to learn a new language of self care, I think. Of acceptance and withdrawing with love in order to find their own peace and joy and emotional distance within the chaos of the relationship.
I accepted my friend wasn't willing to push beyond a certain point with her dh. She and I had an understanding about her dh's procrastination, which got much worse in the year his health began declining. I'm glad she was gentle with his ego. I loved him too...he was kind and gentle and a truly good human being. They deserved the tenderness they extended to each other.
But whew..... the condo needed attention..... the HVAC vents and plumbing and more caulking..... it was good for my soul, bc it allowed me to express my love..... acts of service. The thing is..... I can't always DO and act and fix.
I look for balance with recommitting to compassionate listening too.
I know it's necessary and good and right, but it can't cost me my own stability. There have to be limits. Boundaries are good.
I spoke to my friend today and didn't talk about all the things I shared with my sister about this stuff.
I don't need to have this chat with her and she has a lot on her plate. I might bring up the conflict over my touching the fridge, and I get it. I wouldn't want her to touch all my little piles either, when I think about it. I'll own what's mine, explain why I do some of the things I do, why I want to change them and what I'm working towards so she understands we don't have a problem between us.
I have a problem figuring out how to assert boundaries, discern the difference between greasing social wheels...... overstepping..... reacting vs responding.
She did nothing wrong. Going flat is and was a necessary reaction to boundaries being stepped on, IME. Yes, compassionately speaking about the boundaries would be prefereable, but we do what we have to do to protect ourselves.
We do better when we know how.
I want to end this with a time I told this friend "don't do that," very calmly when she went flat with me over something I couldn't fix. I made a suggestion. She went flat and took my head.... a small snarky taking, btw. I simply met her gaze and stated that boundary... "don't do that."
She stopped. Simple. We went back to having a lovely dinner in a lovely restaurant.... in our twenties at the time.
There was a time we DID handle things more quickly, more effectively, but we're carrying so much baggage by now.... the kids, the marriages, the siblings the parents.... Lord...... sometimes it's hard to find the thread.
If we had healthy boundaries in place..... things would have been so much easier, IMO.
Lighter